Table 1 Characteristics of 24 included systematic reviews

From: An umbrella review of efficacy of digital health interventions for workers

First Author, publication year

Total number of individual studies, n

Number of individual studies included in each review, n (%)

Population

Setting

Intervention and control

Outcome

AMSTAR 2 score

Buckingham et al.12

25

24 (96)

Workers

Workplace

I: m-Health interventions to promote PA and SB

C: Not specified

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes (e.g., weight, BMI, and waist circumference), and others (e.g., quality of life and work performance)

Low

Cotie et al.19

60

7 (12)

Working-age females

Not specified

I: d-Health interventions to increase PA and improve obesity-related outcomes

C: Not specified

PA-related (MVPA) and physiological outcomes

Critically low

Antoun et al.24

34

1 (3)

Adults

Not specified

I: Weight loss intervention using a smartphone application with or without combination of non-mobile intervention

C: Not specified

Weight

Critically low

De Leon et al.25

55

2 (4)

Mixed populations

Not specified

I: Periodic messaging interventions to promote health behavior, including PA, smoking, and others

C: Not specified

PA-related outcomes, smoking, and diet, among others

Critically low

Freak-Poli et al.26

15

11 (73)

Workers

Workplace

I: Interventions used interactive or non-interactive pedometers to promote PA

C: Any intervention without a pedometer or no intervention

PA-related and SB-related outcomes, cardiovascular disease risk factors, quality of life, and adverse effects

High

Howarth et al.13

22

6 (27)

Workers

Workplace

I: d-Health interventions to improve health-related outcomes

C: Not specified

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., mental health, sleep quality)

Critically low

Jung and Cho27

8

8 (100)

Workers

Not specified

I: m-Health interventions to promote PA and weight loss

C: Did not receive any intervention that used mobile phones

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes

Critically low

Lee et al.28

11

11 (100)

Workers with obesity

Not specified

I: d-Health interventions to reduce weight

C: Not specified

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, exercise testing)

Critically low

Morrow et al.29

9

2 (22)

Workers (Obese healthcare staff)

Workplace

I: Interventions focused on PA or diet

C: Usual care or standardized advice

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, blood pressure)

Low

Ogilvie et al.30

48

1 (2)

Mixed population

Not specified

I: Any interventions to promote walking

C: No intervention, attention control, or minimal intervention

PA-related outcome (Specific measures of walking)

Critically low

Ramezani et al.31

39

20 (51)

Workers

Workplace

I: Workplace interventions to increase PA

C: Not specified

PA-related outcomes

Critically low

Reed et al.32

24

13 (54)

Female workers

Workplace

I: Workplace interventions to increase PA and cardiometabolic health

C: Not specified

PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., blood testing)

Low

Robert et al.20

70

1 (1)

Middle-aged and older adults

Not specified

I: d-Health nutritional interventions to optimize nutrition

C: Not specified

PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, quality of life)

Critically low

Sevic et al.14

17

15 (88)

Workers

Not specified

I: d-Health interventions to improve health behavior

C: A non-d-health intervention (waitlist, usual care, or active control)

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., blood pressure, alcohol consumption)

Low

Shrestha et al.33

34

12 (35)

Workers

Workplace

I: Workplace interventions to reduce SB

C: No intervention or other interventions

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., blood pressure, work performance)

High

Spaulding et al.34

24

1 (4)

Mixed population

Not specified

I: Interventions used smartphone applications for preventing cardiovascular diseases

C: Not specified

PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, blood pressure)

Low

Szinay et al.35

16

1 (6)

Mixed population

Not specified

I: m-Health interventions to promote weight-related behaviors

C: Not specified

Physiological outcomes

Moderate

Taylor et al.36

6

5 (83)

Workers (predominantly engaging in desk-based occupation)

Workplace

I: Interventions used computer prompts to reduce SB and increase PA

C: No intervention or other interventions

PA-related and SB-related outcomes

Critically low

Willmott et al.37

24

1 (4)

Young adults

Not specified

I: d-Health interventions for weight management

C: Not specified

Physiological outcomes

Critically low

Parés-Salomón et al.15

19

17 (89)

Workers (Office-based employees)

Not specified

I: A d-Health element as part of interventions to reduce SB

C: No intervention or other interventions

SB-related outcomes

Critically low

Lassen et al.38

14

1 (7)

Workers (people working irregular hours or extended working hours)

Workplace

I: Interventions focused on developing a healthy working environment to improve dietary habits and/or increase PA

C: Not specified

PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, mental health, sleep)

Critically low

Payne et al.39

24

1 (4)

Mixed population

Not specified

I: Interventions used any mobile applications

C: Not specified

PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, alcohol consumption)

Critically low

Widmer et al.40

51

7 (14)

Mixed population

Not specified

I: d-Health interventions for cardiovascular disease prevention

C: Usual care, non-d-Health interventions, no active intervention

Physiological outcomes and others (e.g., blood pressure, cholesterol)

Critically low

Zheng et al.41

34

10 (29)

Mixed population

Not specified

I: m-Health interventions focused on PA, diet, and mental health.

C: Not specified

PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, mental health)

Critically low

Total

683

182 (27)

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

  1. AMSTAR 2 the revised MeaSurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews, C control d-Health, digital health I, intervention, m-Health mobile health, MVPA moderate to vigorous physical activity, NA not applicable, O outcome, P population, PA physical activity, SB sedentary behavior.