Table 1 Characteristics of 24 included systematic reviews
From: An umbrella review of efficacy of digital health interventions for workers
First Author, publication year | Total number of individual studies, n | Number of individual studies included in each review, n (%) | Population | Setting | Intervention and control | Outcome | AMSTAR 2 score |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Buckingham et al.12 | 25 | 24 (96) | Workers | Workplace | I: m-Health interventions to promote PA and SB C: Not specified | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes (e.g., weight, BMI, and waist circumference), and others (e.g., quality of life and work performance) | Low |
Cotie et al.19 | 60 | 7 (12) | Working-age females | Not specified | I: d-Health interventions to increase PA and improve obesity-related outcomes C: Not specified | PA-related (MVPA) and physiological outcomes | Critically low |
Antoun et al.24 | 34 | 1 (3) | Adults | Not specified | I: Weight loss intervention using a smartphone application with or without combination of non-mobile intervention C: Not specified | Weight | Critically low |
De Leon et al.25 | 55 | 2 (4) | Mixed populations | Not specified | I: Periodic messaging interventions to promote health behavior, including PA, smoking, and others C: Not specified | PA-related outcomes, smoking, and diet, among others | Critically low |
Freak-Poli et al.26 | 15 | 11 (73) | Workers | Workplace | I: Interventions used interactive or non-interactive pedometers to promote PA C: Any intervention without a pedometer or no intervention | PA-related and SB-related outcomes, cardiovascular disease risk factors, quality of life, and adverse effects | High |
Howarth et al.13 | 22 | 6 (27) | Workers | Workplace | I: d-Health interventions to improve health-related outcomes C: Not specified | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., mental health, sleep quality) | Critically low |
Jung and Cho27 | 8 | 8 (100) | Workers | Not specified | I: m-Health interventions to promote PA and weight loss C: Did not receive any intervention that used mobile phones | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes | Critically low |
Lee et al.28 | 11 | 11 (100) | Workers with obesity | Not specified | I: d-Health interventions to reduce weight C: Not specified | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, exercise testing) | Critically low |
Morrow et al.29 | 9 | 2 (22) | Workers (Obese healthcare staff) | Workplace | I: Interventions focused on PA or diet C: Usual care or standardized advice | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, blood pressure) | Low |
Ogilvie et al.30 | 48 | 1 (2) | Mixed population | Not specified | I: Any interventions to promote walking C: No intervention, attention control, or minimal intervention | PA-related outcome (Specific measures of walking) | Critically low |
Ramezani et al.31 | 39 | 20 (51) | Workers | Workplace | I: Workplace interventions to increase PA C: Not specified | PA-related outcomes | Critically low |
Reed et al.32 | 24 | 13 (54) | Female workers | Workplace | I: Workplace interventions to increase PA and cardiometabolic health C: Not specified | PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., blood testing) | Low |
Robert et al.20 | 70 | 1 (1) | Middle-aged and older adults | Not specified | I: d-Health nutritional interventions to optimize nutrition C: Not specified | PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, quality of life) | Critically low |
Sevic et al.14 | 17 | 15 (88) | Workers | Not specified | I: d-Health interventions to improve health behavior C: A non-d-health intervention (waitlist, usual care, or active control) | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., blood pressure, alcohol consumption) | Low |
Shrestha et al.33 | 34 | 12 (35) | Workers | Workplace | I: Workplace interventions to reduce SB C: No intervention or other interventions | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., blood pressure, work performance) | High |
Spaulding et al.34 | 24 | 1 (4) | Mixed population | Not specified | I: Interventions used smartphone applications for preventing cardiovascular diseases C: Not specified | PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, blood pressure) | Low |
Szinay et al.35 | 16 | 1 (6) | Mixed population | Not specified | I: m-Health interventions to promote weight-related behaviors C: Not specified | Physiological outcomes | Moderate |
Taylor et al.36 | 6 | 5 (83) | Workers (predominantly engaging in desk-based occupation) | Workplace | I: Interventions used computer prompts to reduce SB and increase PA C: No intervention or other interventions | PA-related and SB-related outcomes | Critically low |
Willmott et al.37 | 24 | 1 (4) | Young adults | Not specified | I: d-Health interventions for weight management C: Not specified | Physiological outcomes | Critically low |
Parés-Salomón et al.15 | 19 | 17 (89) | Workers (Office-based employees) | Not specified | I: A d-Health element as part of interventions to reduce SB C: No intervention or other interventions | SB-related outcomes | Critically low |
Lassen et al.38 | 14 | 1 (7) | Workers (people working irregular hours or extended working hours) | Workplace | I: Interventions focused on developing a healthy working environment to improve dietary habits and/or increase PA C: Not specified | PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, mental health, sleep) | Critically low |
Payne et al.39 | 24 | 1 (4) | Mixed population | Not specified | I: Interventions used any mobile applications C: Not specified | PA-related, SB-related, and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, alcohol consumption) | Critically low |
Widmer et al.40 | 51 | 7 (14) | Mixed population | Not specified | I: d-Health interventions for cardiovascular disease prevention C: Usual care, non-d-Health interventions, no active intervention | Physiological outcomes and others (e.g., blood pressure, cholesterol) | Critically low |
Zheng et al.41 | 34 | 10 (29) | Mixed population | Not specified | I: m-Health interventions focused on PA, diet, and mental health. C: Not specified | PA-related and physiological outcomes, and others (e.g., diet, mental health) | Critically low |
Total | 683 | 182 (27) | NA | NA | NA | NA | NA |