Table 1 Comparison of different genome editing systems in cyanobacteria

From: Development of a base editor for convenient and multiplex genome editing in cyanobacteria

 

Conventional

Cas9

Cpf1 (Cas12a)

Base editor

Editing method

Homologous recombination

Cas9-induced DSB and homologous recombination

Cpf1-induced DSB and homologous recombination

Deaminase-mediated base conversion, no DSB

Typical length of procedure

From 3 weeks to several months until segregation

From 9 days to a few weeks until segregation

From 9 days to a few weeks until segregation

From 9 days to a few weeks until segregation

Cloning steps

Multiple

Multiple

Multiple

One step

Editing effect

Deletion, insertion, and mutation

Deletion, insertion, and mutation

Deletion, insertion, and mutation

Base mutation

Completeness of gene knockout

100%

100%

100%

<100%

Homology arm

Needed

Needed

Needed

Not needed

Multiplex editing

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Toxic to cyanobacteria

Low

Relatively high

Low

Low