Table 5 The effect of non-benzodiazepine receptor agonists on daytime impairment symptoms by domain and ontology

From: Medical ontology learning framework to investigate daytime impairment in insomnia disorder and treatment effects

Endpoint Ontology

Number of daytime impairment symptoms [events per 100 patient years]a

Percentage increase in endpoint after treatment ± SD (P-value)b

Before treatment

During treatment

Average treatment effect [95% CI]

All domains

ICD-clin

16.1

23.2

7.0 [−3.2, 17.3]

43.5% ± 253.9% (P = 0.002)

ICD-clin-DiSMOL

56.0

84.0

28.4 [13.1, 43.7]

50.1% ± 377.8% (P < 0.001)

DiSMOL

129.1

149.8

20.7 [2.6, 38.9]

16.0% ± 449.3% (P = 0.001)

Cognition domain

ICD-clin

16.1

23.2

7.0 [−3.2, 17.3]

43.5% ± 253.9% (P = 0.002)

ICD-clin-DiSMOL

30.7

38.6

8.2 [−3.2, 19.5]

25.5% ± 280.1% (P = 0.008)

DiSMOL

89.4

103.8

14.4 [0.2, 28.6]

16.1% ± 352.0% (P = 0.003)

Emotional domain

ICD-clin

15.9

22.7

6.8 [−3.4, 17.1]

43.0% ± 253.5% (P = 0.002)

ICD-clin-DiSMOL

29.7

51.4

21.1 [11.0, 31.1]

72.9% ± 249.9% (P < 0.001)

DiSMOL

78.7

95.7

17.0 [2.8, 31.2]

21.6% ± 352.1% (P = 0.001)

Physical domain

ICD-clin

16.0

22.9

6.9 [−3.3, 17.1]

43.2% ± 253.6% (P = 0.002)

ICD-clin-DiSMOL

20.7

25.6

4.9 [−5.7, 15.5]

23.6% ± 260.3% (P = 0.036)

DiSMOL

105.8

118.4

12.5 [−3.4, 28.5]

11.8% ± 395.3% (P = 0.016)

  1. None-benzodiazepines were found to significantly increase daytime impairment symptoms across all domains (P-values ≤ 0.016) when assessed using DiSMOL. When evaluated with ICD-clin and ICD-clin-DiSMOL, non-benzodiazepines were associated with a significant worsening of symptoms across cognitive, emotional, and physical domains (P-values ≤ 0.002). However, impairment increases reported by ICD-clin and ICD-clin-DiSMOL were substantially higher than those observed with DiSMOL alone.
  2. CI confidence interval, DiSMOL Disease-Specific Medical Ontology Learning, ICD International Classification of Diseases, ns not significant, SD standard deviation.
  3. aThe follow up period was from 182 days before treatment to approximately 3 months (mean) during treatment.
  4. bAn increase shows worsening of daytime functioning (more daytime impairment symptoms) after treatment compared with before treatment, while a decrease shows an improvement in daytime functioning (fewer daytime impairment symptoms).