Table 1 Comparison table with state of the art literature

[14]

Ku

15.5-16.5

≥85%

≤60^o

17.4–18.35

5.31%

12.88–13.57

5.21%

6 =  0.280λ_o

2 = 0.093λ_o

[15]

Ku

12.05-17.9

≥80%

≤45^o

11.3–11.5

1.7%

-

-

6.6 =  0.308λ_o

1.2 =  0.056λ_o

[16]

X, Ku

8.32-17.55

≥93%

≤45^o

7.42–7.68

3.44%

-

-

7.8 =  0.32λ_o

2.57 =  0.10λ_o

[17]

C, X, Ku

6.46-6.78 10.52-11.85 16.49-17.37

≥90%

≤45^o

7.28–9.40

25.4%

13.38–15.19

12.6%

8 =  0.30λ_o

1.60 =  0.061λ_o

[18]

C, X, Ku

4.3, 7.2,12.3 15.15

≥90%

≤15^o

4.75–5.95 14.35-14.6

22.4%1.7%

8.35–8.8

5.2%

11 =  0.333λ_o

3.2 =  0.098λ_o

[19]

C, X, Ku

7.2-10.51 15.81-17.48

≥90%

≤30^o

12.54–13.76

9.2%

6.78–6.89 18.39-18.82

1.6% 2.3%

7 =  0.291λ_o

2.4 = 0.1λ_o

[20]

Ku, K

-

-

≤45^o ≤ 30^o

15.25–18.9

21.37%

29.7–36.7

21.08%

5.20 =  0.45λ_o

0.3 = 0.26λ_o

[21]

X, Ku, K

12.35-17.8

≥80%

≤50^o

10.85–11.05 21.85-27.40

1.82% 22.53%

12.35–17.8

36.15%

5.94 =  0.35λ_o

1.6 =  0.096λ_o

[22]

Ku, K, Ka

-

-

≤45^o

15–21.2

34.3%

27–30.3

11.5%

2.8 =  0.23λ_o

1.032 =  0.169λ_o

[23]

K, Ka

-

-

≤45^o

19.7–20.2

2.50%

27–30.3

1.68%

5.3 =  0.44λ_o

1.05 =  0.08λ_o

[24]

C,X,Ku

-

-

≤30^o

10.3–14.73

35.39%

8.34–8.71

4.34%

11 =  0.45λ_o

1.6 = 0.06λ_o

This work

Ku, K, Ka

15.97–16.85 24.70–26.65 34.37-35.45

≥95%

≤45°

14.57–15.65 27.47–33.85

7.14% 20.8% (27.94%)

17.27–23.92 35.87–38.32

32.3% 6.60% (38.90%)

2 =  0.17λ_o

0.64 = 0.05λ_o