Table 1 Database of papers examined at the abstract or full-text level for extractable phenotypic data.
From: A comprehensive database of thermal developmental plasticity in reptiles
Column | Description |
|---|---|
paper_no | Unique number assigned to each manuscript data was extracted from. This paper_no column matches the data_no column in Database.csv. |
first_author_surname | The surname of the first author on the manuscript data was extracted from |
authors | All authors on the manuscript, and ordered as specified when published |
year | Year of manuscript publication |
title | Title of the publication |
journal | The name of the journal the article was published in |
volume | Volume of the journal the publication belongs to |
pages | The range of pages of the publication |
doi_stableurl | An internet link to the publication as appropriate. Typically, this is either its DOI, a stable URL, or a link to the publication on ResearchGate. If unable to locate a URL, then cell filled with “NA” |
abstract | Abstract of the publication |
used | “Y”: the publication was included in the database |
“N”: the database was excluded from the database a “Partially”: a subset of the data within the paper was included in the database | |
excld_1 | Excluded (Y/N) because the study species was viviparous |
excld_2 | Excluded (Y/N) because the methods or data were unclear |
excld_3 | Excluded (Y/N) because the study involved a designed temperature shift experiment |
excld_4 | Excluded (Y/N) because the study was not an experimental manipulation |
excld_5 | Excluded (Y/N) because the study involved hormonal experimental manipulation |
excld_6 | Excluded (Y/N) because post-hatching treatments were confounded with the temperature treatments |
excld_7 | Excluded (Y/N) because the paper was inaccessible |
excld_8 | Excluded (Y/N) for another reason, that is not specified above. More details can be found in the 'comments' column as appropriate. |
comments | Text to specify comments for any other reason the paper was excluded, or to provide more details about the manuscript. |
