Table 1 Characteristics of eligible studies included in the meta-analysis.

From: Matrix Metalloproteinase-3 -1171 5A/6A Polymorphism (rs35068180) is Associated with Risk of Periodontitis

First author

Year

Country

Ethnicity

Form of Disease

Sample size (Case/Control)

Distribution of genotypes and alleles

Smoking status

Genotyping method

Quality scores

Case

Control

5A/5A/5A/6A/6A/6A

5A

6A

5A/5A/5A/6A/6A/6A

5A

6A

Itagaki

2004

Japan

Asian

CP

205/142

5/58/142

68

342

4/38/100

46

238

Non-smokers

TaqMan

31

Itagaki

2004

Japan

Asian

AgP

37/142*

0/17/20

17

57

4/38/100

46

238

Non-smokers

TaqMan

31

Astolfi

2006

Brazil

Mixed

CP

90/103

19/52/19

90

90

8/70/25

86

120

Non-smokers

PCR-RFLP

29

Kobayashi

2009

Japan

Asian

CP

147/303

37

257

72

534

S/N

DNA chip & PCR

29

Kobayashi

2009

Japan

Asian

AgP

172/303*

58

286

72

534

S/N

DNA chip & PCR

29

Loo

2011

China

Asian

CP

280/250

154/115/11

423

137

100/135/15

335

165

Non-smokers

PCR-RFLP

28

Letra

2012

Brazil

Mixed

CP

93/299

117

69

356

242

S/N

TaqMan

30

Letra

2012

USA

Caucasian

CP

67/202

78

56

193

211

S/N

TaqMan

30

Li

2012

China

Asian

CP

122/532

75/44/3

194

50

213/283/36

709

355

S/N

PCR-RFLP

27

  1. CP, chronic periodontitis; AgP, aggressive periodontitis; S/N, smokers and nonsmokers.
  2. *The control group for AgP used the same subjects as the control group for CP. In the pooled analysis, the CP and AgP cases were combined into one group and the control group was counted only one time.