Table 3 Comparison between the present and previous reported data related to the DBTT of tungsten-based materials.

From: Extraordinary high ductility/strength of the interface designed bulk W-ZrC alloy plate at relatively low temperature

Material/Size

Working process

DBTT (K)

Dimension (mm)

Method

Ref.

W–0.5ZrC (8.5 mm thick plate)

Rolling

373

2 × 2 × 20

3PB

our

W–2Y2O3 (2 mm thick, Φ 95 mm)

Hot Forging

473

2 × 2 × 25

3PB

13

Pure W(10 mm thick plate)

Rolling

473

2 × 4 × 20

3PB

20

Pure W (4 mm thick)

HIP

473

2 × 3.3 × 20

3PB

20

W–0.2TiC (1 mm thick)

Forging+Rolling

440

1 × 1 × 20

3PB

21

W–0.25Ti–0.05C (1 mm thick plate)

Rolling

260

1 × 1 × 20

3PB

21

W–1%Y2O3

Injection molding

1273

3 × 4 × 27

Charpy

29

Pure W

Injection molding

1173

3 × 4 × 27

Charpy

29

W–0.5TiC

HIP + Forging

484

1 × 1 × 20

3PB

39

WL10

Swaging + Rolling

973

10 × 10 × 55

Charpy

40

Pure W (0.1 mm thick foil)

Rolling + Joinning

373

4 × 15 × 33

Charpy

41