Table 1 Previous studies that analyzed the DCDC2 deletion for association with dyslexia

From: The DCDC2 deletion is not a risk factor for dyslexia

Reference

Country

Sample

Type of analysis

Allele

Quantitative phenotype

P-value

Deletion Frequency

Meng et al., 2005

USA

153 nuclear families

Quantitative

Deletion+STR rare alleles

Homonym Choice

0.00002

8.5%

     

Untimed PIAT Word Recognition

0.023

 
     

Word Recognition

0.04

 
     

OC

0.0035

 
     

OC

0.0385

 

Harold et al., 2006

England

264 nuclear families

Quantitative

Deletion

 

Not associated

10%

  

126 severe families subgroup

  

IWR

0.03

9%

     

READ

0.04

 
     

PA

0.05

 
 

Wales

350 cases

Categorical

Deletion

 

Not associated

9% cases

  

273 controls

 

Deletion+STR rare alleles

 

Not associated

9% controls

Brkanac et al., 2007

USA

191 trios

Quantitative

Deletion

SWE

0.05

7.5%

     

Spelling

0.04

 

Ludwig et al., 2008

Germany

396 trios

Categorical

Deletion+STR rare alleles

 

Not associated

8.6%

Wilcke et al., 2009

Germany

72 cases

Categorical

Deletion

 

P<0.01

10% cases

  

25 severe cases

    

8% severe cases

  

184 controls

    

4% controls

Marino et al., 2012

Italy

303 nuclear families

Quantitative

Deletion

SWR

0.05

6%

    

Deletion

PD

0.04

 
    

STR allele 10

Memory Composite Score

0.00001

 
    

Deletion+STR rare alleles

Memory Composite Score

0.00001

 

Powers et al., 2016

UK

89 cases

Categorical

Deletion

Severe RD

Not associated

8.3%

  

4428 controlsa

  

Severe LI

  
  1. Abbreviations: IWR, irregular word reading; LI, language impairment; OC, orthographic coding; PA, phonological awareness; PD, non-word reading; PIAT, Peabody individual achievement test; READ, single-word reading; RD, reading disability; SWE, sight word efficiency.
  2. aThe samples sizes were estimated by combining information from different studies;11, 12 these studies reported association between the 5 and 6 STR alleles with reading-related measures.