Rodent models of nerve injury are frequently used to study peripheral nerve regeneration, but translating the findings to clinical applications has been difficult, in part because in axons in humans generally need to regenerate over much longer distances, leaving the distal nerves and muscle tissue denervated for long periods of time. In this Review, Scheib and Höke discuss the challenges and advances in the study of peripheral nerve regeneration, and suggest that chronic rodent models of nerve injury more closely mimic the chronic denervation condition that is commonly present in human nerve injuries.