A large proportion of the magmas erupted at continental arc volcanoes are andesites, which are regarded as a major component in the formation of continental crust — consequently, it is important to understand andesite petrogenesis. Here, an alternative view of andesite petrogenesis is presented, based on a review of quenched glassy melt inclusions trapped in phenocrysts, whole-rock chemistry, and high-pressure and high-temperature experiments; this new view resolves several puzzling aspects of arc volcanism.