Table 4 Diagnostic efficacy parameter of 4 diagnostic models.

From: Multicenter, prospective, observational study for urinary exosomal biomarkers of kidney allograft fibrosis

miRNAs

AUC

95% CI

P-value

cutoff

Sensitivity

Specificity

PPV

NPV

(A) Model 1

 miR-21

0.762

0.658–0.846

 < 0.001

 > 1.032

84.5

69.0

84.5

68.9

 miR-29c

0.795

0.694–0.874

 < 0.001

 > 1.605

98.3

67.9

86.3

95.0

 Combination

0.802

0.702–0.880

 < 0.001

 > 0.430

96.5

62.1

83.4

90.0

(B) Model 2

 miR-21

0.762

0.658–0.846

 < 0.001

 > 1.032

84.5

69.0

84.5

68.9

 miR-29c

0.795

0.694–0.874

 < 0.001

 > 1.605

98.3

67.9

86.3

95.0

 miR-205

0.691

0.582–0.787

0.001

 > 2.642

41.1

89.7

88.5

44.1

Combination

0.810

0.711–0.887

 < 0.001

 > 0.377

98.2

48.3

78.6

93.3

(C) Model 3

 miR-19a

0.687

0.579–0.782

0.003

 ≤ 0.919

82.8

55.2

78.7

61.6

 miR-21

0.762

0.658–0.846

 < 0.001

 > 1.032

84.5

69.0

84.5

68.9

 miR-29c

0.795

0.694–0.874

 < 0.001

 > 1.605

98.3

67.9

86.3

95.0

 miR-205

0.691

0.582–0.787

0.001

 > 2.642

41.1

89.7

88.5

44.1

 Combination

0.837

0.742–0.908

p < 0.001

 > 0.582

87.5

72.4

86.0

75.0