Table 3 The optimum parameters of the PI controllers used in the system control.
Gains | \(\:{Kp}_{1}\) | \(\:{Ki}_{1}\) | \(\:{Kp}_{2}\) | \(\:{Ki}_{2}\) | \(\:{Kp}_{3}\) | \(\:{Ki}_{3}\) | \(\:{Kp}_{4}\) | \(\:{Ki}_{4}\) | \(\:{Kp}_{5}\) | \(\:{Ki}_{5}\) | \(\:{Kp}_{6}\) | \(\:{Ki}_{6}\) | \(\:{Kp}_{7}\) | \(\:{Ki}_{7}\) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
GA -PI | 95.2340 | 90.7677 | 99.5889 | 58.4372 | 99.8323 | 19.0675 | 39.8228 | 57.5075 | 11.3808 | 100 | 100 | 11.7834 | 100 | 59.3345 |
COOT-PI | 100 | 24.0447 | 100 | 99.9565 | 99.9949 | 22.0796 | 7.1496 | 100 | 11.4498 | 100 | 99.7063 | 88.7763 | 99.9828 | 62.6826 |