Table 3 Comparison of Bias, MSE, MRE for parameter estimateswhen \(\alpha = 0.40\); \(\beta = 0.10\); \(\gamma = 0.35\);\(\delta = 0.25\); and \(\lambda = 0.70\).

From: A novel extension of the power lindley distribution with statistical properties and application to COVID-19 data

Sample

size

Value

Parameter

Methods of estimation

\(\kappa_{1}\)

\(\kappa_{2}\)

\(\kappa_{3}\)

\(\kappa_{4}\)

\(\kappa_{5}\)

\(\kappa_{6}\)

\(\kappa_{7}\)

\(\kappa_{8}\)

\(\kappa_{9}\)

\(\kappa_{10}\)

20

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.2650

[3]

0.6063

[7]

0.6133

[8]

0.6376

[9]

0.5681

[6]

0.5497

[5]

1.3031

[10]

0.2758

[4]

0.1867

[2]

0.1591

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.1160

[3]

0.8323

[7]

0.5445

[5]

0.5925

[6]

1.0266

[9]

0.9584

[8]

1.2145

[10]

0.2464

[4]

0.0699

[1]

0.1049

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.2487

[8]

0.2089

[5]

0.2411

[7]

0.2494

[9]

0.2368

[6]

0.1872

[4]

0.2533

[10]

0.1818

[3]

0.0746

[2]

0.0668

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.3783

[4]

0.3985

[6]

0.4954

[7]

0.5704

[10]

0.5139

[8]

0.3911

[5]

0.3587

[3]

0.5639

[9]

0.1319

[1]

0.1593

[2]

\(\lambda\)

3.0810

[9]

1.0813

[7]

1.7593

[8]

7.1189

[10]

0.9999

[6]

0.6869

[3]

0.9065

[5]

0.7675

[4]

0.4054

[2]

0.3732

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.2986

[4]

35.169

[8]

39.556

[9]

0.6512

[5]

30.098

[6]

32.203

[7]

125.01

[10]

0.1662

[3]

0.0379

[1]

0.0429

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.1355

[2]

98.112

[9]

49.549

[6]

0.7846

[4]

68.654

[8]

51.025

[7]

115.23

[10]

1.8078

[5]

0.0172

[1]

0.1358

[3]

\(\gamma\)

0.1095

[9]

0.0747

[5]

0.0956

[7]

0.1103

[10]

0.0933

[6]

0.0642

[4]

0.1039

[8]

0.0625

[3]

0.0150

[2]

0.0100

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.4326

[4]

0.4515

[5]

0.6365

[8]

0.6467

[9]

0.6154

[7]

0.4846

[6]

0.2995

[3]

0.8427

[10]

0.0474

[1]

0.0798

[2]

\(\lambda\)

17.345

[8]

10.827

[6]

22.643

[9]

59.833

[10]

15.815

[7]

3.4907

[4]

8.6605

[5]

1.9472

[3]

0.2487

[1]

0.3489

[2]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.6627

[3]

1.5158

[8]

1.5334

[9]

1.2940

[5]

1.4204

[7]

1.3743

[6]

3.2578

[10]

0.6894

[4]

0.4666

[2]

0.3978

[1]

\(\beta\)

1.1605

[3]

8.3231

[7]

5.4447

[6]

1.9249

[4]

10.266

[9]

9.5843

[8]

12.145

[10]

2.4637

[5]

0.7982

[1]

1.0491

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.7106

[[8]

0.5968

[5]

0.6889

[7]

0.7127

[9]

0.6767

[6]

0.5349

[4]

0.7237

[10]

0.5196

[3]

0.2132

[2]

0.1909

[1]

\(\delta\)

1.5134

[4]

1.5940

[6]

1.9614

[8]

1.9707

[9]

1.9001

[7]

1.5642

[5]

1.4347

[3]

2.2556

[10]

0.5276

[1]

0.6373

[2]

\(\lambda\)

4.4142

[9]

1.5447

[7]

2.5133

[8]

10.170

[10]

1.4285

[6]

0.9814

[3]

1.2950

[5]

1.0965

[4]

0.5791

[2]

0.5330

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

81

[5]

98

[6]

112

[8.5]

119

[10]

104

[7]

79

[4]

112

[8.5]

74

[3]

22

[1]

24

[2]

50

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.2167

[3]

0.2679

[6]

0.2948

[8]

0.2896

[7]

0.3160

[10]

0.2206

[4]

0.2986

[9]

0.2576

[5]

0.1810

[2]

0.1553

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0853

[3]

0.1545

[6]

0.1846

[8]

0.1360

[4]

0.1920

[9]

0.1540

[5]

0.1999

[10]

0.1740

[7]

0.0706

[1]

0.0723

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1477

[7]

0.1256

[4]

0.1677

[9]

0.1533

[8]

0.1727

[10]

0.1096

[3]

0.1439

[6]

0.1394

[5]

0.0638

[1]

0.0639

[2]

\(\delta\)

0.2655

[3]

0.3708

[6]

0.4759

[8]

0.4927

[9]

0.4972

[10]

0.3207

[5]

0.3009

[4]

0.4464

[7]

0.1261

[1]

0.1473

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.7997

[8]

0.7349

[5]

0.9720

[9]

0.9962

[10]

0.7948

[7]

0.4951

[3]

0.5133

[4]

0.7440

[6]

0.4002

[2]

0.3453

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0590

[3]

0.1668

[7]

0.1639

[6]

0.1728

[8]

0.2698

[9]

0.1088

[5]

0.2718

[10]

0.0980

[4]

0.0372

[1]

0.0413

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.0138

[3]

0.1984

[5]

0.2373

[7]

0.1326

[4]

0.2096

[6]

0.2674

[9]

0.2402

[8]

0.4282

[10]

0.0110

[2]

0.0092

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0418

[7]

0.0290

[4]

0.0475

[9]

0.0424

[8]

0.0518

[10]

0.0216

[3]

0.0379

[6]

0.0347

[5]

0.0092

[2]

0.0085

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1817

[3]

0.4196

[6]

0.5407

[9]

0.4967

[7]

0.5111

[8]

0.3305

[5]

0.2567

[4]

0.5636

[10]

0.0458

[1]

0.0709

[2]

\(\lambda\)

11.059

[10]

1.8545

[7]

2.2696

[8]

6.3703

[9]

1.6360

[6]

0.7984

[3]

0.8064

[4]

1.5743

[5]

0.2454

[1]

0.3019

[2]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.5418

[3]

0.6697

[6]

0.7371

[8]

0.7240

[7]

0.7901

[10]

0.5516

[4]

0.7464

[9]

0.6440

[5]

0.4525

[2]

0.3882

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.8531

[3]

1.5449

[6]

1.8461

[8]

1.3602

[4]

1.9208

[9]

1.5401

[5]

1.9993

[10]

1.7400

[7]

0.7588

[2]

0.7228

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.4221

[7]

0.3589

[4]

0.4792

[9]

0.4381

[8]

0.4934

[10]

0.3131

[3]

0.4110

[6]

0.3983

[5]

0.1824

[1]

0.1827

[2]

\(\delta\)

1.0622

[3]

1.4833

[6]

1.8235

[10]

1.7707

[8]

1.7362

[7]

1.2828

[5]

1.2039

[4]

1.7858

[9]

0.5044

[1]

0.5891

[2]

\(\lambda\)

1.1424

[8]

1.0499

[5]

1.2457

[9]

1.4232

[10]

1.1355

[7]

0.7073

[3]

0.7333

[4]

1.0629

[6]

0.5717

[2]

0.4933

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

74

[4]

83

[5]

125

[9]

111

[8]

128

[10]

65

[3]

98

[7]

96

[6]

22

[1]

23

[2]

100

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.2038

[4]

0.2108

[5]

0.2280

[8]

0.2228

[6]

0.2371

[9]

0.1667

[3]

0.2257

[7]

0.2408

[10]

0.1590

[2]

0.1522

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0795

[3]

0.0953

[6]

0.1158

[8]

0.0944

[5]

0.1169

[9]

0.0816

[4]

0.1235

[10]

0.1138

[7]

0.0715

[2]

0.0705

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0901

[4]

0.0933

[5]

0.1312

[10]

0.0981

[6]

0.1301

[8]

0.0756

[3]

0.0990

[7]

0.1311

[9]

0.0585

[1]

0.0608

[2]

\(\delta\)

0.2563

[4]

0.3542

[6]

0.4429

[9]

0.4109

[7]

0.4750

[10]

0.2864

[5]

0.2453

[3]

0.4204

[8]

0.1214

[1]

0.1356

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.5222

[5]

0.6163

[6]

0.7284

[10]

0.6623

[7]

0.7110

[9]

0.4228

[4]

0.4155

[3]

0.7074

[8]

0.3585

[2]

0.3401

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0480

[4]

0.0661

[5]

0.0984

[9]

0.0771

[7]

0.0920

[8]

0.0371

[3]

0.1304

[10]

0.0699

[6]

0.0369

[2]

0.0368

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0077

[3]

0.0260

[5]

0.0542

[9]

0.0248

[4]

0.0416

[7]

0.0344

[6]

0.0928

[10]

0.0434

[8]

0.0074

[1]

0.0076

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0153

[5]

0.0151

[4]

0.0292

[9]

0.0171

[6]

0.0301

[10]

0.0097

[3]

0.0188

[7]

0.0286

[8]

0.0067

[1]

0.0078

[2]

\(\delta\)

0.1780

[4]

0.3512

[6]

0.4277

[8]

0.3921

[7]

0.4670

[9]

0.2849

[5]

0.1614

[3]

0.5471

[10]

0.0433

[1]

0.0700

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.9423

[6]

1.0387

[7]

1.0821

[8]

0.9096

[5]

1.3220

[9]

0.5160

[4]

0.3898

[3]

1.4512

[10]

0.2453

[1]

0.2841

[2]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.5095

[4]

0.5269

[5]

0.5700

[8]

0.5571

[6]

0.5929

[9]

0.4168

[3]

0.5643

[7]

0.6019

[10]

0.3975

[2]

0.3806

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.7952

[3]

0.9532

[6]

1.1583

[8]

0.9444

[5]

1.1692

[9]

0.8165

[4]

1.2355

[10]

1.1086

[7]

0.7556

[2]

0.7046

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.2573

[4]

0.2665

[5]

0.3750

[10]

0.2803

[6]

0.3716

[8]

0.2161

[3]

0.2828

[7]

0.3746

[9]

0.1672

[1]

0.1738

[2]

\(\delta\)

1.0250

[4]

1.4166

[6]

1.7815

[10]

1.6436

[8]

1.6289

[7]

1.1455

[5]

0.9810

[3]

1.6817

[9]

0.4857

[1]

0.5424

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.7459

[5]

0.8805

[6]

1.0277

[10]

0.9461

[7]

1.0157

[9]

0.6041

[4]

0.5935

[3]

1.0106

[8]

0.5122

[2]

0.4859

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

62

[4]

83

[5]

134

[10]

92

[6]

130

[9]

59

[3]

93

[7]

127

[8]

22

[1]

23

[2]

150

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1939

[4]

0.1966

[5]

0.2197

[9]

0.2152

[8]

0.2060

[7]

0.1619

[3]

0.1995

[6]

0.2391

[10]

0.1486

[1]

0.1501

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.0761

[3]

0.0855

[6]

0.1060

[8]

0.0819

[5]

0.1082

[9]

0.0810

[4]

0.1028

[7]

0.1109

[10]

0.0748

[2]

0.0695

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0664

[4]

0.0692

[5]

0.1110

[9]

0.0738

[6]

0.1072

[8]

0.0609

[3]

0.0759

[7]

0.1117

[10]

0.0535

[2]

0.0525

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.2304

[5]

0.3475

[6]

0.3953

[9]

0.3658

[7]

0.4341

[10]

0.2290

[4]

0.2269

[3]

0.3774

[8]

0.1159

[1]

0.1331

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.4727

[5]

0.5549

[6]

0.5907

[7]

0.6523

[9]

0.6117

[8]

0.3792

[4]

0.3563

[3]

0.6840

[10]

0.3169

[1]

0.3301

[2]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0436

[4]

0.0471

[5]

0.0701

[9]

0.0539

[7]

0.0520

[6]

0.0352

[2]

0.1495

[10]

0.0658

[8]

0.0351

[1]

0.0358

[3]

\(\beta\)

0.0074

[3]

0.0165

[6]

0.0439

[9]

0.0135

[4]

0.0379

[7]

0.0146

[5]

0.1190

[10]

0.0405

[8]

0.0070

[1]

0.0070

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0072

[4]

0.0074

[5]

0.0204

[10]

0.0086

[6]

0.0194

[9]

0.0060

[3]

0.0101

[7]

0.0186

[8]

0.0059

[2]

0.0055

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1533

[4]

0.3630

[8]

0.3560

[7]

0.3115

[6]

0.4566

[10]

0.1950

[5]

0.1394

[3]

0.4469

[9]

0.0407

[1]

0.0475

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.4846

[5]

0.6637

[6]

0.8797

[8]

0.8033

[7]

0.8918

[9]

0.3549

[4]

0.2964

[3]

1.2183

[10]

0.2397

[2]

0.2325

[1]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.4847

[4]

0.4915

[5]

0.5493

[9]

0.5384

[8]

0.5151

[7]

0.4048

[3]

0.4987

[6]

0.5978

[10]

0.3715

[1]

0.3803

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.7613

[3]

0.8555

[6]

1.0600

[8]

0.8187

[5]

1.0824

[9]

0.8100

[4]

1.0285

[7]

1.1384

[10]

0.7479

[2]

0.6956

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.1898

[4]

0.1977

[5]

0.3174

[9]

0.2110

[6]

0.3064

[8]

0.1740

[3]

0.2171

[7]

0.3191

[10]

0.1528

[2]

0.1501

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.9218

[5]

1.3899

[6]

1.6113

[9]

1.4632

[7]

1.6210

[10]

0.9159

[4]

0.9077

[3]

1.5095

[8]

0.4637

[1]

0.5324

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.6753

[5]

0.7927

[6]

0.9010

[8]

0.9319

[9]

0.8739

[7]

0.5417

[4]

0.5091

[3]

0.9771

[10]

0.4527

[1]

0.4716

[2]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

62

[4]

86

[6]

128

[9]

100

[7]

124

[8]

55

[3]

85

[5]

139

[10]

21

[1]

25

[2]

250

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1750

[5]

0.1872

[6]

0.2022

[8]

0.2124

[10]

0.1938

[7]

0.1612

[4]

0.1499

[3]

0.2102

[9]

0.1483

[2]

0.1482

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0726

[4]

0.0786

[7]

0.0965

[9]

0.0774

[6]

0.0851

[8]

0.0699

[3]

0.0639

[1]

0.0966

[10]

0.0756

[5]

0.0642

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0552

[4]

0.0592

[6]

0.0881

[9]

0.0585

[5]

0.0811

[8]

0.0482

[3]

0.0603

[7]

0.1054

[10]

0.0450

[2]

0.0429

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1578

[3]

0.3078

[7]

0.3746

[9]

0.2770

[6]

0.4052

[10]

0.1816

[4]

0.1945

[5]

0.3636

[8]

0.1004

[1]

0.1098

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.3720

[6]

0.5303

[7]

0.5182

[5]

0.5916

[9]

0.5458

[8]

0.3457

[4]

0.3200

[3]

0.6530

[10]

0.2858

[1]

0.3143

[2]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0360

[5]

0.0456

[7]

0.0501

[8]

0.0505

[9]

0.0460

[6]

0.0333

[3]

0.0309

[2]

0.0519

[10]

0.0334

[4]

0.0302

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0058

[2]

0.0111

[7]

0.0236

[9]

0.0071

[5]

0.0178

[8]

0.0083

[6]

0.0063

[3]

0.0384

[10]

0.0068

[4]

0.0050

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0050

[4]

0.0055

[6]

0.0118

[9]

0.0051

[5]

0.0107

[8]

0.0037

[2.5]

0.0061

[7]

0.0159

[10]

0.0037

[2.5]

0.0032

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0726

[3]

0.2673

[7]

0.3392

[8]

0.1973

[6]

0.4121

[9]

0.1164

[5]

0.0938

[4]

0.4250

[10]

0.0224

[1]

0.0351

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.2929

[5]

0.4881

[6]

0.7627

[9]

0.5982

[8]

0.5919

[7]

0.2428

[4]

0.2159

[3]

1.1676

[10]

0.1762

[1]

0.1832

[2]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.4376

[5]

0.4831

[6]

0.5056

[8]

0.5311

[9]

0.4844

[7]

0.4030

[4]

0.3748

[3]

0.5570

[10]

0.3709

[2]

0.3705

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.7256

[5]

0.7861

[7]

0.9651

[9]

0.7739

[6]

0.8513

[8]

0.6994

[3]

0.6386

[1]

1.0792

[10]

0.7151

[4]

0.6422

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1578

[4]

0.1693

[6]

0.2517

[9]

0.1670

[5]

0.2317

[8]

0.1378

[3]

0.1723

[7]

0.2677

[10]

0.1287

[2]

0.1225

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.6310

[3]

1.2312

[7]

1.5287

[9]

1.1080

[6]

1.6157

[10]

0.7266

[4]

0.7781

[5]

1.4513

[8]

0.4016

[1]

0.4392

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.5314

[5]

0.7576

[6]

0.8132

[8]

0.8451

[9]

0.7798

[7]

0.4938

[4]

0.4571

[3]

0.8935

[10]

0.4083

[1]

0.4490

[2]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

63

[5]

98

[6]

126

[9]

104

[7]

119

[8]

56.5

[3]

57

[4]

145

[10]

33.5

[2]

23

[1]

400

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1728

[5]

0.1942

[9]

0.1845

[6]

0.2102

[10]

0.1854

[7]

0.1609

[4]

0.1437

[3]

0.1870

[8]

0.1337

[1]

0.1403

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.0715

[4]

0.0716

[5]

0.0780

[9]

0.0764

[8]

0.0758

[6]

0.0683

[3]

0.0559

[1]

0.0837

[10]

0.0759

[7]

0.0625

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0436

[3]

0.0487

[5]

0.0692

[9]

0.0497

[7]

0.0685

[8]

0.0440

[4]

0.0496

[6]

0.0943

[10]

0.0426

[2]

0.0350

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1398

[3]

0.2441

[7]

0.3658

[9]

0.2336

[6]

0.3813

[10]

0.1564

[5]

0.1549

[4]

0.3549

[8]

0.0923

[1]

0.0988

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.3671

[5]

0.4912

[7]

0.4540

[6]

0.5488

[9]

0.5186

[8]

0.3468

[4]

0.2849

[3]

0.6147

[10]

0.2144

[1]

0.2821

[2]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0348

[6]

0.0425

[8]

0.0423

[7]

0.0488

[10]

0.0427

[9]

0.0312

[4]

0.0272

[2]

0.0215

[1]

0.0316

[5]

0.0278

[3]

\(\beta\)

0.0056

[4]

0.0068

[7]

0.0137

[10]

0.0063

[6]

0.0110

[8]

0.0052

[3]

0.0040

[1]

0.0118

[9]

0.0061

[5]

0.0047

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0029

[3]

0.0038

[6.5]

0.0073

[9]

0.0035

[5]

0.0071

[8]

0.0029

[3]

0.0038

[6.5]

0.0094

[10]

0.0029

[3]

0.0022

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0588

[4]

0.1577

[7]

0.3066

[9]

0.1305

[6]

0.3648

[10]

0.0824

[5]

0.0516

[3]

0.3036

[8]

0.0174

[1]

0.0337

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.2551

[5]

0.3945

[6]

0.5162

[8]

0.4681

[7]

0.5360

[9]

0.2326

[4]

0.1497

[2]

1.0330

[10]

0.1066

[1]

0.1516

[3]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.4320

[5]

0.4781

[8]

0.4612

[6]

0.5256

[10]

0.4635

[7]

0.4022

[4]

0.3591

[3]

0.5194

[9]

0.3344

[1]

0.3508

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.7150

[5]

0.7157

[6]

0.7799

[9]

0.7636

[8]

0.7570

[7]

0.6821

[3]

0.5594

[1]

0.9802

[10]

0.7062

[4]

0.6255

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1247

[3]

0.1391

[5]

0.1976

[9]

0.1421

[7]

0.1956

[8]

0.1257

[4]

0.1418

[6]

0.2168

[10]

0.1216

[2]

0.0999

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.5592

[3]

0.9763

[7]

1.4631

[9]

0.9345

[6]

1.5251

[10]

0.6256

[5]

0.6195

[4]

1.3334

[8]

0.3695

[1]

0.3952

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.5244

[5]

0.7017

[6]

0.7486

[8]

0.7839

[9]

0.7408

[7]

0.4801

[4]

0.4069

[3]

0.8094

[10]

0.3064

[1]

0.4031

[2]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

63

[5]

99.5

[6]

123

[9]

114

[7]

122

[8]

56

[4]

48.5

[3]

131

[10]

36

[2]

29

[1]

600

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1568

[5]

0.1920

[9]

0.1708

[7]

0.1957

[10]

0.1853

[8]

0.1583

[6]

0.1304

[2]

0.1513

[4]

0.1287

[1]

0.1315

[3]

\(\beta\)

0.0702

[8]

0.0655

[4.5]

0.0674

[7]

0.0750

[9]

0.0655

[4.5]

0.0668

[6]

0.0524

[1]

0.0654

[3]

0.0798

[10]

0.0613

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0384

[2]

0.0450

[7]

0.0629

[8]

0.0414

[6]

0.0641

[9]

0.0399

[4]

0.0408

[5]

0.0759

[10]

0.0394

[3]

0.0313

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1101

[3]

0.2164

[7]

0.3470

[9]

0.1609

[6]

0.3631

[10]

0.1543

[5]

0.1390

[4]

0.3320

[8]

0.0848

[1]

0.0920

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.3088

[4]

0.4527

[8]

0.3271

[5]

0.4503

[7]

0.5176

[9]

0.3339

[6]

0.2659

[3]

0.5865

[10]

0.1967

[1]

0.2233

[2]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0290

[4]

0.04192

[9]

0.0419

[8]

0.0422

[10]

0.0417

[7]

0.0310

[6]

0.0223

[2]

0.0136

[1]

0.0307

[5]

0.0250

[3]

\(\beta\)

0.0054

[5]

0.0048

[3]

0.0076

[9]

0.0061

[7]

0.0073

[8]

0.0049

[4]

0.0034

[1]

0.0086

[10]

0.0057

[6]

0.0046

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0022

[2]

0.0031

[7]

0.0060

[8]

0.0025

[5]

0.0061

[9]

0.0023

[3.5]

0.0026

[6]

0.0079

[10]

0.0023

[3.5]

0.0017

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0397

[3]

0.1494

[7]

0.2796

[9]

0.0792

[6]

0.3571

[10]

0.0747

[5]

0.0428

[4]

0.2625

[8]

0.0130

[1]

0.0287

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.1846

[4]

0.3672

[7]

0.4674

[9]

0.3136

[6]

0.4527

[8]

0.2149

[5]

0.1247

[2]

1.0123

[10]

0.0971

[1]

0.1289

[3]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.3922

[4]

0.4610

[7]

0.4495

[6]

0.4892

[10]

0.4632

[8]

0.3958

[5]

0.3260

[2]

0.4817

[9]

0.3218

[1]

0.3289

[3]

\(\beta\)

0.7025

[8]

0.6550

[4]

0.6744

[6]

0.7504

[9]

0.6545

[3]

0.6683

[5]

0.5240

[1]

0.9054

[10]

0.6994

[7]

0.6129

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1098

[2]

0.1287

[7]

0.1798

[9]

0.1183

[6]

0.1831

[10]

0.1139

[4]

0.1167

[5]

0.1609

[8]

0.1126

[3]

0.0895

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.4404

[3]

0.9320

[7]

1.3581

[9]

0.6436

[6]

1.4525

[10]

0.6171

[5]

0.5559

[4]

1.2067

[8]

0.3393

[1]

0.3683

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.4412

[4]

0.6732

[8]

0.6130

[6]

0.6434

[7]

0.7394

[9]

0.4769

[5]

0.3799

[3]

0.7584

[10]

0.2810

[1]

0.3191

[2]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

61

[4]

101.5

[6]

115

[8]

110

[7]

122.5

[10]

74.5

[5]

45

[2]

119

[9]

45.5

[3]

31

[1]