Table 3 Comparison of Bias, MSE, MRE for parameter estimateswhen \(\alpha = 0.40\); \(\beta = 0.10\); \(\gamma = 0.35\);\(\delta = 0.25\); and \(\lambda = 0.70\).
Sample size | Value | Parameter | Methods of estimation | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
\(\kappa_{1}\) | \(\kappa_{2}\) | \(\kappa_{3}\) | \(\kappa_{4}\) | \(\kappa_{5}\) | \(\kappa_{6}\) | \(\kappa_{7}\) | \(\kappa_{8}\) | \(\kappa_{9}\) | \(\kappa_{10}\) | |||
20 | Bias [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.2650 [3] | 0.6063 [7] | 0.6133 [8] | 0.6376 [9] | 0.5681 [6] | 0.5497 [5] | 1.3031 [10] | 0.2758 [4] | 0.1867 [2] | 0.1591 [1] |
\(\beta\) | 0.1160 [3] | 0.8323 [7] | 0.5445 [5] | 0.5925 [6] | 1.0266 [9] | 0.9584 [8] | 1.2145 [10] | 0.2464 [4] | 0.0699 [1] | 0.1049 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.2487 [8] | 0.2089 [5] | 0.2411 [7] | 0.2494 [9] | 0.2368 [6] | 0.1872 [4] | 0.2533 [10] | 0.1818 [3] | 0.0746 [2] | 0.0668 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.3783 [4] | 0.3985 [6] | 0.4954 [7] | 0.5704 [10] | 0.5139 [8] | 0.3911 [5] | 0.3587 [3] | 0.5639 [9] | 0.1319 [1] | 0.1593 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 3.0810 [9] | 1.0813 [7] | 1.7593 [8] | 7.1189 [10] | 0.9999 [6] | 0.6869 [3] | 0.9065 [5] | 0.7675 [4] | 0.4054 [2] | 0.3732 [1] | ||
MSE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.2986 [4] | 35.169 [8] | 39.556 [9] | 0.6512 [5] | 30.098 [6] | 32.203 [7] | 125.01 [10] | 0.1662 [3] | 0.0379 [1] | 0.0429 [2] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.1355 [2] | 98.112 [9] | 49.549 [6] | 0.7846 [4] | 68.654 [8] | 51.025 [7] | 115.23 [10] | 1.8078 [5] | 0.0172 [1] | 0.1358 [3] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.1095 [9] | 0.0747 [5] | 0.0956 [7] | 0.1103 [10] | 0.0933 [6] | 0.0642 [4] | 0.1039 [8] | 0.0625 [3] | 0.0150 [2] | 0.0100 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.4326 [4] | 0.4515 [5] | 0.6365 [8] | 0.6467 [9] | 0.6154 [7] | 0.4846 [6] | 0.2995 [3] | 0.8427 [10] | 0.0474 [1] | 0.0798 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 17.345 [8] | 10.827 [6] | 22.643 [9] | 59.833 [10] | 15.815 [7] | 3.4907 [4] | 8.6605 [5] | 1.9472 [3] | 0.2487 [1] | 0.3489 [2] | ||
MRE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.6627 [3] | 1.5158 [8] | 1.5334 [9] | 1.2940 [5] | 1.4204 [7] | 1.3743 [6] | 3.2578 [10] | 0.6894 [4] | 0.4666 [2] | 0.3978 [1] | |
\(\beta\) | 1.1605 [3] | 8.3231 [7] | 5.4447 [6] | 1.9249 [4] | 10.266 [9] | 9.5843 [8] | 12.145 [10] | 2.4637 [5] | 0.7982 [1] | 1.0491 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.7106 [[8] | 0.5968 [5] | 0.6889 [7] | 0.7127 [9] | 0.6767 [6] | 0.5349 [4] | 0.7237 [10] | 0.5196 [3] | 0.2132 [2] | 0.1909 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 1.5134 [4] | 1.5940 [6] | 1.9614 [8] | 1.9707 [9] | 1.9001 [7] | 1.5642 [5] | 1.4347 [3] | 2.2556 [10] | 0.5276 [1] | 0.6373 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 4.4142 [9] | 1.5447 [7] | 2.5133 [8] | 10.170 [10] | 1.4285 [6] | 0.9814 [3] | 1.2950 [5] | 1.0965 [4] | 0.5791 [2] | 0.5330 [1] | ||
Sum ranks [ranks] | Â | 81 [5] | 98 [6] | 112 [8.5] | 119 [10] | 104 [7] | 79 [4] | 112 [8.5] | 74 [3] | 22 [1] | 24 [2] | |
50 | Bias [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.2167 [3] | 0.2679 [6] | 0.2948 [8] | 0.2896 [7] | 0.3160 [10] | 0.2206 [4] | 0.2986 [9] | 0.2576 [5] | 0.1810 [2] | 0.1553 [1] |
\(\beta\) | 0.0853 [3] | 0.1545 [6] | 0.1846 [8] | 0.1360 [4] | 0.1920 [9] | 0.1540 [5] | 0.1999 [10] | 0.1740 [7] | 0.0706 [1] | 0.0723 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.1477 [7] | 0.1256 [4] | 0.1677 [9] | 0.1533 [8] | 0.1727 [10] | 0.1096 [3] | 0.1439 [6] | 0.1394 [5] | 0.0638 [1] | 0.0639 [2] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.2655 [3] | 0.3708 [6] | 0.4759 [8] | 0.4927 [9] | 0.4972 [10] | 0.3207 [5] | 0.3009 [4] | 0.4464 [7] | 0.1261 [1] | 0.1473 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.7997 [8] | 0.7349 [5] | 0.9720 [9] | 0.9962 [10] | 0.7948 [7] | 0.4951 [3] | 0.5133 [4] | 0.7440 [6] | 0.4002 [2] | 0.3453 [1] | ||
MSE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.0590 [3] | 0.1668 [7] | 0.1639 [6] | 0.1728 [8] | 0.2698 [9] | 0.1088 [5] | 0.2718 [10] | 0.0980 [4] | 0.0372 [1] | 0.0413 [2] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.0138 [3] | 0.1984 [5] | 0.2373 [7] | 0.1326 [4] | 0.2096 [6] | 0.2674 [9] | 0.2402 [8] | 0.4282 [10] | 0.0110 [2] | 0.0092 [1] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0418 [7] | 0.0290 [4] | 0.0475 [9] | 0.0424 [8] | 0.0518 [10] | 0.0216 [3] | 0.0379 [6] | 0.0347 [5] | 0.0092 [2] | 0.0085 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.1817 [3] | 0.4196 [6] | 0.5407 [9] | 0.4967 [7] | 0.5111 [8] | 0.3305 [5] | 0.2567 [4] | 0.5636 [10] | 0.0458 [1] | 0.0709 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 11.059 [10] | 1.8545 [7] | 2.2696 [8] | 6.3703 [9] | 1.6360 [6] | 0.7984 [3] | 0.8064 [4] | 1.5743 [5] | 0.2454 [1] | 0.3019 [2] | ||
MRE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.5418 [3] | 0.6697 [6] | 0.7371 [8] | 0.7240 [7] | 0.7901 [10] | 0.5516 [4] | 0.7464 [9] | 0.6440 [5] | 0.4525 [2] | 0.3882 [1] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.8531 [3] | 1.5449 [6] | 1.8461 [8] | 1.3602 [4] | 1.9208 [9] | 1.5401 [5] | 1.9993 [10] | 1.7400 [7] | 0.7588 [2] | 0.7228 [1] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.4221 [7] | 0.3589 [4] | 0.4792 [9] | 0.4381 [8] | 0.4934 [10] | 0.3131 [3] | 0.4110 [6] | 0.3983 [5] | 0.1824 [1] | 0.1827 [2] | ||
\(\delta\) | 1.0622 [3] | 1.4833 [6] | 1.8235 [10] | 1.7707 [8] | 1.7362 [7] | 1.2828 [5] | 1.2039 [4] | 1.7858 [9] | 0.5044 [1] | 0.5891 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 1.1424 [8] | 1.0499 [5] | 1.2457 [9] | 1.4232 [10] | 1.1355 [7] | 0.7073 [3] | 0.7333 [4] | 1.0629 [6] | 0.5717 [2] | 0.4933 [1] | ||
Sum ranks [ranks] | Â | 74 [4] | 83 [5] | 125 [9] | 111 [8] | 128 [10] | 65 [3] | 98 [7] | 96 [6] | 22 [1] | 23 [2] | |
100 | Bias [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.2038 [4] | 0.2108 [5] | 0.2280 [8] | 0.2228 [6] | 0.2371 [9] | 0.1667 [3] | 0.2257 [7] | 0.2408 [10] | 0.1590 [2] | 0.1522 [1] |
\(\beta\) | 0.0795 [3] | 0.0953 [6] | 0.1158 [8] | 0.0944 [5] | 0.1169 [9] | 0.0816 [4] | 0.1235 [10] | 0.1138 [7] | 0.0715 [2] | 0.0705 [1] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0901 [4] | 0.0933 [5] | 0.1312 [10] | 0.0981 [6] | 0.1301 [8] | 0.0756 [3] | 0.0990 [7] | 0.1311 [9] | 0.0585 [1] | 0.0608 [2] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.2563 [4] | 0.3542 [6] | 0.4429 [9] | 0.4109 [7] | 0.4750 [10] | 0.2864 [5] | 0.2453 [3] | 0.4204 [8] | 0.1214 [1] | 0.1356 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.5222 [5] | 0.6163 [6] | 0.7284 [10] | 0.6623 [7] | 0.7110 [9] | 0.4228 [4] | 0.4155 [3] | 0.7074 [8] | 0.3585 [2] | 0.3401 [1] | ||
MSE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.0480 [4] | 0.0661 [5] | 0.0984 [9] | 0.0771 [7] | 0.0920 [8] | 0.0371 [3] | 0.1304 [10] | 0.0699 [6] | 0.0369 [2] | 0.0368 [1] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.0077 [3] | 0.0260 [5] | 0.0542 [9] | 0.0248 [4] | 0.0416 [7] | 0.0344 [6] | 0.0928 [10] | 0.0434 [8] | 0.0074 [1] | 0.0076 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0153 [5] | 0.0151 [4] | 0.0292 [9] | 0.0171 [6] | 0.0301 [10] | 0.0097 [3] | 0.0188 [7] | 0.0286 [8] | 0.0067 [1] | 0.0078 [2] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.1780 [4] | 0.3512 [6] | 0.4277 [8] | 0.3921 [7] | 0.4670 [9] | 0.2849 [5] | 0.1614 [3] | 0.5471 [10] | 0.0433 [1] | 0.0700 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.9423 [6] | 1.0387 [7] | 1.0821 [8] | 0.9096 [5] | 1.3220 [9] | 0.5160 [4] | 0.3898 [3] | 1.4512 [10] | 0.2453 [1] | 0.2841 [2] | ||
MRE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.5095 [4] | 0.5269 [5] | 0.5700 [8] | 0.5571 [6] | 0.5929 [9] | 0.4168 [3] | 0.5643 [7] | 0.6019 [10] | 0.3975 [2] | 0.3806 [1] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.7952 [3] | 0.9532 [6] | 1.1583 [8] | 0.9444 [5] | 1.1692 [9] | 0.8165 [4] | 1.2355 [10] | 1.1086 [7] | 0.7556 [2] | 0.7046 [1] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.2573 [4] | 0.2665 [5] | 0.3750 [10] | 0.2803 [6] | 0.3716 [8] | 0.2161 [3] | 0.2828 [7] | 0.3746 [9] | 0.1672 [1] | 0.1738 [2] | ||
\(\delta\) | 1.0250 [4] | 1.4166 [6] | 1.7815 [10] | 1.6436 [8] | 1.6289 [7] | 1.1455 [5] | 0.9810 [3] | 1.6817 [9] | 0.4857 [1] | 0.5424 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.7459 [5] | 0.8805 [6] | 1.0277 [10] | 0.9461 [7] | 1.0157 [9] | 0.6041 [4] | 0.5935 [3] | 1.0106 [8] | 0.5122 [2] | 0.4859 [1] | ||
Sum ranks [ranks] | Â | 62 [4] | 83 [5] | 134 [10] | 92 [6] | 130 [9] | 59 [3] | 93 [7] | 127 [8] | 22 [1] | 23 [2] | |
150 | Bias [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.1939 [4] | 0.1966 [5] | 0.2197 [9] | 0.2152 [8] | 0.2060 [7] | 0.1619 [3] | 0.1995 [6] | 0.2391 [10] | 0.1486 [1] | 0.1501 [2] |
\(\beta\) | 0.0761 [3] | 0.0855 [6] | 0.1060 [8] | 0.0819 [5] | 0.1082 [9] | 0.0810 [4] | 0.1028 [7] | 0.1109 [10] | 0.0748 [2] | 0.0695 [1] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0664 [4] | 0.0692 [5] | 0.1110 [9] | 0.0738 [6] | 0.1072 [8] | 0.0609 [3] | 0.0759 [7] | 0.1117 [10] | 0.0535 [2] | 0.0525 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.2304 [5] | 0.3475 [6] | 0.3953 [9] | 0.3658 [7] | 0.4341 [10] | 0.2290 [4] | 0.2269 [3] | 0.3774 [8] | 0.1159 [1] | 0.1331 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.4727 [5] | 0.5549 [6] | 0.5907 [7] | 0.6523 [9] | 0.6117 [8] | 0.3792 [4] | 0.3563 [3] | 0.6840 [10] | 0.3169 [1] | 0.3301 [2] | ||
MSE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.0436 [4] | 0.0471 [5] | 0.0701 [9] | 0.0539 [7] | 0.0520 [6] | 0.0352 [2] | 0.1495 [10] | 0.0658 [8] | 0.0351 [1] | 0.0358 [3] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.0074 [3] | 0.0165 [6] | 0.0439 [9] | 0.0135 [4] | 0.0379 [7] | 0.0146 [5] | 0.1190 [10] | 0.0405 [8] | 0.0070 [1] | 0.0070 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0072 [4] | 0.0074 [5] | 0.0204 [10] | 0.0086 [6] | 0.0194 [9] | 0.0060 [3] | 0.0101 [7] | 0.0186 [8] | 0.0059 [2] | 0.0055 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.1533 [4] | 0.3630 [8] | 0.3560 [7] | 0.3115 [6] | 0.4566 [10] | 0.1950 [5] | 0.1394 [3] | 0.4469 [9] | 0.0407 [1] | 0.0475 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.4846 [5] | 0.6637 [6] | 0.8797 [8] | 0.8033 [7] | 0.8918 [9] | 0.3549 [4] | 0.2964 [3] | 1.2183 [10] | 0.2397 [2] | 0.2325 [1] | ||
MRE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.4847 [4] | 0.4915 [5] | 0.5493 [9] | 0.5384 [8] | 0.5151 [7] | 0.4048 [3] | 0.4987 [6] | 0.5978 [10] | 0.3715 [1] | 0.3803 [2] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.7613 [3] | 0.8555 [6] | 1.0600 [8] | 0.8187 [5] | 1.0824 [9] | 0.8100 [4] | 1.0285 [7] | 1.1384 [10] | 0.7479 [2] | 0.6956 [1] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.1898 [4] | 0.1977 [5] | 0.3174 [9] | 0.2110 [6] | 0.3064 [8] | 0.1740 [3] | 0.2171 [7] | 0.3191 [10] | 0.1528 [2] | 0.1501 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.9218 [5] | 1.3899 [6] | 1.6113 [9] | 1.4632 [7] | 1.6210 [10] | 0.9159 [4] | 0.9077 [3] | 1.5095 [8] | 0.4637 [1] | 0.5324 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.6753 [5] | 0.7927 [6] | 0.9010 [8] | 0.9319 [9] | 0.8739 [7] | 0.5417 [4] | 0.5091 [3] | 0.9771 [10] | 0.4527 [1] | 0.4716 [2] | ||
Sum ranks [ranks] | Â | 62 [4] | 86 [6] | 128 [9] | 100 [7] | 124 [8] | 55 [3] | 85 [5] | 139 [10] | 21 [1] | 25 [2] | |
250 | Bias [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.1750 [5] | 0.1872 [6] | 0.2022 [8] | 0.2124 [10] | 0.1938 [7] | 0.1612 [4] | 0.1499 [3] | 0.2102 [9] | 0.1483 [2] | 0.1482 [1] |
\(\beta\) | 0.0726 [4] | 0.0786 [7] | 0.0965 [9] | 0.0774 [6] | 0.0851 [8] | 0.0699 [3] | 0.0639 [1] | 0.0966 [10] | 0.0756 [5] | 0.0642 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0552 [4] | 0.0592 [6] | 0.0881 [9] | 0.0585 [5] | 0.0811 [8] | 0.0482 [3] | 0.0603 [7] | 0.1054 [10] | 0.0450 [2] | 0.0429 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.1578 [3] | 0.3078 [7] | 0.3746 [9] | 0.2770 [6] | 0.4052 [10] | 0.1816 [4] | 0.1945 [5] | 0.3636 [8] | 0.1004 [1] | 0.1098 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.3720 [6] | 0.5303 [7] | 0.5182 [5] | 0.5916 [9] | 0.5458 [8] | 0.3457 [4] | 0.3200 [3] | 0.6530 [10] | 0.2858 [1] | 0.3143 [2] | ||
MSE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.0360 [5] | 0.0456 [7] | 0.0501 [8] | 0.0505 [9] | 0.0460 [6] | 0.0333 [3] | 0.0309 [2] | 0.0519 [10] | 0.0334 [4] | 0.0302 [1] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.0058 [2] | 0.0111 [7] | 0.0236 [9] | 0.0071 [5] | 0.0178 [8] | 0.0083 [6] | 0.0063 [3] | 0.0384 [10] | 0.0068 [4] | 0.0050 [1] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0050 [4] | 0.0055 [6] | 0.0118 [9] | 0.0051 [5] | 0.0107 [8] | 0.0037 [2.5] | 0.0061 [7] | 0.0159 [10] | 0.0037 [2.5] | 0.0032 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.0726 [3] | 0.2673 [7] | 0.3392 [8] | 0.1973 [6] | 0.4121 [9] | 0.1164 [5] | 0.0938 [4] | 0.4250 [10] | 0.0224 [1] | 0.0351 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.2929 [5] | 0.4881 [6] | 0.7627 [9] | 0.5982 [8] | 0.5919 [7] | 0.2428 [4] | 0.2159 [3] | 1.1676 [10] | 0.1762 [1] | 0.1832 [2] | ||
MRE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.4376 [5] | 0.4831 [6] | 0.5056 [8] | 0.5311 [9] | 0.4844 [7] | 0.4030 [4] | 0.3748 [3] | 0.5570 [10] | 0.3709 [2] | 0.3705 [1] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.7256 [5] | 0.7861 [7] | 0.9651 [9] | 0.7739 [6] | 0.8513 [8] | 0.6994 [3] | 0.6386 [1] | 1.0792 [10] | 0.7151 [4] | 0.6422 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.1578 [4] | 0.1693 [6] | 0.2517 [9] | 0.1670 [5] | 0.2317 [8] | 0.1378 [3] | 0.1723 [7] | 0.2677 [10] | 0.1287 [2] | 0.1225 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.6310 [3] | 1.2312 [7] | 1.5287 [9] | 1.1080 [6] | 1.6157 [10] | 0.7266 [4] | 0.7781 [5] | 1.4513 [8] | 0.4016 [1] | 0.4392 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.5314 [5] | 0.7576 [6] | 0.8132 [8] | 0.8451 [9] | 0.7798 [7] | 0.4938 [4] | 0.4571 [3] | 0.8935 [10] | 0.4083 [1] | 0.4490 [2] | ||
Sum ranks [ranks] | Â | 63 [5] | 98 [6] | 126 [9] | 104 [7] | 119 [8] | 56.5 [3] | 57 [4] | 145 [10] | 33.5 [2] | 23 [1] | |
400 | Bias [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.1728 [5] | 0.1942 [9] | 0.1845 [6] | 0.2102 [10] | 0.1854 [7] | 0.1609 [4] | 0.1437 [3] | 0.1870 [8] | 0.1337 [1] | 0.1403 [2] |
\(\beta\) | 0.0715 [4] | 0.0716 [5] | 0.0780 [9] | 0.0764 [8] | 0.0758 [6] | 0.0683 [3] | 0.0559 [1] | 0.0837 [10] | 0.0759 [7] | 0.0625 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0436 [3] | 0.0487 [5] | 0.0692 [9] | 0.0497 [7] | 0.0685 [8] | 0.0440 [4] | 0.0496 [6] | 0.0943 [10] | 0.0426 [2] | 0.0350 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.1398 [3] | 0.2441 [7] | 0.3658 [9] | 0.2336 [6] | 0.3813 [10] | 0.1564 [5] | 0.1549 [4] | 0.3549 [8] | 0.0923 [1] | 0.0988 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.3671 [5] | 0.4912 [7] | 0.4540 [6] | 0.5488 [9] | 0.5186 [8] | 0.3468 [4] | 0.2849 [3] | 0.6147 [10] | 0.2144 [1] | 0.2821 [2] | ||
MSE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.0348 [6] | 0.0425 [8] | 0.0423 [7] | 0.0488 [10] | 0.0427 [9] | 0.0312 [4] | 0.0272 [2] | 0.0215 [1] | 0.0316 [5] | 0.0278 [3] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.0056 [4] | 0.0068 [7] | 0.0137 [10] | 0.0063 [6] | 0.0110 [8] | 0.0052 [3] | 0.0040 [1] | 0.0118 [9] | 0.0061 [5] | 0.0047 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0029 [3] | 0.0038 [6.5] | 0.0073 [9] | 0.0035 [5] | 0.0071 [8] | 0.0029 [3] | 0.0038 [6.5] | 0.0094 [10] | 0.0029 [3] | 0.0022 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.0588 [4] | 0.1577 [7] | 0.3066 [9] | 0.1305 [6] | 0.3648 [10] | 0.0824 [5] | 0.0516 [3] | 0.3036 [8] | 0.0174 [1] | 0.0337 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.2551 [5] | 0.3945 [6] | 0.5162 [8] | 0.4681 [7] | 0.5360 [9] | 0.2326 [4] | 0.1497 [2] | 1.0330 [10] | 0.1066 [1] | 0.1516 [3] | ||
MRE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.4320 [5] | 0.4781 [8] | 0.4612 [6] | 0.5256 [10] | 0.4635 [7] | 0.4022 [4] | 0.3591 [3] | 0.5194 [9] | 0.3344 [1] | 0.3508 [2] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.7150 [5] | 0.7157 [6] | 0.7799 [9] | 0.7636 [8] | 0.7570 [7] | 0.6821 [3] | 0.5594 [1] | 0.9802 [10] | 0.7062 [4] | 0.6255 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.1247 [3] | 0.1391 [5] | 0.1976 [9] | 0.1421 [7] | 0.1956 [8] | 0.1257 [4] | 0.1418 [6] | 0.2168 [10] | 0.1216 [2] | 0.0999 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.5592 [3] | 0.9763 [7] | 1.4631 [9] | 0.9345 [6] | 1.5251 [10] | 0.6256 [5] | 0.6195 [4] | 1.3334 [8] | 0.3695 [1] | 0.3952 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.5244 [5] | 0.7017 [6] | 0.7486 [8] | 0.7839 [9] | 0.7408 [7] | 0.4801 [4] | 0.4069 [3] | 0.8094 [10] | 0.3064 [1] | 0.4031 [2] | ||
Sum ranks [ranks] | Â | 63 [5] | 99.5 [6] | 123 [9] | 114 [7] | 122 [8] | 56 [4] | 48.5 [3] | 131 [10] | 36 [2] | 29 [1] | |
600 | Bias [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.1568 [5] | 0.1920 [9] | 0.1708 [7] | 0.1957 [10] | 0.1853 [8] | 0.1583 [6] | 0.1304 [2] | 0.1513 [4] | 0.1287 [1] | 0.1315 [3] |
\(\beta\) | 0.0702 [8] | 0.0655 [4.5] | 0.0674 [7] | 0.0750 [9] | 0.0655 [4.5] | 0.0668 [6] | 0.0524 [1] | 0.0654 [3] | 0.0798 [10] | 0.0613 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0384 [2] | 0.0450 [7] | 0.0629 [8] | 0.0414 [6] | 0.0641 [9] | 0.0399 [4] | 0.0408 [5] | 0.0759 [10] | 0.0394 [3] | 0.0313 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.1101 [3] | 0.2164 [7] | 0.3470 [9] | 0.1609 [6] | 0.3631 [10] | 0.1543 [5] | 0.1390 [4] | 0.3320 [8] | 0.0848 [1] | 0.0920 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.3088 [4] | 0.4527 [8] | 0.3271 [5] | 0.4503 [7] | 0.5176 [9] | 0.3339 [6] | 0.2659 [3] | 0.5865 [10] | 0.1967 [1] | 0.2233 [2] | ||
MSE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.0290 [4] | 0.04192 [9] | 0.0419 [8] | 0.0422 [10] | 0.0417 [7] | 0.0310 [6] | 0.0223 [2] | 0.0136 [1] | 0.0307 [5] | 0.0250 [3] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.0054 [5] | 0.0048 [3] | 0.0076 [9] | 0.0061 [7] | 0.0073 [8] | 0.0049 [4] | 0.0034 [1] | 0.0086 [10] | 0.0057 [6] | 0.0046 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.0022 [2] | 0.0031 [7] | 0.0060 [8] | 0.0025 [5] | 0.0061 [9] | 0.0023 [3.5] | 0.0026 [6] | 0.0079 [10] | 0.0023 [3.5] | 0.0017 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.0397 [3] | 0.1494 [7] | 0.2796 [9] | 0.0792 [6] | 0.3571 [10] | 0.0747 [5] | 0.0428 [4] | 0.2625 [8] | 0.0130 [1] | 0.0287 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.1846 [4] | 0.3672 [7] | 0.4674 [9] | 0.3136 [6] | 0.4527 [8] | 0.2149 [5] | 0.1247 [2] | 1.0123 [10] | 0.0971 [1] | 0.1289 [3] | ||
MRE [ranks] | \(\alpha\) | 0.3922 [4] | 0.4610 [7] | 0.4495 [6] | 0.4892 [10] | 0.4632 [8] | 0.3958 [5] | 0.3260 [2] | 0.4817 [9] | 0.3218 [1] | 0.3289 [3] | |
\(\beta\) | 0.7025 [8] | 0.6550 [4] | 0.6744 [6] | 0.7504 [9] | 0.6545 [3] | 0.6683 [5] | 0.5240 [1] | 0.9054 [10] | 0.6994 [7] | 0.6129 [2] | ||
\(\gamma\) | 0.1098 [2] | 0.1287 [7] | 0.1798 [9] | 0.1183 [6] | 0.1831 [10] | 0.1139 [4] | 0.1167 [5] | 0.1609 [8] | 0.1126 [3] | 0.0895 [1] | ||
\(\delta\) | 0.4404 [3] | 0.9320 [7] | 1.3581 [9] | 0.6436 [6] | 1.4525 [10] | 0.6171 [5] | 0.5559 [4] | 1.2067 [8] | 0.3393 [1] | 0.3683 [2] | ||
\(\lambda\) | 0.4412 [4] | 0.6732 [8] | 0.6130 [6] | 0.6434 [7] | 0.7394 [9] | 0.4769 [5] | 0.3799 [3] | 0.7584 [10] | 0.2810 [1] | 0.3191 [2] | ||
Sum ranks [ranks] | Â | 61 [4] | 101.5 [6] | 115 [8] | 110 [7] | 122.5 [10] | 74.5 [5] | 45 [2] | 119 [9] | 45.5 [3] | 31 [1] |