Table 5 Comparison of Bias, MSE, MRE for parameter estimateswhen \(\alpha = 0.20\); \(\beta = 0.95\); \(\gamma = 1.15\);\(\delta = 0.25\); and \(\lambda = 1.05\).

From: A novel extension of the power lindley distribution with statistical properties and application to COVID-19 data

Sample size

Value

Parameter

Methods of estimation

\(\kappa_{1}\)

\(\kappa_{2}\)

\(\kappa_{3}\)

\(\kappa_{4}\)

\(\kappa_{5}\)

\(\kappa_{6}\)

\(\kappa_{7}\)

\(\kappa_{8}\)

\(\kappa_{9}\)

\(\kappa_{10}\)

20

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.9067

[7]

0.9267

[8]

0.7723

[5]

0.8021

[6]

1.0964

[9]

0.5963

[4]

1.1732

[10]

0.2400

[3]

0.0682

[1]

0.0740

[2]

\(\beta\)

2.6788

[4]

5.0875

[9]

4.0345

[6]

2.4698

[3]

4.7464

[7]

5.0196

[8]

6.2200

[10]

3.3221

[5]

0.3904

[1]

0.9405

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.5789

[8]

0.5244

[7]

0.6380

[10]

0.5034

[5]

0.5827

[9]

0.4773

[3]

0.4992

[4]

0.5143

[6]

0.2215

[2]

0.1866

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1661

[3]

0.2332

[8]

0.2150

[5]

0.2228

[6]

0.2518

[9]

0.3477

[10]

0.1923

[4]

0.2287

[7]

0.0976

[1]

0.1162

[2]

\(\lambda\)

2.3726

[8]

1.2387

[4]

3.2135

[10]

2.3487

[7]

3.1940

[9]

1.6740

[5]

1.6799

[6]

1.0958

[3]

0.4464

[1]

0.5556

[2]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

66.247

[7]

84.528

[8]

65.827

[6]

53.761

[5]

89.890

[9]

39.366

[4]

117.20

[10]

1.2769

[3]

0.0226

[2]

0.0184

[1]

\(\beta\)

176.33

[5]

669.87

[9]

551.33

[8]

163.75

[4]

517.84

[7]

261.36

[6]

1724.1

[10]

113.75

[3]

3.9492

[1]

18.110

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.7300

[10]

0.5157

[5]

0.6310

[9]

0.5558

[7]

0.5527

[6]

0.3835

[3]

0.4846

[4]

0.6075

[8]

0.0972

[2]

0.0696

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0534

[2]

0.1720

[8]

0.0917

[5]

0.2204

[9]

0.1603

[7]

0.4399

[10]

0.0877

[4]

0.1009

[6]

0.0176

[1]

0.0581

[3]

\(\lambda\)

122.02

[8]

26.433

[5]

192.63

[10]

150.39

[9]

120.75

[7]

21.831

[3]

24.656

[4]

38.396

[6]

0.5691

[1]

1.5900

[2]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

4.5337

[7]

4.6335

[8]

3.8613

[5]

4.0106

[6]

5.4821

[9]

2.9816

[4]

5.8661

[10]

1.2002

[3]

0.3409

[1]

0.3701

[2]

\(\beta\)

2.8198

[4]

5.3552

[9]

4.2468

[6]

2.5998

[3]

4.9962

[7]

5.2838

[8]

6.5474

[10]

3.4970

[5]

0.4109

[1]

0.9900

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.5034

[8]

0.4560

[7]

0.5548

[10]

0.4377

[5]

0.5067

[9]

0.4151

[3]

0.4341

[4]

0.4472

[6]

0.1926

[2]

0.1623

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.6642

[3]

0.9330

[8]

0.8601

[5]

0.8913

[6]

1.0070

[9]

1.3908

[10]

0.7691

[4]

0.9147

[7]

0.3904

[1]

0.4648

[2]

\(\lambda\)

2.2596

[8]

1.1797

[4]

3.0605

[10]

2.2369

[7]

3.0419

[9]

1.5943

[5]

1.600

[6]

1.0436

[3]

0.4252

[1]

0.5291

[2]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

92

[6]

107

[8]

110

[9]

88

[5]

122

[10]

86

[4]

100

[7]

74

[3]

19

[1]

27

[2]

50

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1621

[4]

0.1536

[3]

0.1940

[9]

0.6141

[10]

0.1923

[8]

0.1674

[6]

0.1662

[5]

0.1727

[7]

0.0532

[1]

0.0557

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.6640

[3]

3.5193

[10]

3.0219

[8]

1.4609

[4]

2.2103

[7]

3.3611

[9]

1.6007

[5]

1.9478

[6]

0.3815

[1]

0.4558

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.3102

[5]

0.3230

[6]

0.5007

[10]

0.2880

[3]

0.4508

[9]

0.3059

[4]

0.3552

[7]

0.4028

[8]

0.1549

[2]

0.1202

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0984

[3]

0.2146

[9]

0.2056

[6]

0.1408

[4]

0.2227

[10]

0.2134

[8]

0.1650

[5]

0.2099

[7]

0.0802

[2]

0.0791

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.3844

[3]

0.4118

[4]

0.9404

[10]

0.8949

[8]

0.9305

[9]

0.5114

[6]

0.5316

[7]

0.4187

[5]

0.2872

[2]

0.2641

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.3619

[9]

0.1204

[6]

0.1283

[7]

15.960

[10]

0.1140

[5]

0.1090

[4]

0.0921

[3]

0.2392

[8]

0.0078

[1]

0.0103

[2]

\(\beta\)

9.3527

[3]

188.91

[9]

263.41

[10]

22.420

[4]

90.345

[7]

148.94

[8]

25.912

[5]

27.090

[6]

1.0500

[1]

2.8342

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.3504

[8]

0.2279

[5]

0.4191

[10]

0.2134

[4]

0.3401

[7]

0.1859

[3]

0.2710

[6]

0.3918

[9]

0.0479

[2]

0.0359

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0277

[3]

0.1491

[9]

0.0986

[7]

0.0614

[4]

0.1439

[8]

0.1646

[10]

0.0840

[6]

0.0795

[5]

0.0139

[1]

0.0225

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.7126

[4]

0.9342

[6]

11.279

[9]

11.685

[10]

7.4979

[8]

0.8416

[5]

1.2365

[7]

0.4416

[3]

0.2101

[1]

0.2160

[2]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.8108

[4]

0.7683

[3]

0.9702

[9]

3.0704

[10]

0.9613

[8]

0.8368

[6]

0.8311

[5]

0.8635

[7]

0.2656

[1]

0.2787

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.6990

[3]

3.7046

[10]

3.1810

[8]

1.5377

[4]

2.8877

[7]

3.5380

[9]

1.6849

[5]

2.0503

[6]

0.4016

[1]

0.4797

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.2698[5]

0.2809

[6]

0.4354

[10]

0.2504

[3]

0.3920

[9]

0.2660

[4]

0.3088

[7]

0.3503

[8]

0.1347

[2]

0.1045

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.3936

[3]

0.8584

[9]

0.8225

[6]

0.5632

[4]

0.8907

[10]

0.8537

[8]

0.6599

[5]

0.8398

[7]

0.3208

[2]

0.3165

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.3661

[3]

0.3922

[4]

0.8956

[10]

0.8523

[8]

0.8862

[9]

0.4870

[6]

0.5063

[7]

0.3988

[5]

0.2736

[2]

0.2516

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

63

[3]

99

[8]

129

[10]

90

[5]

121

[9]

96

[6]

85

[4]

97

[7]

22

[1]

23

[2]

100

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1186

[3]

0.1526

[5]

0.1911

[10]

0.1546

[6]

0.1766

[9]

0.1264

[4]

0.1623

[8]

0.1570

[7]

0.0460

[2]

0.0446

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.3498

[3]

2.9456

[10]

2.1138

[7]

0.5568

[4]

2.6356

[9]

2.1743

[8]

1.4263

[5]

1.5507

[6]

0.2629

[1]

0.2973

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1790

[4]

0.2210

[6]

0.4083

[10]

0.1439

[3]

0.3662

[9]

0.2119

[5]

0.2642

[7]

0.2861

[8]

0.0927

[2]

0.0795

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0599

[3]

0.1669

[7]

0.2012

[9]

0.0711

[4]

0.2193

[10]

0.1544

[6]

0.1403

[5]

0.1838

[8]

0.0544

[2]

0.0495

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.1736

[1]

0.2564

[5]

0.4928

[10]

0.2514

[4]

0.4635

[9]

0.3205

[8]

0.3068

[7]

0.2884

[6]

0.1896

[3]

0.1737

[2]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.2017

[9]

0.1193

[7]

0.1192

[6]

0.5305

[10]

0.0984

[5]

0.0661

[3]

0.0866

[4]

0.1541

[8]

0.0074

[1]

0.0090

[2]

\(\beta\)

1.2720

[3]

180.38

[10]

56.025

[7]

3.4094

[4]

58.570

[8]

127.70

[9]

20.122

[6]

15.038

[5]

0.4684

[1]

1.0769

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1779

[7]

0.1077

[5]

0.2741

[10]

0.0850

[3]

0.2151

[8]

0.0913

[4]

0.1681

[6]

0.2171

[9]

0.0211

[1]

0.0239

[2]

\(\delta\)

0.0107

[3]

0.1120

[9]

0.0963

[8]

0.0184

[4]

0.1280

[10]

0.0808

[7]

0.0583

[5]

0.0696

[6]

0.0096

[2]

0.0092

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0785

[1]

0.1487

[4]

0.6591

[10]

0.2410

[6]

0.4775

[9]

0.3326

[8]

0.3042

[7]

0.1690

[5]

0.1082

[3]

0.0808

[2]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.5931

[3]

0.7429

[5]

0.9556

[10]

0.7728

[6]

0.8830

[9]

0.6318

[4]

0.8114

[7]

0.8563

[8]

0.2300

[2]

0.2229

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.3682

[3]

3.1006

[10]

2.2251

[8]

0.5861

[4]

2.0743

[7]

2.2888

[9]

1.5014

[5]

1.6323

[6]

0.2768

[1]

0.3129

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1556

[4]

0.1922

[6]

0.3550

[10]

0.1251

[3]

0.3184

[9]

0.1842

[5]

0.2298

[7]

0.2487

[8]

0.0806

[2]

0.0691

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.2395

[3]

0.6677

[7]

0.8049

[9]

0.2843

[4]

0.8173

[10]

0.6176

[6]

0.5614

[5]

0.7351

[8]

0.2174

[2]

0.1982

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.1654

[2]

0.2442

[5]

0.4694

[10]

0.2395

[4]

0.4415

[9]

0.3053

[8]

0.2922

[7]

0.2747

[6]

0.1806

[3]

0.1653

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

52

[3]

101

[7]

134

[10]

69

[4]

130

[9]

94

[6]

91

[5]

104

[8]

28

[2]

22

[1]

150

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0919

[4]

0.1337

[7]

0.1875

[10]

0.0885

[3]

0.1709

[9]

0.1001

[5]

0.1302

[6]

0.1460

[8]

0.0429

[2]

0.0281

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.2743

[3]

2.0731

[9]

2.0613

[8]

0.3782

[4]

2.4960

[10]

2.0018

[7]

0.8144

[5]

1.0518

[6]

0.1574

[1]

0.1966

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.1079

[4]

0.1892

[7]

0.3496

[10]

0.0949

[3]

0.3174

[9]

0.1619

[5]

0.1757

[6]

0.2562

[8]

0.0792

[2]

0.0532

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0470

[3]

0.1463

[7]

0.1975

[9]

0.0479

[4]

0.2025

[10]

0.1317

[6]

0.0936

[5]

0.1510

[8]

0.0415

[2]

0.0350

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.1213

[2]

0.2380

[7]

0.3640

[10]

0.1523

[4]

0.3516

[9]

0.2112

[5]

0.2208

[6]

0.2579

[8]

0.1384

[3]

0.0978

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1034

[8]

0.1064

[9]

0.0972

[7]

0.0814

[6]

0.0785

[5]

0.0455

[3]

0.0702

[4]

0.1267

[10]

0.0065

[2]

0.0028

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.6117

[3]

60.483

[9]

31.124

[7]

2.2144

[4]

56.049

[8]

114.19

[10]

12.026

[6]

5.9491

[5]

0.2361

[1]

0.3846

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0843

[5]

0.0865

[7]

0.2011

[10]

0.0387

[3]

0.1637

[8]

0.0625

[4]

0.0857

[6]

0.1694

[9]

0.0174

[2]

0.0151

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0083

[3]

0.0903

[8]

0.0952

[9]

0.0088

[4]

0.0979

[10]

0.0742

[7]

0.0240

[5]

0.0431

[6]

0.0039

[1]

0.0046

[2]

\(\lambda\)

0.0460

[2]

0.2277

[8]

0.2621

[9]

0.0626

[4]

0.2761

[10]

0.0965

[5]

0.1487

[6]

0.1647

[7]

0.0537

[3]

0.0290

[1]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.4595

[4]

0.6686

[7]

0.9374

[10]

0.4427

[3]

0.8656

[9]

0.5004

[5]

0.6512

[6]

0.7849

[8]

0.2147

[2]

0.1407

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.2887

[3]

2.1822

[10]

2.1698

[9]

0.3981

[4]

1.6273

[7]

2.1072

[8]

0.8573

[5]

1.1071

[6]

0.1657

[1]

0.2070

[2]

\(\gamma\)

0.0939

[4]

0.1645

[7]

0.3040

[10]

0.0825

[3]

0.2760

[9]

0.1408

[5]

0.1527[6]

0.2228

[8]

0.0689

[2]

0.0463

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1881

[3]

0.5852

[7]

0.7901

[10]

0.1918

[4]

0.7882

[9]

0.5266

[6]

0.3746

[5]

0.6041

[8]

0.1660

[2]

0.1401

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.1156

[2]

0.2266

[7]

0.3467

[10]

0.1450

[4]

0.3349

[9]

0.2011

[5]

0.2103

[6]

0.2456

[8]

0.1318

[3]

0.0932

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

53

[3]

116

[8]

138

[10]

57

[4]

131

[9]

86

[6]

83

[5]

113

[7]

29

[2]

19

[1]

250

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0558

[4]

0.1080

[6]

0.1782

[10]

0.0488

[3]

0.1553

[9]

0.0781

[5]

0.1188

[7]

0.1399

[8]

0.0272

[2]

0.0213

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.1429

[3]

0.7168

[6]

1.8060

[9]

0.1498

[4]

2.1433

[10]

1.0549

[8]

0.6786

[5]

0.9317

[7]

0.1274

[2]

0.1263

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0523

[4]

0.1310

[6]

0.2886

[10]

0.0486

[3]

0.2698

[9]

0.1230

[5]

0.1339

[7]

0.1959

[8]

0.0403

[2]

0.0271

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0262

[3]

0.0844

[5]

0.1794

[10]

0.0252

[2]

0.1608

[9]

0.0845

[6]

0.0856

[7]

0.1355

[8]

0.0269

[4]

0.0202

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0760

[2]

0.1595

[5]

0.2562

[9]

0.0880

[4]

0.2766

[10]

0.1659

[7]

0.1627

[6]

0.2113

[8]

0.0815

[3]

0.0615

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0533

[5]

0.0656

[7]

0.0961

[10]

0.0329

[4]

0.0620

[6]

0.0279

[3]

0.0810

[8]

0.0933

[9]

0.0034

[1]

0.0047

[2]

\(\beta\)

0.1882

[2]

7.1560

[7]

25.892

[8]

0.4895

[4]

50.015

[10]

38.730

[9]

5.1819

[5]

5.5347

[6]

0.1416

[1]

0.1925

[3]

\(\gamma\)

0.0284

[4]

0.0485

[6]

0.1312

[10]

0.0123

[3]

0.1191

[9]

0.0372

[5]

0.0522

[7]

0.0989

[8]

0.0062

[2]

0.0039

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0036

[3]

0.0259

[6]

0.0702

[9]

0.0037

[4]

0.0809

[10]

0.0324

[7]

0.0225

[5]

0.0360

[8]

0.0023

[1.5]

0.0023

[1.5]

\(\lambda\)

0.0207

[2]

0.0683

[6]

0.1171

[9]

0.0372

[4]

0.1793

[10]

0.0759

[7]

0.0636

[5]

0.1006

[8]

0.0213

[3]

0.0120

[1]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.2792

[4]

0.5402

[6]

0.8910

[10]

0.2439

[3]

0.8352

[9]

0.3906

[5]

0.5939

[7]

0.7300

[8]

0.1359

[2]

0.1064

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.1505

[3]

0.7545

[6]

1.9011

[10]

0.1577

[4]

1.2655

[9]

1.1104

[8]

0.7144

[5]

0.9807

[7]

0.1341

[2]

0.1329

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0455

[4]

0.1139

[6]

0.2509

[10]

0.0423

[3]

0.2346

[9]

0.1070

[5]

0.1164

[7]

0.1703

[8]

0.0350

[2]

0.0236

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.1047

[3]

0.3376

[5]

0.7176

[10]

0.1007

[2]

0.6950

[9]

0.3381

[6]

0.3424

[7]

0.5419

[8]

0.1075

[4]

0.0810

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0724

[2]

0.1519

[5]

0.2440

[9]

0.0838

[4]

0.2635

[10]

0.1580

[7]

0.1550

[6]

0.2012

[8]

0.0776

[3]

0.0586

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

48

[3]

88

[5]

143

[10]

51

[4]

138

[9]

93

[6]

94

[7]

117

[8]

34.5

[2]

18.5

[1]

400

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0329

[4]

0.0796

[6]

0.1760

[10]

0.0186

[2]

0.1314

[9]

0.0629

[5]

0.0804

[7]

0.1207

[8]

0.0192

[3]

0.0124

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0637

[3]

0.5235

[7]

1.2910

[10]

0.0620

[2]

1.2813

[9]

0.5061

[5]

0.5074

[6]

0.8577

[8]

0.0741

[4]

0.0447

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0310

[4]

0.0926

[5]

0.2283

[10]

0.0193

[2]

0.2236

[9]

0.0931

[6]

0.0947

[7]

0.1464

[8]

0.0244

[3]

0.0134

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0148

[3]

0.0633

[6]

0.1421

[9]

0.0128

[2]

0.1459

[10]

0.0634

[7]

0.0612

[5]

0.1108

[8]

0.0171

[4]

0.0106

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0502

[3]

0.1164

[6]

0.2009

[10]

0.0471

[2]

0.1997

[9]

0.1231

[7]

0.1159

[5]

0.1767

[8]

0.0548

[4]

0.0355

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0333

[5]

0.0424

[7]

0.0943

[10]

0.0066

[3]

0.0431

[8]

0.0182

[4]

0.0398

[6]

0.0736

[9]

0.0024

[2]

0.0008

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0319

[2]

2.8128

[6]

8.1959

[9]

0.0773

[3]

14.007

[10]

2.1052

[5]

3.5468

[7]

3.9855

[8]

0.1198

[4]

0.0178

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0222

[5]

0.0257

[6]

0.0874

[10]

0.0021

[2]

0.0852

[9]

0.0201

[4]

0.0268

[7]

0.0631

[8]

0.0031

[3]

0.0012

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0015

[4]

0.0109

[5]

0.0392

[9]

0.0009

[2]

0.0495

[10]

0.0112

[6]

0.0120

[7]

0.0276

[8]

0.0010

[3]

0.0005

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0135

[4]

0.0499

[7]

0.0778

[8]

0.0083

[2]

0.0848

[10]

0.0261

[5]

0.0294

[6]

0.0836

[9]

0.0127

[3]

0.0058

[1]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.1646

[4]

0.3981

[6]

0.8802

[10]

0.0931

[2]

0.8097

[9]

0.3145

[5]

0.4002

[7]

0.6581

[8]

0.0960

[3]

0.0622

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0671

[3]

0.5511

[7]

1.3589

[10]

0.0653

[2]

0.9834

[9]

0.5328

[5]

0.5341

[6]

0.8427

[8]

0.0780

[4]

0.0470

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0269

[4]

0.0805

[5]

0.1985

[10]

0.0167

[2]

0.1944

[9]

0.0810

[6]

0.0824

[7]

0.1316

[8]

0.0212

[3]

0.0117

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0594

[3]

0.2533

[6]

0.5685

[9]

0.0513

[2]

0.5837

[10]

0.2538

[7]

0.2448

[5]

0.4319

[8]

0.0685

[4]

0.0425

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0480

[3]

0.1109

[6]

0.1914

[10]

0.0448

[2]

0.1902

[9]

0.1172

[7]

0.1104

[5]

0.1463

[8]

0.0522

[4]

0.0338

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

54

[4]

91

[6]

144

[10]

32

[2]

139

[9]

84

[5]

93

[7]

122

[8]

51

[3]

15

[1]

600

Bias

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0178

[4]

0.0657

[7]

0.1620

[10]

0.0090

[2]

0.1027

[8]

0.0501

[5]

0.0609

[6]

0.1157

[9]

0.0122

[3]

0.0084

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0554

[4]

0.2769

[5]

0.9243

[9]

0.0308

[2]

0.9862

[10]

0.3051

[6]

0.3443

[7]

0.7024

[8]

0.0381

[3]

0.0253

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0140

[4]

0.0662

[5]

0.1809

[9]

0.0101

[2]

0.1879

[10]

0.0715

[6]

0.0734

[7]

0.1081

[8]

0.0135

[3]

0.0088

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0094

[3]

0.0492

[7]

0.1255

[9]

0.0076

[2]

0.1323

[10]

0.0468

[5]

0.0472

[6]

0.0948

[8]

0.0098

[4]

0.0070

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0339

[4]

0.0844

[5]

0.1582

[9]

0.0276

[2]

0.1638

[10]

0.0985

[7]

0.0902

[6]

0.1296

[8]

0.0338

[3]

0.0194

[1]

MSE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0077

[4]

0.0301

[7]

0.0754

[9]

0.0007

[1.5]

0.0838

[10]

0.0132

[5]

0.0277

[6]

0.0511

[8]

0.0008

[3]

0.0007

[1.5]

\(\beta\)

0.0477

[4]

0.3343

[5]

4.4609

[9]

0.0076

[2]

4.9907

[10]

0.4820

[6]

1.8023

[7]

2.7640

[8]

0.0169

[3]

0.0061

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0037

[4]

0.0108

[5]

0.0553

[9]

0.0007

[2]

0.0599

[10]

0.0128

[6]

0.0193

[7]

0.0519

[8]

0.0009

[3]

0.0003

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0007

[4]

0.0067

[6]

0.0301

[9]

0.0003

[2.5]

0.0349

[10]

0.0060

[5]

0.0077

[7]

0.0208

[8]

0.0003

[2.5]

0.0002

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0063

[4]

0.0137

[5]

0.0491

[8]

0.0038

[2]

0.0512

[9]

0.0160

[6]

0.0193

[7]

0.0551

[10]

0.0061

[3]

0.0023

[1]

MRE

[ranks]

\(\alpha\)

0.0889

[4]

0.3284

[7]

0.8101

[10]

0.0452

[2]

0.7985

[9]

0.2505

[5]

0.3044

[6]

0.5068

[8]

0.0612

[3]

0.0420

[1]

\(\beta\)

0.0584

[4]

0.2915

[5]

0.9730

[10]

0.0324

[2]

0.9036

[9]

0.3212

[6]

0.3624

[7]

0.7592

[8]

0.0402

[3]

0.0267

[1]

\(\gamma\)

0.0121

[4]

0.0576

[5]

0.1574

[9]

0.0088

[2]

0.1634

[10]

0.0622

[6]

0.0639

[7]

0.0964

[8]

0.0117

[3]

0.0076

[1]

\(\delta\)

0.0374

[3]

0.1970

[7]

0.5018

[9]

0.0304

[2]

0.5293

[10]

0.1872

[5]

0.1889

[6]

0.3240

[8]

0.0393

[4]

0.0281

[1]

\(\lambda\)

0.0323

[4]

0.0804

[5]

0.1507

[9]

0.0263

[2]

0.1560

[10]

0.0938

[7]

0.0859

[6]

0.1087

[8]

0.0322

[3]

0.0185

[1]

Sum ranks

[ranks]

 

58

[4]

86

[5.5]

137

[9]

30

[2]

145

[10]

86

[5.5]

98

[7]

123

[8]

46.5

[3]

15.5

[1]