Table 3 SSIM of integer wavelet transform and singular value decomposition.

From: Analysis of hybrid integer wavelet transform and singular value decomposition for image steganography under various noise conditions

Attack

DFT

DCT

DWT

LWT

IWT

DWT + DFT

DWT + DCT

Gaussian noise with 0.01 mean & 0.002 variance

0.2726

0.2489

0.1846

0.1699

0.0409

0.1853

0.19

Gaussian noise with 0.0 mean &0.001 variance

0.264

0.2384

0.282

0.2463

0.0554

0.2759

0.2782

Gaussian noise with 0.01 mean & 0.005 variance

0.1347

0.1266

0.1058

0.1035

0.0241

0.1071

0.1097

Speckle noise 0.02

0.0818

0.078

0.1043

0.0947

0.0211

0.1048

0.1041

Speckle noise 0.01

0.1279

0.1199

0.1614

0.1439

0.0306

0.1651

0.1671

Speckle noise 0.015

0.0999

0.0959

0.1272

0.1155

0.0263

0.1278

0.1309

Salt and Pepper noise 0.02

0.1882

0.1834

0.1763

0.1737

0.056

0.1733

0.1748

Salt and Pepper noise 0.01

0.3621

0.3513

0.3546

0.3028

0.1157

0.338

0.3556

Salt and Pepper noise 0.005

0.5544

0.5616

0.5677

0.5072

0.2347

0.5447

0.5491

Poisson Noise

0.167

0.1159

0.1889

0.1692

0.0381

0.1908

0.1955

Attack

DWT + SVD

LWT + DCT

LWT + SVD

IWT + DCT

IWT + SVD

Proposed

Gaussian noise with 0.01 mean & 0.002 variance

0.7765

0.1711

0.7147

0.039

0.5011

0.9752

Gaussian noise with 0.0 mean &0.001 variance

0.8584

0.2402

0.8351

0.0592

0.6324

0.9735

Gaussian noise with 0.01 mean & 0.005 variance

0.585

0.1031

0.4916

0.023

0.3297

0.9106

Speckle noise 0.02

0.5398

0.0949

0.4473

0.0179

0.3125

0.9036

Speckle noise 0.01

0.6708

0.1422

0.5908

0.032

0.3953

0.9404

Speckle noise 0.015

0.5857

0.1124

0.5079

0.0205

0.122

0.9172

Salt and Pepper noise 0.02

0.5465

0.1675

0.4737

0.0531

0.2899

0.9071

Salt and Pepper noise 0.01

0.7058

0.317

0.6395

0.1184

0.3974

0.9529

Salt and Pepper noise 0.005

0.8102

0.5159

0.7951

0.2437

0.58

0.9748

Poisson Noise

0.7572

0.1733

0.6927

0.0396

0.4859

0.9734