Table 17 Comparative analysis of the proposed model with modern techniques.
Model Type | Techniques | Strengths | Limitations | Suitability for This Study |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Proposed Hybrid Model | SVM + ANN + Fuzzy Logic | Fast, interpretable, lightweight, good for small datasets | May underperform on large-scale time-series data | Well-suited for realtime smart city systems |
Bilinear Spatiotemporal Fusion Network (BLSTF) | Temporal Enhancement Module, | Reduces multi-step error accumulation | Tailored for stable, periodic traffic; may underperform in highly irregular traffic patterns | Suitable for scenarios with regular traffic patterns where efficiency and interpretability are priorities11 |
6G-Enabled Intelligent Traffic Flow Control System | Vehicle Networking, Machine Learning | Accurate traffic prediction (error rate as low as 0.81%) | Real-world implementation challenges in diverse city environments | Highly suitable for forward-looking urban traffic management systems with access to high-speed networks and smart infrastructure8 |
USTAN (Unified Spatial–Temporal Attention Network) | Spatial neighbor graph, temporal neighbor array, unified attention mechanism, gated fusion module | Captures spatial–temporal dependencies simultaneously, adaptively integrates external factors, improved prediction accuracy | May require high computational resources due to unified attention across all spatial–temporal neighbors | Moderately suitable: Offers robust spatial–temporal modeling but may not meet lightweight, real-time edge deployment constraints18 |
Reinforcement Learning Models | DQN, DDPG, Q-Learning | Dynamic, adaptive decision-making | Requires simulation environments and extensive tuning | Not aligned with passive traffic prediction9 |
Transformer-based Spatio-Temporal Model | Dynamic Spatial–Temporal Trend Transformer (DST2former), | Captures both dynamic and static traffic patterns effectively | Increased model complexity | Highly suitable due to its ability to model complex, non-linear spatio-temporal dependencies in realtime traffic flow data24 |