Table 12 Comparison of Pareto front solutions based on total cost for case study-2.
Cycle time | Yoosefelahi et.al., | NSGA- mCAP | Work stations | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Total Cost | Nj | Total Cost | Nj | ||||||
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |||||
413 | 7,804,777 | 5 | 6,001,834 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r5] | [r3] |
420 | 7,447,794 | 5 | 6,029,071 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r5] | [r3] |
424 | 6,954,386 | 5 | 6,033,919 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r5] | [r3] |
448 | 6,934,902 | 5 | 5,887,529 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
456 | 6,476,045 | 5 | 5,845,795 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
466 | 6,951,858 | 5 | 5,884,534 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
473 | 6,523,850 | 5 | 5,852,918 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
474 | 6,187,839 | 5 | 5,880,436 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
477 | 6,370,923 | 5 | 5,819,251 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
477 | 6,936,989 | 5 | 5,819,251 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
478 | 6,072,387 | 5 | 5,881,852 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | [r3] |
485 | 6,094,621 | 5 | 5,759,719 | 5 | [r4] | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] |
489 | 6,029,431 | 5 | 5,721,162 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r1] | Â |
504 | 6,041,066 | 5 | 5,566,435 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r5] | Â |
506 | 5,744,180 | 5 | 5,439,659 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
506 | 6,728,392 | 5 | 5,439,659 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
522 | 6,368,395 | 5 | 5,405,546 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
525 | 6,009,264 | 5 | 5,392,992 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
529 | 6,228,385 | 5 | 5,264,380 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
531 | 6,020,181 | 5 | 5,324,584 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
534 | 6,011,238 | 5 | 5,324,584 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
543 | 5,938,309 | 5 | 5,252,404 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
546 | 5,723,295 | 5 | 5,183,617 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â |
551 | 6,547,575 | 5 | 5,276,254 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
551 | 6,934,461 | 5 | 5,276,254 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
576 | 6,358,604 | 5 | 5,292,611 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
577 | 5,572,164 | 5 | 5,311,116 | 5 | [r3] | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] |
580 | 5,503,466 | 5 | 5,304,164 | 5 | [r3] | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] |
581 | 5,889,736 | 5 | 5,311,116 | 5 | [r3] | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] |
584 | 5,335,494 | 5 | 5,303,178 | 4 | [r4] | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â |
591 | 6,710,995 | 5 | 5,280,336 | 5 | [r3] | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] |
644 | 6,699,524 | 5 | 4,760,316 | 3 | [r2] | [r1] | [r5] | Â | Â |
650 | 5,468,410 | 5 | 4,726,992 | 3 | [r2] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
659 | 6,926,964 | 5 | 4,726,992 | 3 | [r2] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
680 | 5,926,571 | 4 | 4,610,494 | 4 | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] | Â |
681 | 6,172,386 | 4 | 4,610,494 | 4 | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] | Â |
686 | 5,919,267 | 4 | 4,607,602 | 4 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] | Â |
697 | 5,491,124 | 5 | 4,580,205 | 4 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | [r3] | Â |
729 | 6,123,778 | 4 | 4,502,579 | 3 | [r2] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
802 | 6,115,886 | 4 | 4,128,889 | 3 | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
837 | 5,944,225 | 3 | 4,052,982 | 3 | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
849 | 6,349,943 | 5 | 4,016,052 | 3 | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
849 | 5,517,236 | 3 | 4,016,052 | 3 | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
853 | 6,766,866 | 5 | 4,037,866 | 3 | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
872 | 5,384,962 | 4 | 4,049,137 | 3 | [r3] | [r1] | [r3] | Â | Â |
885 | 4,343,018 | 3 | 3,872,096 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
885 | 4,717,912 | 3 | 3,872,096 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
890 | 5,340,405 | 4 | 3,872,096 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
894 | 6,741,835 | 5 | 3,844,568 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
905 | 5,289,138 | 4 | 3,844,568 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
911 | 6,704,661 | 5 | 3,844,568 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
911 | 6,263,610 | 5 | 3,844,568 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
911 | 5,388,960 | 4 | 3,844,568 | 3 | [r5] | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â |
926 | 5,343,585 | 4 | 3,832,102 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
931 | 5,191,424 | 4 | 3,822,804 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
935 | 4,550,154 | 3 | 3,822,804 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
937 | 5,250,245 | 4 | 3,822,804 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
952 | 5,309,229 | 4 | 3,807,382 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
954 | 4,525,245 | 3 | 3,812,430 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
967 | 6,973,021 | 5 | 3,792,121 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
970 | 5,538,610 | 4 | 3,792,121 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
971 | 6,549,367 | 5 | 3,792,121 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
971 | 6,381,957 | 5 | 3,792,121 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
986 | 4,713,560 | 2 | 3,819,382 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
991 | 6,483,297 | 5 | 3,818,884 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
1008 | 4,684,886 | 2 | 3,818,884 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
1025 | 4,283,339 | 3 | 3,859,867 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
1030 | 4,508,890 | 3 | 3,826,957 | 3 | [r3] | [r5] | [r3] | Â | Â |
1060 | 6,924,348 | 5 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1061 | 5,351,874 | 4 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1063 | 5,083,625 | 4 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1079 | 5,342,460 | 4 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1079 | 4,370,096 | 3 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1080 | 5,824,367 | 4 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1096 | 6,904,119 | 5 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1096 | 5,147,591 | 4 | 3,751,554 | 2 | [r2] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1109 | 3,885,494 | 3 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1119 | 5,758,297 | 4 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1127 | 4,275,842 | 3 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1129 | 4,271,575 | 3 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1132 | 4,358,625 | 3 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1158 | 4,775,093 | 3 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1163 | 3,695,910 | 2 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1167 | 3,691,509 | 2 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1179 | 4,615,755 | 3 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1179 | 3,684,439 | 2 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1182 | 4,260,104 | 3 | 3,530,104 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1211 | 3,662,931 | 2 | 3,550,229 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1231 | 3,984,015 | 3 | 3,550,229 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1251 | 3,639,310 | 2 | 3,550,229 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1259 | 4,610,494 | 4 | 3,550,229 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1264 | 3,637,274 | 2 | 3,550,229 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1270 | 4,615,664 | 3 | 3,550,229 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1292 | 4,089,723 | 3 | 3,556,619 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1292 | 3,634,909 | 2 | 3,556,619 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1300 | 3,622,844 | 2 | 3,556,619 | 2 | [r3] | [r1] | Â | Â | Â |
1325 | 3,160,494 | 2 | 3,160,494 | 2 | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1400 | 3,620,731 | 2 | 3,160,494 | 2 | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1453 | 3,609,260 | 2 | 3,160,494 | 2 | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1463 | 3,573,158 | 2 | 3,160,494 | 2 | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1516 | 3,561,687 | 2 | 3,160,494 | 2 | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
1954 | 3,885,494 | 3 | 3,160,494 | 2 | [r3] | [r3] | Â | Â | Â |
2104 | 3,069,424 | 1 | 3,069,424 | 1 | [r4] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2318 | 4,089,723 | 3 | 2,916,184 | 1 | [r1] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2446 | 3,294,678 | 2 | 2,916,184 | 1 | [r1] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2495 | 4,239,373 | 3 | 2,916,184 | 1 | [r1] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2495 | 3,160,494 | 2 | 2,916,184 | 1 | [r1] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2495 | 3,406,309 | 2 | 2,916,184 | 1 | [r1] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2545 | 3,364,723 | 2 | 2,916,184 | 1 | [r1] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2545 | 3,267,359 | 2 | 2,916,184 | 1 | [r1] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2617 | 2,435,494 | 1 | 2,435,494 | 1 | [r3] | Â | Â | Â | Â |
2617 | 2,435,494 | 1 | 2,435,494 | 1 | [r3] | Â | Â | Â | Â |