Table 10 Summary of results of IEEE 69-bus RDN (Case 5).

From: Optimized placement of distributed generators, capacitors, and EV charging stations in reconfigured radial distribution networks using enhanced artificial hummingbird algorithm

Parameters

Base Case

Fuzzy-COLAHA

[Proposed]

Fuzzy-AHA

[Studied]

Fuzzy-AOA

[Studied]

Fuzzy-WOA

[Studied]

Fuzzy-GA

[Studied]

Total APL(kW)

224.96

14.97

16.93

18.37

27.35

27.14

Total RPL(kVAr)

102.15

11.15

13.76

14.14

14.57

21.70

Tie switch number

69, 70, 71, 72, 73

17, 69, 72, 44, 11

45, 7, 14, 52, 12

71, 14, 8, 70, 41

4, 69, 19, 40, 22

56, 16, 39, 45, 22

DG location

-

14, 54, 62

23, 69, 63

61, 22, 12

16, 61, 56

8, 67, 62

DG size (kW)

-

765, 839, 1194

1267, 712, 1243

1247, 1130, 950

1234, 1218, 1267

1267, 10, 1267

DG size (kVAr)

-

371, 407, 578

614, 345, 602

604, 547, 460

598, 590, 614

614, 5, 614

SC location

-

8, 11, 2

69, 31, 27

39, 68, 16

12, 58, 44

55, 29, 12

SC size (kVAr)

-

200, 200, 400

100, 200, 300

200, 200, 200

200, 100, 200

300, 100, 500

EV location

-

2, 29, 53, 47, 11

4, 21, 29, 69, 46

53, 25, 23, 60, 11

15, 31, 37, 69, 18

8, 3, 69, 35, 34

Number of EV

-

38, 20, 13, 14, 20

30, 50, 10, 50, 20

30, 12, 42, 35, 18

50, 39, 11, 35, 39

10, 10, 10, 10, 50

Real power EV (kW)

-

247, 130, 84.5, 91, 130

195, 325, 65, 325, 130

195, 78, 273, 228, 117

325, 254, 72, 228, 254

65, 65, 65, 65, 325

Reactive power EV (kVAr)

-

120, 63, 41, 44, 63

94, 157, 31, 157, 63

94, 38, 132, 110, 57

157, 123, 35, 110, 123

31, 31, 31, 31, 157

S/S active power (kW)

4026.85

1701.36

1636.52

1383.76

1241.24

1869.44

S/S reactive power (kVAr)

2796.25

550.12

547.23

496.90

407.48

583.40

S/S power factor

0.8214

0.9515

0.9484

0.9412

0.9501

0.9546

Min. bus voltage (in p.u)

0.9090

0.9915

0.9905

0.9904

0.9876

0.9800

  1. *S/S stands for system