Table 15 Obtained score/fitness from proposed GWO-TLBO optimization and other algorithms (Design_1 to Design_11).

From: An integrative TLBO-driven hybrid grey wolf optimizer for the efficient resolution of multi-dimensional, nonlinear engineering problems

 

EBOwithCMAR

JSO

LSHADE_EpSin

LSHADE_SPACMA

GWO_TLBO

Function_name

Mean score

Std. deviation

Mean score

Std. deviation

Mean score

Std. deviation

Mean score

Std. deviation

Mean score

Std. deviation

SPECIAL1

265.7518118

3.055863424

278.6901749

16.65924439

281.1703239

13.43109105

279.2510794

9.868159314

263.9035466

0.00753526

SPECIAL2

3.48282E + 12

3.52206E + 12

4.05501E + 12

3.85278E + 12

4.13792E + 12

3.62813E + 12

3.65502E + 12

3.32679E + 12

3011.308041

6.306024589

SPECIAL3

530,096.5318

363,549.9391

608,225.3186

422,661.4687

577,964.0998

375,886.0236

638,905.9889

392,293.675

6095.339805

356.0635542

SPECIAL4

3.6873E + 14

3.55086E + 14

3.50867E + 14

3.52564E + 14

5.08087E + 14

3.74734E + 14

3.49732E + 14

4.00577E + 14

0.012777117

0.00012712

SPECIAL5

4.514457692

1.646557009

5.55076E + 13

1.68886E + 14

1.70766E + 13

7.07463E + 13

1.4605E + 14

3.3951E + 14

1.728777743

0.001662253

SPECIAL6

9.81363E + 15

1.14678E + 16

3.16762E + 16

2.74755E + 16

2.01547E + 16

9.65502E + 15

2.65435E + 16

2.52097E + 16

− 85,210.1042

108.9972277

SPECIAL7

0.794901158

0.128846729

0.78743162

0.136974799

0.818784246

0.120374843

0.917941578

0.204470674

0.390723857

0.000606993

SPECIAL8

0.005404929

0.008969283

0.009843161

0.018865803

0.002329176

0.002920018

0.006745933

0.008129104

1.40489E-12

1.62241E-12

SPECIAL9

6.70764E + 27

5.45805E + 27

9.48576E + 27

1.45824E + 28

9.97508E + 27

9.34573E + 27

9.08624E + 27

9.43195E + 27

1.992557459

0.010211129

SPECIAL10

8.274603933

1.128169692

8.190535732

1.531703424

8.427143491

1.477654842

8.885727363

1.647018959

1.303434116

0.000133539

SPECIAL11

0.015177921

0.003729515

0.017162337

0.004595796

0.018141456

0.006784385

0.017007964

0.006473704

0.006626015

5.20577E-08

Back to article page