Table 9 Results of the pairwise comparisons of seven models.
Metrics | Models | ECS-AdaBoost | ECSDNN | ECS-Stacking | CSNNE | CSCNN | CCS-CNN |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AUC-ROC | ECS-SDE | 0.01748 | 0.01381 | 0.04907 | 0.00693 | 0.55683 | 0.03423 |
ECS-AdaBoost | 0.85011 | 0.70504 | 0.70504 | 0.09879 | 0.77972 | ||
ECSDNN | 0.67454 | 0.77972 | 0.07003 | 0.70504 | |||
ECS-Stacking | 0.49033 | 0.27420 | 0.85011 | ||||
CSNNE | 0.03423 | 0.55683 | |||||
CSCNN | 0.20760 | ||||||
AUC-PR | ECS-SDE | 0.01748 | 0.00152 | 0.22850 | 0.02408 | 0.01748 | 0.22850 |
ECS-AdaBoost | 0.42581 | 0.22850 | 0.93959 | 1.00000 | 0.22850 | ||
ECSDNN | 0.04907 | 0.35957 | 0.42581 | 0.04907 | |||
ECS-Stacking | 0.27882 | 0.22850 | 1.00000 | ||||
CSNNE | 0.93959 | 0.27882 | |||||
CSCNN | 0.22850 | ||||||
BS+ | ECS-SDE | 0.01748 | 0.21092 | 0.01381 | 0.01381 | 0.59022 | 0.27882 |
ECS-AdaBoost | 0.21092 | 0.85011 | 0.82303 | 0.08170 | 0.16986 | ||
ECSDNN | 0.16986 | 0.13716 | 0.59022 | 0.85011 | |||
ECS-Stacking | 0.85011 | 0.05888 | 0.13716 | ||||
CSNNE | 0.04279 | 0.11291 | |||||
CSCNN | 0.70504 | ||||||
Save | ECS-SDE | 0.01381 | 0.17635 | 0.15807 | 0.03210 | 0.15807 | 0.00330 |
ECS-AdaBoost | 0.39034 | 0.44947 | 0.82303 | 0.44947 | 0.70504 | ||
ECSDNN | 0.89261 | 0.51706 | 0.89261 | 0.17635 | |||
ECS-Stacking | 0.59022 | 1.00000 | 0.20760 | ||||
CSNNE | 0.59022 | 0.51706 | |||||
CSCNN | 0.20760 | ||||||
BS– | ECS-SDE | 0.59022 | 0.08782 | 0.59022 | 0.74073 | 0.02853 | 0.06127 |
ECS-AdaBoost | 0.02408 | 0.22850 | 0.74073 | 0.01406 | 0.01748 | ||
ECSDNN | 0.30026 | 0.04206 | 0.70504 | 0.85011 | |||
ECS-Stacking | 0.38526 | 0.12344 | 0.22850 | ||||
CSNNE | 0.01748 | 0.02853 | |||||
CSCNN | 0.74073 |