Table 8 CEC2019 different function optimization indicators.
Function | Optimization indicator | DKCBKA | GO | NOA | PO | SOA | SSA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
FC1 | Min. | 1 | 1 | 2.1637E+08 | 1 | 1.0306E+00 | 1 |
Mean | 1 | 4.2238E+08 | 4.7517E+08 | 1 | 3.8301E+06 | 1 | |
Std. | 0 | 4.7827E+08 | 1.9054E+08 | 5.9344E−17 | 6.0493E+06 | 0 | |
FC2 | Min. | 4.1848E+00 | 4.2841E+00 | 1.4020E+04 | 4.2235E+00 | 5 | 5.0000E+00 |
Mean | 4.3750E+00 | 1.6764E+04 | 1.9023E+04 | 4.5012E+00 | 3.0909E+03 | 5.0000E+00 | |
Std. | 1.4536E−01 | 1.5260E+04 | 3.2965E+03 | 3.1097E−01 | 2.7167E+03 | 5.0944E−09 | |
FC3 | Min. | 1.000000017 | 1.4096E+00 | 1.0823E+01 | 1.4143E+00 | 4.5051E+00 | 1.4092E+00 |
Mean | 1.3955E+00 | 8.6849E+00 | 1.1833E+01 | 4.2123E+00 | 6.9551E+00 | 2.1849E+00 | |
Std. | 7.4697E−02 | 2.5938E+00 | 3.8518E−01 | 1.7249E+00 | 1.5707E+00 | 1.0621E+00 | |
FC4 | Min. | 8.9600E+00 | 2.5874E+01 | 1.0161E+02 | 1.3553E+01 | 4.5664E+01 | 3.1844E+01 |
Mean | 2.2897E+01 | 7.7498E+01 | 1.1893E+02 | 3.7823E+01 | 7.2076E+01 | 6.5937E+01 | |
Std. | 1.1907E+01 | 2.9727E+01 | 1.1409E+01 | 1.2806E+01 | 1.9509E+01 | 2.3839E+01 | |
FC5 | Min. | 1.1348E+00 | 1.1403E+00 | 5.0126E+01 | 1.2627E+00 | 3.1495E+01 | 1.9790E+00 |
Mean | 1.4864E+00 | 2.8990E+00 | 1.0989E+02 | 2.1977E+00 | 6.6455E+01 | 6.6793E+00 | |
Std. | 2.4535E−01 | 2.1391E+00 | 2.8961E+01 | 9.7002E−01 | 2.2127E+01 | 3.3662E+00 | |
FC6 | Min. | 2.2865E+00 | 9.5083E+00 | 1.0996E+01 | 3.3344E+00 | 7.7423E+00 | 8.2595E+00 |
Mean | 4.3633E+00 | 1.2117E+01 | 1.3398E+01 | 6.4015E+00 | 1.0332E+01 | 1.0544E+01 | |
Std. | 1.1171E+00 | 1.1399E+00 | 8.8722E−01 | 1.4872E+00 | 1.1462E+00 | 1.3750E+00 | |
FC7 | Min. | 2.4169E+02 | 1.0588E+03 | 2.1076E+03 | 3.5538E+02 | 1.3400E+03 | 7.8192E+02 |
Mean | 6.3606E+02 | 1.5035E+03 | 2.4035E+03 | 1.0227E+03 | 2.1270E+03 | 1.2890E+03 | |
Std. | 2.5670E+02 | 2.6591E+02 | 1.6866E+02 | 3.7526E+02 | 3.0874E+02 | 3.1111E+02 | |
FC8 | Min. | 2.5185E+00 | 4.1815E+00 | 4.9836E+00 | 3.4864E+00 | 4.0875E+00 | 3.8335E+00 |
Mean | 3.5087E+00 | 5.0728E+00 | 5.2594E+00 | 4.2373E+00 | 4.7497E+00 | 4.7602E+00 | |
Std. | 4.4290E−01 | 3.6765E−01 | 1.1538E−01 | 2.7424E−01 | 2.4012E−01 | 4.0788E−01 | |
FC9 | Min. | 1.0869E+00 | 1.1173E+00 | 3.3288E+00 | 1.1177E+00 | 1.2978E+00 | 1.1080E+00 |
Mean | 1.2575E+00 | 1.3269E+00 | 4.4102E+00 | 1.3016E+00 | 2.9348E+00 | 1.3460E+00 | |
Std. | 1.2710E−01 | 1.9621E−01 | 5.1402E−01 | 1.3761E−01 | 1.1256E+00 | 1.4708E−01 | |
FC10 | Min. | 1.0090E+00 | 2.0985E+01 | 2.1391E+01 | 2.1017E+01 | 2.1456E+01 | 2.0983E+01 |
Mean | 1.7389E+01 | 2.1006E+01 | 2.1760E+01 | 2.1136E+01 | 2.1590E+01 | 2.0985E+01 | |
Std. | 7.5180E+00 | 2.5630E−02 | 2.0506E−01 | 1.0135E−01 | 8.5954E−02 | 1.4984E−03 |
