Table 6 Qualitative comparison of reduced model performance parameters.

From: Constrained search space selection based optimization approach for enhanced reduced order approximation of interconnected power system models

Reduction method

Reduced model

Rise time

Transient Time

RMSE

IAE

ISE

IRE

Original system

4.5115e-13

15.5088

 

0.9969

Proposed model

\(\frac{{10.784{s^2} - 7.7438s+7.5338 \times {{10}^{ - 13}}}}{{5.457{s^3}+16.5184{s^2}+30.6793s+22.2031}}\)

1.5106e-14

5.9454

12.1124

4.4382

0.1630

0.9255

BTM PSO [39]

\(\frac{{1.074{s^2} - 0.3678s+0.001127}}{{{s^3}+1.227{s^2}+5.454s+0.4189}}\)

0.0023

35.3890

13.1658

13.9193

1.1835

0.5120

BTM MM [35]

\(\frac{{ - 1.185{s^2} - 0.01565s+1.63 \times {{10}^{ - 14}}}}{{{s^3}+1.227{s^2}+5.454s+0.4189}}\)

5.9064e-14

10.7890

9.4334

13.8070

5.3746

0.6104

RAM FDM [38]

\(\frac{{ - 0.04292{s^2} - 5.725 \times {{10}^{ - 4}}s+5.96 \times {{10}^{ - 16}}}}{{{s^3}+0.7511{s^2}+0.1878s+0.01532}}\)

6.1391e-12

35.2297

20.0942

10.4908

1.9847

0.0014

DPR CSF [48]

\(\frac{{ - 0.1221{s^2} - 0.001664s+1.732 \times {{10}^{ - 15}}}}{{{s^3}+1.47{s^2}+0.4766s+0.04452}}\)

4.2437e-12

30.5728

14.7212

9.3351

1.8383

0.0054

RA DT [49]

\(\frac{{ - 5.561 \times {{10}^8}{s^2} - 7.418 \times {{10}^6}s+3.245 \times {{10}^{ - 10}}}}{{(8.9083{s^3}+7.0977{s^2}+2.259s+0.1985) \times {{10}^9}}}\)

0

31.9332

17.8236

9.6095

1.8658

0.0028

BTM [50]

\(\frac{{1.276{s^2} - 1.045s+0.1127}}{{{s^3}+1.227{s^2}+5.454s+0.4189}}\)

0.2599

46.6217

22.2921

35.2833

5.5604

0.7749

DM FDM [51]

\(\frac{{ - 4.862 \times {{10}^8}{s^2} - 7.418 \times {{10}^6}s+7.722 \times {{10}^{ - 6}}}}{{(0.5895{s^3}+3.865{s^2}+5.615s+1.985) \times {{10}^8}}}\)

6.7057e-14

7.8734

16.2519

20.4098

11.7772

5.4834

TMM FDM [52]

\(\frac{{ - 0.08432{s^2} - 0.001193s}}{{{s^3}+0.6417{s^2}+0.2538s+0.03194}}\)

0

18.5030

15.8887

9.2253

1.7016

0.0069

SEM SRAM [53]

\(\frac{{ - 4.648 \times {{10}^5}{s^2} - 6200s+6.454 \times {{10}^{ - 9}}}}{{(13.13{s^3}+8.152{s^2}+2.033s+0.1659) \times {{10}^6}}}\)

5.5849e-12

34.3205

21.1364

10.7207

2.0160

0.0012

  1. * Cauer second form (CSF), Routh array (RA), direct truncation (DT), differentiation method (DM), time moment matching (TMM), simplified RAM (SRAM).