Table 6 Qualitative comparison of reduced model performance parameters.
Reduction method | Reduced model | Rise time | Transient Time | RMSE | IAE | ISE | IRE |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Original system | 4.5115e-13 | 15.5088 | Â | 0.9969 | |||
Proposed model | \(\frac{{10.784{s^2} - 7.7438s+7.5338 \times {{10}^{ - 13}}}}{{5.457{s^3}+16.5184{s^2}+30.6793s+22.2031}}\) | 1.5106e-14 | 5.9454 | 12.1124 | 4.4382 | 0.1630 | 0.9255 |
BTM PSO [39] | \(\frac{{1.074{s^2} - 0.3678s+0.001127}}{{{s^3}+1.227{s^2}+5.454s+0.4189}}\) | 0.0023 | 35.3890 | 13.1658 | 13.9193 | 1.1835 | 0.5120 |
BTM MM [35] | \(\frac{{ - 1.185{s^2} - 0.01565s+1.63 \times {{10}^{ - 14}}}}{{{s^3}+1.227{s^2}+5.454s+0.4189}}\) | 5.9064e-14 | 10.7890 | 9.4334 | 13.8070 | 5.3746 | 0.6104 |
RAM FDM [38] | \(\frac{{ - 0.04292{s^2} - 5.725 \times {{10}^{ - 4}}s+5.96 \times {{10}^{ - 16}}}}{{{s^3}+0.7511{s^2}+0.1878s+0.01532}}\) | 6.1391e-12 | 35.2297 | 20.0942 | 10.4908 | 1.9847 | 0.0014 |
DPR CSF [48] | \(\frac{{ - 0.1221{s^2} - 0.001664s+1.732 \times {{10}^{ - 15}}}}{{{s^3}+1.47{s^2}+0.4766s+0.04452}}\) | 4.2437e-12 | 30.5728 | 14.7212 | 9.3351 | 1.8383 | 0.0054 |
RA DT [49] | \(\frac{{ - 5.561 \times {{10}^8}{s^2} - 7.418 \times {{10}^6}s+3.245 \times {{10}^{ - 10}}}}{{(8.9083{s^3}+7.0977{s^2}+2.259s+0.1985) \times {{10}^9}}}\) | 0 | 31.9332 | 17.8236 | 9.6095 | 1.8658 | 0.0028 |
BTM [50] | \(\frac{{1.276{s^2} - 1.045s+0.1127}}{{{s^3}+1.227{s^2}+5.454s+0.4189}}\) | 0.2599 | 46.6217 | 22.2921 | 35.2833 | 5.5604 | 0.7749 |
DM FDM [51] | \(\frac{{ - 4.862 \times {{10}^8}{s^2} - 7.418 \times {{10}^6}s+7.722 \times {{10}^{ - 6}}}}{{(0.5895{s^3}+3.865{s^2}+5.615s+1.985) \times {{10}^8}}}\) | 6.7057e-14 | 7.8734 | 16.2519 | 20.4098 | 11.7772 | 5.4834 |
TMM FDM [52] | \(\frac{{ - 0.08432{s^2} - 0.001193s}}{{{s^3}+0.6417{s^2}+0.2538s+0.03194}}\) | 0 | 18.5030 | 15.8887 | 9.2253 | 1.7016 | 0.0069 |
SEM SRAM [53] | \(\frac{{ - 4.648 \times {{10}^5}{s^2} - 6200s+6.454 \times {{10}^{ - 9}}}}{{(13.13{s^3}+8.152{s^2}+2.033s+0.1659) \times {{10}^6}}}\) | 5.5849e-12 | 34.3205 | 21.1364 | 10.7207 | 2.0160 | 0.0012 |