Table 3 Three separate models testing different social support types as moderators between AI chat type (independent variable) and occupational self-efficacy (dependent variable).

From: AI feedback and workplace social support in enhancing occupational self-efficacy: a randomized controlled trial in Japan

 

Model 1 (informational support)

Model 2 (instrumental support)

Model 3 (emotional support)

Estimate

95% CI

SE

β

Estimate

95% CI

SE

β

Estimate

95% CI

SE

β

Fixed effects

            

(Intercept)

3.10***

[2.88, 3.31]

0.11

 

3.09***

[2.87, 3.31]

0.11

 

3.13***

[2.92, 3.33]

0.10

 

Time point (pre/post)

0.05

[− 0.09, 0.19]

0.07

0.11

0.05

[− 0.09, 0.19]

0.07

0.12

0.08

[− 0.06, 0.22]

0.07

0.12

Chat type

− 0.11

[− 0.41, 0.19]

0.15

0.01

− 0.10

[− 0.40, 0.20]

0.15

0.02

− 0.17

[− 0.44, 0.11]

0.14

− 0.04

Social support

0.06

[− 0.12, 0.24]

0.09

0.20

0.02

[− 0.16, 0.21]

0.09

0.18

0.23*

[0.01, 0.45]

0.12

0.42

Chat type × social support

0.15

[− 0.12, 0.43]

0.14

0.07

0.22

[− 0.06, 0.49]

0.14

0.09

0.18

[− 0.14, 0.49]

0.16

0.03

Time point × chat type

0.24*

[0.05, 0.43]

0.10

0.08

0.25*

[0.06, 0.44]

0.10

0.08

0.21*

[0.02, 0.40]

0.10

0.07

Time point × social support

0.06

[− 0.05, 0.18]

0.06

0.01

0.07

[− 0.05, 0.19]

0.06

− 0.01

0.22**

[0.07, 0.37]

0.08

0.05

Time point × chat type × social support

− 0.10

[− 0.28, 0.07]

0.09

− 0.04

− 0.16

[− 0.34, 0.01]

0.09

− 0.06

− 0.24*

[− 0.46, − 0.03]

0.11

− 0.07

Random effects

            

Random intercept variance

0.47

   

0.47

   

0.39

   

Residual variance

0.12

   

0.12

   

0.12

   
  1. All three models use Occupational Self-Efficacy as the dependent variable. The key difference across the models is the type of social support variable tested: Model 1 includes Informational Support, Model 2 includes Instrumental Support, and Model 3 includes Emotional Support. All other predictors and control variables remain the same across models.
  2. CI confidence interval, SE standard error.
  3. *p < .05, **p < .01, ***p < .001.