Table 6 Wilcoxon’s signed rank test on CEC-2022 test suite (Dimension = 10).

From: Hybrid adaptive ant lion optimization with traditional controllers for driving and controlling switched reluctance motors to enhance performance

Function

HAALO vs PSO

HAALO vs PPSO

HAALO vs GA

HAALO vs ALO

HAALO vs RIME

HAALO vs GEO

HAALO vs MSACO

HAALO vs DBO

HAALO vs FPA

HAALO vs SHO

HAALO vs LUS

F22-01

1.5E−09

9.3E−09

4.9E−06

2.6E−06

4.6E−06

9.8E−06

4.9E−03

3.3E−03

6.3E−03

2.4E−03

7.7E−04

F22-02

1.3E−09

1.3E−09

1.5E−06

1.4E−06

6.4E−06

1.8E−06

3.5E−03

9.0E−03

4.7E−03

6.7E−03

1.7E−03

F22-03

1.9E−09

4.1E−10

1.7E−06

2.8E−06

1.8E−06

9.0E−07

1.2E−03

4.6E−03

2.1E−03

3.6E−03

5.0E−03

F22-04

6.9E−09

3.9E−10

8.0E−06

6.3E−06

8.3E−07

8.7E−06

9.2E−03

6.2E−04

2.8E−03

8.1E−03

7.5E−03

F22-05

1.8E−09

2.1E−09

3.7E−06

4.9E−06

6.2E−06

3.7E−06

4.6E−03

7.5E−03

3.8E−04

2.5E−03

7.1E−03

F22-06

9.0E−09

5.1E−09

5.3E−06

1.1E−06

4.5E−06

5.3E−06

2.4E−03

2.7E−03

3.8E−03

2.1E−04

3.2E−03

F22-07

2.1E−09

3.3E−09

1.2E−06

8.9E−06

5.9E−06

6.8E−06

7.9E−03

5.0E−03

8.8E−04

5.4E−03

5.9E−03

F22-08

7.5E−09

4.3E−09

1.3E−06

2.8E−06

3.6E−06

6.5E−06

5.7E−03

3.6E−03

9.9E−03

6.1E−03

2.4E−03

F22-09

1.0E−09

1.5E−09

2.5E−06

1.6E−06

1.9E−06

2.9E−06

1.7E−03

9.0E−03

8.1E−04

5.2E−03

4.1E−03

F22-10

9.8E−09

1.1E−09

4.0E−06

9.7E−06

8.7E−06

8.2E−06

2.6E−03

1.7E−03

6.7E−03

9.3E−03

5.6E−03

F22-11

5.7E−09

2.8E−09

7.7E−06

1.9E−06

3.2E−06

4.3E−06

5.1E−03

2.4E−03

1.2E−03

6.1E−03

2.9E−03

F22-12

5.8E−09

1.5E−09

4.8E−06

5.3E−06

5.3E−07

3.4E−06

1.4E−03

6.4E−04

9.9E−03

3.2E−03

8.1E−03

Back to article page