Table 7 Wilcoxon’s signed rank test on CEC 2022 test suite (Dimension = 20).
Function | HAALO vs PSO | HAALO vs PPSO | HAALO vs GA | HAALO vs ALO | HAALO vs RIME | HAALO vs GEO | HAALO vs MSACO | HAALO vs DBO | HAALO vs FPA | HAALO vs SHO | HAALO vs LUS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
F22-01 | 2.5E−09 | 6.8E−09 | 7.6E−06 | 6.0E−06 | 4.7E−06 | 4.1E−06 | 3.5E−03 | 9.3E−03 | 8.3E−03 | 9.7E−03 | 1.3E−03 |
F22-02 | 7.3E−09 | 9.4E−09 | 1.8E−06 | 6.7E−07 | 7.4E−06 | 5.7E−06 | 8.4E−03 | 1.4E−03 | 8.0E−03 | 2.0E−03 | 1.6E−03 |
F22-03 | 1.6E−09 | 8.1E−09 | 6.7E−06 | 5.2E−06 | 3.6E−06 | 8.8E−06 | 3.9E−03 | 8.2E−03 | 4.4E−03 | 3.8E−03 | 4.6E−03 |
F022-4 | 3.0E−09 | 7.5E−09 | 5.0E−06 | 2.3E−06 | 9.0E−06 | 3.8E−06 | 5.4E−03 | 9.1E−03 | 6.2E−03 | 1.2E−03 | 9.4E−03 |
F22-05 | 6.3E−09 | 3.3E−09 | 1.4E−06 | 7.9E−06 | 6.2E−06 | 5.3E−06 | 8.9E−03 | 7.9E−03 | 1.5E−03 | 3.1E−03 | 2.5E−03 |
F22-06 | 7.4E−09 | 3.4E−10 | 5.7E−06 | 7.6E−06 | 8.8E−06 | 3.4E−06 | 8.2E−03 | 1.1E−03 | 8.5E−03 | 1.3E−03 | 4.0E−03 |
F22-07 | 8.0E−09 | 1.5E−09 | 2.3E−06 | 7.2E−06 | 7.2E−06 | 6.4E−06 | 6.9E−03 | 5.4E−03 | 2.5E−03 | 3.5E−03 | 1.8E−03 |
F22-08 | 9.1E−09 | 5.8E−09 | 4.0E−06 | 4.6E−06 | 9.5E−06 | 1.5E−06 | 5.9E−03 | 5.1E−03 | 6.1E−03 | 1.9E−04 | 8.7E−03 |
F22-09 | 9.3E−09 | 5.7E−09 | 7.0E−06 | 9.2E−06 | 7.1E−06 | 1.5E−06 | 5.8E−03 | 6.1E−03 | 4.2E−03 | 7.4E−03 | 9.3E−03 |
F22-10 | 9.3E−09 | 4.5E−09 | 1.1E−06 | 9.8E−06 | 8.4E−06 | 1.3E−06 | 9.2E−03 | 8.7E−03 | 5.2E−03 | 5.9E−03 | 4.0E−03 |
F22-11 | 5.5E−10 | 3.4E−09 | 8.0E−06 | 5.6E−08 | 3.3E−06 | 4.0E−06 | 5.4E−03 | 9.2E−03 | 3.5E−03 | 3.5E−03 | 7.4E−03 |
F22-12 | 4.5E−09 | 2.2E−09 | 4.5E−06 | 1.4E−06 | 1.8E−06 | 5.0E−06 | 4.2E−03 | 9.1E−03 | 3.6E−03 | 5.8E−03 | 6.3E−03 |
