Table 3 Robustness test results.

From: How does inter-provincial trade promote economic growth? Empirical evidence from Chinese provinces

Variables

Robustness test 1

Robustness test 2

Robustness test 3

Robustness test 4

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

In-migration area

Out-migration area

lntrade

0.248*** (4.20)

0.067*** (3.32)

0.077* (2.07)

0.261*** (4.05)

 

lnretail_sales

    

0.341*** (4.88)

lninterna_trade

0.047** (2.07)

0.021 (1.39)

0.058 (1.06)

0.054** (2.54)

0.027 (1.11)

lnpatents

0.059** (2.45)

0.003 (0.27)

0.128*** (9.62)

0.034 (1.22)

−0.018 (−0.75)

lncap

0.139** (2.70)

0.081*** (3.45)

0.257*** (5.49)

0.202*** (4.33)

0.243*** (3.72)

lnh_cap

1.035*** (3.00)

0.435*** (3.61)

1.120*** (3.66)

1.090** (2.83)

0.907*** (2.86)

Constant

2.563** (2.57)

6.928*** (18.97)

3.374** (3.04)

2.900** (2.79)

3.315*** (3.70)

Observations

638

638

198

440

638

R-squared

0.994

0.998

0.993

0.990

0.991

Fixed effect

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

  1. *, ** and *** denote p < 0.10, p < 0.05 and p < 0.01, and t-value is shown in brackets.