Table 4 Information regarding the ethical approvals, specific terms, licenses, applicability concerns, and the risk of bias in the ground truth annotations of the included datasets
Dataset No. | Ethical approval | Specific terms and licenses | Applicability concern | Risk of bias in the ground truth annotations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
1. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
2. | Not reported | CC BY NC 3.0 | Moderate | Low |
3. | Ethical approval was obtained from the Tufts University Institutional Research Board (IRB ID MODCR-01-12631). | Extracts of Data Use Terms • Researcher shall use the Database only for non-commercial research and educational purposes • Tufts University nor Panetta’s Vision and Sensing System Lab makes no representations or warranties regarding the Database • Researcher accepts full responsibility for his or her use of the Database • The Panetta’s vision and sensing systems lab reserves the right to revise, amend, alter or delete the information provided herein at any time, but shall not be responsible for or liable in respect of any such revisions, amendments, alterations or deletions • No permission is granted to reproduce the database or post into any webpage or any other storage means | Low | Moderate |
4. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
5. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | Low |
6. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
7. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
8. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
9. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | – |
10. | Not reported | Not reported | Moderate | – |
11. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
12. | Not reported | CC0 1.0 | Moderate | High |
13. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
14. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
15. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | Moderate |
16. | Not reported | CC BY-SA 4.0 | Moderate | – |
17. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | High | High |
18. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
19. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
20. | Ethical approval and patients’ consent has been obtained. | CC0 1.0 | Low | Low |
21. | All the necessary permissions have been obtained from the ethics committee. | CC0 1.0 and CC-BY | Low | Low |
22. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
23. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
24. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | – |
25. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
26. | Not reported | CC BY-SA 3.0 | Moderate | – |
27. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
28. | Informed Consent: All patients provided their consent in accordance with the dental ethical principles. | CC BY 4.0 | Low | High |
29. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
30. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
31. | Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethics Committee of China-Japan Union Hospital of Jilin University [#2024011704]. | Not reported | Moderate | Low |
32. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
33. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
34. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
35. | Not reported | MIT | Moderate | High |
36. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
37. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
38. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
39. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
40. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
41. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
42. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
43. | Ethical approval of the institution was obtained. | CC BY 4.0 | Low | Low |
44. | Ethical review and approval for this study were waived due to it being retrospective and the images were taken for reasons unrelated to this study. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants. | CC BY 4.0 | Low | – |
45. | Not reported | CC0 1.0 | Moderate | High |
46. | Not reported | Not reported | High | Low |
47. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
48. | Not reported | CC0 1.0 | Moderate | High |
49. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
50. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
51. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
52. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
53. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
54. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
55. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
56. | Not reported | CC0 1.0 | Moderate | High |
57. | Not reported | Not reported | High | Low |
58. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
59. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
60. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | Low |
61. | Not reported | CC0 1.0 | Moderate | High |
62. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
63. | Not reported | CC0 1.0 | Moderate | High |
64. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
65. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
66. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
67. | Not reported | Not reported | High | Low |
68. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
69. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
70. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
71. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | – |
72. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
73. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
74. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
75. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
76. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
77. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | – |
78. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
79. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | – |
80. | Not reported | CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 | Moderate | High |
81. | Ethical approval was obtained from the Institutional Review Board of China Medical University Hospital. (CMUH 107-REC3-092). | CC BY 4.0 | Low | – |
82. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
83. | Ethical approval was obtained from Comitato Etico dell’Area Vasta Emilia Nord (Approval Number 1374/2020/OSS/ESTMO SIRER ID 1275 - NAI-CBCT-D). | Not reported | Moderate | Low |
84. | Ethical approval of was obtained from the Medical Ethics Committee of Sichuan Provincial People’s Hospital and the University of Electronic Science and Technology Hospital Research Ethics Committee (No. 2022YR014). | CC BY-NC-ND | Low | Low |
85. | Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethical Committee of the Medical Faculty of the University of Heidelberg under Application No. S-039/2016. | Not reported | Moderate | – |
86. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | – |
87. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
88. | Not reported | CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 | Moderate | Low |
89. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | Moderate |
90. | Not reported | CC BY-NC 4.0 | Moderate | Low |
91. | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
92. | Not reported | Not reported | High | – |
93. | Not reported | CC BY NC 3.0 | Moderate | Low |
94. | Ethical approval was obtained from the Research Ethics Committee of the Hospital Universitário Cassiano Antonio de Moraes da Universidade Federal do EspĂrito Santo under registration no. 5,022,438 | CC BY 4.0 | Low | Low |
95. | Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethical Committee of Human Studies of Institute of Advanced Study in Science and Technology, Guwahati, Assam with registration number IEC (HS)/IASST/1082/ 2014-15/2. | CC BY 4.0 | Low | Moderate |
96. | Ethics approval was obtained from the Ethics Committee on the Use of Animals under protocol numbers 038/09 and A016/21 at the Federal University of Uberlândia, Brazil. | Not reported | Moderate | Low |
97. | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | High |
98. | Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethics Committee (certificate number CAAE - 39212420.9.0000.5347). | Not reported | Moderate | Low |
99. | Not reported | Apache 2.0 | Moderate | High |
100 | Ethical approval was obtained from the Health Research Authority (HRA) and the Joint Research Management Ofce (JRMO) (LREC 22/PR/0058). | CC BY 4.0 | Low | Moderate |
101 | Not reported | CC BY 4.0 | Moderate | Moderate |
102 | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
103 | Not reported | Not reported | High | High |
104 | Ethical approval was obtained from the Zgoda nr KB-14/22 wystawiona przez Bioethics Committee at the Regional Medical Chamber in Gdańsk | CC BY 4.0 | Low | High |
105 | Not reported | CC BY-NC | Moderate | High |
