Table 1 Effects of different head motion correction methods on Results of fMRI

From: Improving brain difference identification in autism spectrum disorder through enhanced head motion correction in ICA-AROMA

Study

Methods of fMRI

Methods for Head Motion Correction

Dataset Sources

Results of fMRI (Hypoconnectivity/Hyperconnectivity)

Paakkiet al. 15

ReHo

FSL 3.3

University Hospital of Oulu

Right superior temporal sulcus, inferior and middle frontal gyri, bilateral cerebellar crus I, right insula and right postcentral gyrus/ right thalamus, left inferior frontal and anterior subcallosal gyrus and bilateral cerebellar lobule

Maximo et al. 16

ReHo

AFNI and FSL with GSR

University of California San Diego

Cingulate and medial frontal/visual regions; underconnectivity:

Nair et al. 22,23,27

ReHo

AFNI, FSL and RMSD

SDSU of ABIDE

Cingulate gyrus/ posterior, visual regions

Hagen et al. 17

ICA

SPM5

University of Cambridge

Salience network: insula, a medial temporal lobe network, the amygdala

Mueller et al. 18

FEAT/ICA/ MELODIC

FSL 4.16 and AFNI

University Munich

Bilateral superior temporal gyrus, temporal lobe

Bos et al. 19

ICA of GIFT

SPM8

University Medical Center in Utrecht

Insula connectivity increased with age in ASD, whereas it decreased in typically developing children.

Guo et al. 20

AFNI

Data-Driven Wavelet Despiking

University of Cambridge

ASD higher semi-metric percentages (SMPs)

King et al. 21

FreeSurfer (v6.0.0)

Volume censoring (scrubbing)

ABIDE I and (ABIDE II)

Homotopic, default network, salience network, long-range connections, and corticostriatal

  1. *Notes: ReHo- Regional Homogeneity, FSL- fMRI Software Library, AFNI- Analysis of Functional NeuroImages software (AFNI; Cox, 1996), GSR-Global Signal Regression, RMSD-Root Mean Square of Displacement, SPM8-Wellcome Dept. of Cognitive Neurology (http://www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk), FEAT- FMRI Expert Analysis Tool, MELODIC- Multivariate Exploratory Linear Optimized Decomposition into Independent Components software 3.10, GIFT-Group version of Independent Components Analysis fMRI Toolbox (http://icatb.sourcefourge.net, version 2.e), SPM- Statistical Parametric Mapping (www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm), ABIDE- Autism Brain Imaging Data Exchange, DCSD-University of California San Diego.