Table 10 Typological characteristics comparison of IDCL

From: Spatial form and formation process of irrigation district cultural landscapes: the Songgu irrigation District, Zhejiang, China

Irrigation Type

Case

Natural Environment

Irrigated Area

Unit Composition

Degree of Human Intervention

Spatial Characteristics

Governance Mode

Surface water irrigation

Songgu IDCL

River valley

small- to medium-sized

Multiple Parallel Units

Moderate: Channel excavation

Hierarchical linear canal network (main canal–branch canal–minor canal)

Multi-level: government, local, community

Dujiangyan

Large river basin

Large

Single Unit

Low: Adaptive diversion without weirs

Hierarchical linear canal network relying on natural riverbed

Composite governance: government and local

Hani terraces

Mountainous and hilly

Small

Multiple Dispersed Units

High: Embankment construction, terracing

Hierarchical terraced canal network

Family or clan-based autonomy

Groundwater irrigation

Karez

Arid region

small- to medium-sized

Multiple Dispersed Units

High: Wells and tunnels

Point–line network of vertical wells and sloping tunnels

Religious or community autonomy

Composite irrigation

Jiangnan Jitang

Coastal plain

small- to medium-sized

Multiple Networked Units

High: Embankments and pond construction

Networked pond–field system

Community self-governance