Table 4 Volatile organic compounds quantified for resin bed 3D printers from the four identified studies during the literature search [32, 38, 56, 92] Concentrations are given as µg/m3 - micrograms per cubic metre or as µg/h – micrograms per hour.
VOC | Study | Emission rate, clear resin, unspecified manufacturer, µg/h, approximate | Concentration (range), clear resin, Formlabs µg/m3 | Concentration (range), castable wax resin, Formlabs µg/m3 | Concentration (Standard deviation), Formlabs grey photopolymer resin µg/m3 | Measurement conditions | Health impacts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2-Butanone | Väisänen, 2022 | 6 µg/m3 | <1 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Nose, throat and eye irritations | ||
2-Ethylpiperazine | Väisänen, 2022 | 4 (4–5) µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Non-hazardous | |||
2-Hydroxyethyl methacrylate | Zhang [36] | Print ~330 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Skin, and respiratory irritants | |||
2-Hydroxypropyl methacrylate | Väisänen, 2022 | 6 (2–8) µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Skin and respiratory irritant | |||
2-Hydroxypropyl methacrylate | Bowers, [38] | SLA - 18.1–21.9 µg/m3 DLP - 31.2 (1.5) µg/m3 | 12.85 m3 steel chamber | Skin and respiratory irritant | |||
2-Hydroxypropyl methacrylate | Zhang [36] | Print −2800 µg/h Wash - 1800 µg/h Cure - 1200 µg/h | 1 m3 camber | Skin and respiratory irritant | |||
2-Methyl-2,4-pentanediol | Zhang [36] | Wash ~40 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Skin and eye irritation, reproductive toxicity | |||
2-Pentanol, 4-methyl | Zhang [36] | Wash ~50 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Severe eye damage, respiratory organ toxicity | |||
2,6-Di-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol | Zhang [36] | Wash 60 µg/h Cure ~100 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Toxic to aquatic life | |||
Acetaldehyde | Väisänen, 2022 | 2 µg/m3 | 1 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Eye irritation, carcinogen, germ cell mutagen, respiratory organ toxicity | ||
Acetaldehyde | Bowers, [38] | SLA - 10.0–16.3 µg/m3 DLP - 8.3 (1.4) µg/m3 | 12.85 m3 steel chamber | Eye irritation, carcinogen, germ cell mutagen, respiratory organ toxicity | |||
Acetone | Väisänen, 2022 | 3 µg/m3 | 2 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Eye irritation, central nervous system toxicity, drowsiness | ||
Acetone | Zisook [56] | 245 ppbv =581 µg/m3 | 28 m3 sampling room | Eye irritation, central nervous system toxicity, drowsiness | |||
Acetone | Bowers, [38] | SLA - 2.7–10.1 µg/m DLP - 13.6 (1.5) µg/m3 | 12.85 m3 steel chamber | Eye irritation, central nervous system toxicity, drowsiness | |||
Acetone | Zhang [36] | Print ~280 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Eye irritation, central nervous system toxicity, drowsiness | |||
Alpha pinene | Väisänen, 2022 | 6 (5–7) µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Oral toxicity, skin irritation, aquatic hazard | |||
Benzaldehyde | Väisänen, 2022 | <1 µg/m3 | <1 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Acute toxicity, skin and eye irritation, reproductive toxicity, respiratory toxicity | ||
Butyraldehyde | Väisänen, 2022 | 4 µg/m3 | 3 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Eye irritation, flammable | ||
Crotonic anhydride | Zhang [36] | Print ~180 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Skin corrosive | |||
Dodecane,2,6,11-trimethyl | Zhang [36] | Cure ~350 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Aquatic hazard | |||
Ethanol | Bowers, [38] | SLA - 0.02−4.5 µg/m3 DLP - 7.4 (3.2) µg/m3 | 12.85 m3 steel chamber | Eye irritation, flammable | |||
Ethyl methacrylate | Väisänen, 2022 | 4 (4–5) µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Skin corrosion, eye damage, respiratory toxicity | |||
Formaldehyde | Väisänen, 2022 | 1 µg/m3 | 1 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Fatal if swallowed, skin corrosion, carcinogen, germ cell mutagen, organ toxicity | ||
Hexaldehyde | Väisänen, 2022 | 4 µg/m3 | 1 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Skin and eye irritation | ||
Isopropanol | Zisook [56] | 560 ppbv =1374 µg/m3 | 28 m3 sampling room | Eye irritation, respiratory toxicity | |||
Isopropanol | Zhang [36] | Wash 87729 µg/h Cure ~1100 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Eye irritation, respiratory toxicity | |||
Methylene chloride | Bowers, [38] | SLA - 0.03–16.0 µg/m3 DLP - 3.4 (5.4) µg/m3 | 12.85 m3 steel chamber | Skin and eye irritation, carcinogen, central nervous system toxicity | |||
Methyl-methacrylate | Väisänen, 2022 | 6 (5–7) µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Skin irritation, respiratory toxicity | |||
Nonanal | Väisänen, 2022 | 13 (11–14) µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Skin irritation | |||
Propionaldehyde | Väisänen, 2022 | 1 µg/m3 | 1 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Oral toxicity, skin corrosion, respiratory toxicity | ||
Propylene glycol | Zhang [36] | Print ~350 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Non-hazardous | |||
Styrene | Bowers, [38] | SLA - <1.52 µg/m3 DLP - 4.5 µg/m3 | 12.85 m3 steel chamber | Acute toxicity, reproductive toxicity, respiratory and hearing organ toxicity, fatal if swallowed | |||
Undecane, 3,7-dimethyl | Zhang [36] | Cure ~60 µg/h | 1 m3 chamber | Unknown | |||
Total carbonyl | Väisänen, 2022 | 21 µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Additive effects from all VOCs present | |||
TVOC | Väisänen, 2022 | 41 (32–48) µg/m3 | 46 (43–51) µg/m3 | 52 m3 3D printing lab | Additive effects from all VOCs present |