Table 3 Neuroimaging studies of poverty.
Study, location | Participants | Mean age (SD; range) % Female | Exposure | Study design; covariates | Primary findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Poverty | |||||
Butterworth et al. [102] Australia | 431 participants from PATH study | 46.7 (0.07; 44–48) 65.8% | Financial hardship questions | Cross sectional Covariates: age, sex | Current financial hardship was associated with smaller left and right hippocampal and amygdala volumes |
Chan et al. [103] USA | 304 participants | 20–59 60.7% | Family income | Cross sectional Covariates: age, sex, childhood SES, mental health and cognitive ability | Current SES was related to segregation of large-scale functional brain networks and thinner mean cortical grey matter. |
Noble et al. [94] USA | 1099 participants from PING study | 11.9 (4.9; 3–20) 48.3% | Family income | Cross sectional Covariates: age, sex, scanner site, and genetic ancestry factor | In children from lower income families, even small differences in income were linked to significant differences in surface area, whereas in children from higher income families, similar income changes were associated with smaller differences in surface area. |
Kim et al. [98] USA | 7569 participants from the ABCD cohort | 9.91 (0.52; 9–10) 47.5% | Income-to-needs ratio | Cross sectional Covariates: sex, race, parental educational level, study site, baseline psychiatric problems | Living in poverty was associated with less cortical surface area in the left superior temporal gyrus, left fusiform gyrus, right lateral occipital cortex, and right middle frontal gyrus. And smaller cortical volumes in the left superior temporal gyrus, postcentral gyrus, lateral occipital cortex, lateral orbitofrontal cortex, right lateral occipital cortex, transverse temporal gyrus, and rostral middle frontal gyrus. |
White et al. [105] USA | 172 participants | 13.49 (0.52; 12–15) 65.7% | Income-to-needs ratio | Cross sectional Covariates: age, sex, race | Larger response in brain regions implicated in attention to reward and loss cues and to reward and loss feedback. |
Javanbakth et al. [100] USA | 52 participants from longitudinal cohort | 23.6 (1.2; 22–25) 46.1% | Income-to-needs ratio | Longitudinal Covariates: age, sex | Childhood poverty, independent of concurrent adult income, was associated with higher amygdala and medial prefrontal cortical and with decreased left amygdala and medial prefrontal cortex functional connectivity. |
Luby et al. [93] USA | 145 participants from Preschool Depression cohort | 9.78 (1.29; 6–12) 51% | Income-to-needs ratio | Longitudinal Covariates: age, sex, pubertal status, history of psychiatric disorders and psychotropic medication use | Poverty was associated with smaller cortical grey matter and hippocampal and amygdala volumes. |
Hair et al. [99] USA | 389 participants from Normal Brain Development cohort | 12 (4–22) 52.5% | Income-to-needs ratio | Longitudinal Covariates: birth weight, race, family size, and maternal education. | Children from poor families had structural differences in the frontal lobe, temporal lobe, and hippocampus. |
Kim et al. [101] USA | 49 participants from longitudinal cohort | Poverty measured at 9 years. MRI at 24 | Family income | Longitudinal Covariates: Current income | Adults with lower family income at age 9 exhibited reduced ventrolateral and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex activity and failure to suppress amygdala activation at age 24. |
Hair et al. [99] USA | 486 participants from Normal Brain Development cohort | 10.1 (5.54; 0–20) 51.9% | Income | Longitudinal Covariates: birth weight, site | Structural differences in grey matter development for children living in or near poverty, first detected during childhood (age 2.5–6.5 years), evolve throughout adolescence. |
McDermott et al. [95] USA | 623 participants from longitudinal cohort | First scan: 12 (4; 5.2–25.4) 47.9% | Hollingshead SES scale | Longitudinal Covariates: age, sex | Higher SES is associated with areal expansion of lateral prefrontal, anterior cingulate, lateral temporal, and superior parietal cortices and ventrolateral thalamic, and medial amygdalo-hippocampal subregions. |