Table 3 Conditional growth mixture modeling (GMM) results of depressive symptom trajectories.

From: The interrelations between psychological outcome trajectories and resource changes amid large-scale disasters: A growth mixture modeling analysis

  

Reference class

Class

 

Chronic distress

Delayed distress

Recovery

Resilience

 

Covariates

OR (95% CI)

OR (95% CI)

OR (95% CI)

OR (95% CI)

Chronic distress

Demographics

Gender

Male

1

1

1

 

Female

1.176 (0.476, 2.905)

0.664 (0.279, 1.584)

1.411 (0.759, 2.622)

Age

55 or above

1

1

1

 

45–54

3.500 (0.119, 103.211)

7.198 (0.491, 105.425)

4.841 (0.451, 51.924)

 

35–44

3.778 (0.161, 88.814)

13.043 (1.042, 163.319)

16.508 (1.665, 163.707)

 

25–34

2.993 (0.123, 73.089)

13.403 (1.033, 173.854)

19.207 (1.841, 200.429)

 

15–24

1.308 (0.051, 33.299)

15.331 (1.061, 221.491)

25.761 (2.310, 287.275)

Education

Tertiary or above

1

1

1

 

Secondary or below

1.113 (0.392, 3.157)

0.671 (0.243, 1.849)

1.732 (0.829, 3.617)

Marital status

Married

1

1

1

 

Single/divorced/widowed

0.951 (0.273, 3.317)

0.758 (0.274, 2.101)

1.188 (0.545, 2.590)

Employment

Employed

1

1

1

 

Dependent

2.820 (0.753, 10.568)

1.073 (0.330, 3.492)

0.738 (0.293, 1.863)

 

Unemployed

2.001 (0.285, 14.073)

0.519 (0.121, 2.223)

1.382 (0.431, 4.424)

Income†

$60,000 or above

1

1

1

 

$40,000–$59,999

1.295 (0.347, 4.828)

0.906 (0.274, 2.992)

0.511 (0.211, 1.233)

 

$20,000–$39,999

0.559 (0.170, 1.839)

0.726 (0.216, 2.438)

0.300 (0.125, 0.718)

 

$19,999 or below

2.189 (0.375, 12.785)

0.931 (0.233, 3.721)

0.486 (0.166, 1.426)

Resources

Personal

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

2.874 (0.824, 10.032)

5.625 (1.711, 18.492)

5.294 (2.106, 13.308)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.239 (0.031, 1.836)

0.849 (0.122, 5.925)

1.064 (0.196, 5.791)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

4.088 (0.558, 29.937)

1.276 (0.350, 4.656)

0.787 (0.381, 1.627)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

0.348 (0.100, 1.214)

0.178 (0.054, 0.584)

0.189 (0.075, 0.475)

Social

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

1.230 (0.308, 4.909)

3.161 (0.934, 10.704)

7.399 (2.757, 19.856)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

11.923 (0.592, 240.254)

9.521 (1.530, 59.247)

6.854 (2.097, 22.406)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

1.176 (0.273, 5.074)

0.547 (0.135, 2.216)

0.338 (0.117, 0.979)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

0.813 (0.204, 3.244)

0.316 (0.093, 1.071)

0.135 (0.050, 0.363)

Financial

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

1.479 (0.407, 5.377)

5.064 (1.437, 17.849)

6.022 (2.290, 15.838)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

2.446 (0.358, 16.685)

3.677 (0.654, 20.659)

5.739 (1.493, 22.054)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

1.226 (0.323, 4.653)

0.379 (0.117, 1.232)

0.430 (0.186, 0.997)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

0.676 (0.186, 2.459)

0.197 (0.056, 0.696)

0.166 (0.063, 0.437)

Delayed distress

Demographics

Gender

Male

1

1

1

 

Female

0.850 (0.344, 2.101)

0.565 (0.245, 1.304)

1.200 (0.580, 2.483)

Age

55 or above

1

1

1

 

45–54

0.286 (0.010, 8.424)

2.056 (0.226, 18.696)

1.383 (0.173, 11.027)

 

35–44

0.265 (0.011, 6.221)

3.452 (0.497, 24.001)

4.369 (0.659, 28.967)

 

25–34

0.334 (0.014, 8.159)

4.478 (0.648, 30.932)

6.417 (0.960, 42.903)

 

15–24

0.765 (0.030, 19.464)

11.721 (1.581, 86.882)

19.696 (2.901, 133.697)

Education

Tertiary or above

1

1

1

 

Secondary or below

0.899 (0.317, 2.550)

0.603 (0.229, 1.586)

1.556 (0.678, 3.571)

Marital status

Married

1

1

1

 

Single/divorced/widowed

1.052 (0.302, 3.669)

0.798 (0.270, 2.353)

1.250 (0.457, 3.416)

Employment

Employed

1

1

1

 

Dependent

0.355 (0.095, 1.329)

0.381 (0.125, 1.156)

0.262 (0.094, 0.727)

 

Unemployed

0.500 (0.071, 3.513)

0.259 (0.046, 1.452)

0.690 (0.128, 3.729)

Income†

$60,000 or above

1

1

1

 

$40,000–$59,999

0.772 (0.207, 2.880)

0.700 (0.215, 2.279)

0.394 (0.138, 1.123)

 

$20,000–$39,999

1.788 (0.544, 5.876)

1.297 (0.419, 4.020)

0.536 (0.206, 1.392)

 

$19,999 or below

0.457 (0.078, 2.668)

0.425 (0.085, 2.140)

0.222 (0.048, 1.025)

Resources

Personal

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.348 (0.100, 1.214)

1.957 (0.716, 5.351)

1.842 (0.776, 4.372)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

4.188 (0.545, 32.198)

3.554 (1.082, 11.679)

4.457 (1.513, 13.130)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

0.245 (0.033, 1.791)

0.312 (0.039, 2.486)

0.193 (0.028, 1.343)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

2.874 (0.824, 10.032)

0.511 (0.187, 1.397)

0.543 (0.229, 1.289)

Social

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.813 (0.204, 3.244)

2.570 (0.931, 7.092)

6.014 (2.438, 14.838)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.084 (0.004, 1.690)

0.799 (0.046, 13.937)

0.575 (0.039, 8.519)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

0.850 (0.197, 3.667)

0.465 (0.131, 1.648)

0.287 (0.096, 0.861)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

1.230 (0.308, 4.909)

0.389 (0.141, 1.074)

0.166 (0.067, 0.410)

Financial

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.676 (0.186, 2.459)

3.424 (1.204, 9.741)

4.072 (1.693, 9.794)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.409 (0.060, 2.789)

1.503 (0.284, 7.955)

2.347 (0.503, 10.941)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

0.816 (0.215, 3.095)

0.309 (0.091, 1.053)

0.351 (0.118, 1.047)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

1.479 (0.407, 5.377)

0.292 (0.103, 0.831)

0.246 (0.102, 0.591)

Recovery

Demographics

Gender

Male

1

1

1

 

Female

1.505 (0.631, 3.588)

1.770 (0.767, 4.084)

2.123 (1.182, 3.814)

Age

55 or above

1

1

1

 

45–54

0.139 (0.009, 2.035)

0.486 (0.053, 4.421)

0.672 (0.238, 1.898)

 

35–44

0.077 (0.006, 0.960)

0.290 (0.042, 2.014)

1.266 (0.529, 3.027)

 

25–34

0.075 (0.006, 0.968)

0.223 (0.032, 1.542)

1.433 (0.607, 3.381)

 

15–24

0.065 (0.005, 0.942)

0.085 (0.012, 0.632)

1.680 (0.626, 4.511)

Education

Tertiary or above

1

1

1

 

Secondary or below

1.491 (0.541, 4.112)

1.659 (0.631, 4.367)

2.583 (1.296, 5.149)

Marital status

Married

1

1

1

 

Single/divorced/widowed

1.319 (0.476, 3.654)

1.254 (0.425, 3.700)

1.567 (0.826, 2.975)

Employment

Employed

1

1

1

 

Dependent

0.932 (0.286, 3.031)

2.627 (0.865, 7.979)

0.688 (0.344, 1.375)

 

Unemployed

1.928 (0.450, 8.258)

3.858 (0.689, 21.615)

2.663 (1.008, 7.033)

Income†

$60,000 or above

1

1

1

 

$40,000–$59,999

1.104 (0.334, 3.647)

1.429 (0.439, 4.657)

0.564 (0.259, 1.225)

 

$20,000–$39,999

1.378 (0.410, 4.629)

0.771 (0.249, 2.389)

0.413 (0.184, 0.929)

 

$19,999 or below

1.074 (0.269, 4.289)

2.351 (0.467, 11.823)

0.522 (0.223, 1.223)

Resources

Personal

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.178 (0.054, 0.584)

0.511 (0.187, 1.397)

0.941 (0.461, 1.920)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

1.178 (0.169, 8.226)

0.281 (0.086, 0.925)

1.254 (0.548, 2.870)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

0.784 (0.215, 2.860)

3.204 (0.402, 25.525)

0.617 (0.206, 1.849)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

5.625 (1.711, 18.492)

1.957 (0.716, 5.351)

1.062 (0.521, 2.167)

Social

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.316 (0.093, 1.071)

0.389 (0.141, 1.074)

2.341 (1.222, 4.484)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.105 (0.017, 0.654)

1.252 (0.072, 21.856)

0.720 (0.200, 2.593)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

1.827 (0.451, 7.397)

2.149 (0.607, 7.609)

0.617 (0.257, 1.486)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

3.161 (0.934, 10.704)

2.570 (0.931, 7.092)

0.427 (0.223, 0.818)

Financial

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.197 (0.056, 0.696)

0.292 (0.103, 0.831)

1.189 (0.563, 2.514)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.272 (0.048, 1.528)

0.665 (0.126, 3.520)

1.561 (0.555, 4.389)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

2.636 (0.811, 8.563)

3.232 (0.950, 10.998)

1.134 (0.497, 2.592)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

5.064 (1.437, 17.849)

3.424 (1.204, 9.741)

0.841 (0.398, 1.778)

Resilience

Demographics

Gender

Male

1

1

1

 

Female

0.709 (0.381, 1.317)

0.833 (0.403, 1.725)

0.471 (0.262, 0.846)

Age

55 or above

1

1

1

 

45–54

0.207 (0.019, 2.216)

0.723 (0.091, 5.766)

1.487 (0.527, 4.196)

 

35–44

0.061 (0.006, 0.601)

0.229 (0.035, 1.517)

0.790 (0.330, 1.889)

 

25–34

0.052 (0.005, 0.543)

0.156 (0.023, 1.042)

0.698 (0.296, 1.646)

 

15–24

0.039 (0.003, 0.433)

0.051 (0.007, 0.345)

0.595 (0.222, 1.598)

Education

Tertiary or above

1

1

1

 

Secondary or below

0.577 (0.276, 1.206)

0.642 (0.280, 1.474)

0.387 (0.194, 0.772)

Marital status

Married

1

1

1

 

Single/divorced/widowed

0.842 (0.386, 1.834)

0.800 (0.293, 2.187)

0.638 (0.336, 1.211)

Employment

Employed

1

1

1

 

Dependent

1.355 (0.537, 3.419)

3.820 (1.375, 10.613)

1.454 (0.727, 2.908)

 

Unemployed

0.724 (0.226, 2.318)

1.449 (0.268, 7.825)

0.376 (0.142, 0.992)

Income†

$60,000 or above

1

1

1

 

$40,000–$59,999

1.959 (0.811, 4.732)

2.536 (0.890, 7.226)

1.774 (0.817, 3.855)

 

$20,000–$39,999

3.336 (1.392, 7.991)

1.866 (0.718, 4.849)

2.421 (1.077, 5.442)

 

$19,999 or below

2.056 (0.701, 6.026)

4.500 (0.976, 20.748)

1.915 (0.818, 4.483)

Resources

Personal

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.189 (0.075, 0.475)

0.543 (0.229, 1.289)

1.062 (0.521, 2.167)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.940 (0.173, 5.113)

0.224 (0.076, 0.661)

0.797 (0.348, 1.825)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

1.271 (0.615, 2.626)

5.194 (0.744, 36.249)

1.621 (0.541, 4.858)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

5.294 (2.106, 13.308)

1.842 (0.776, 4.372)

0.941 (0.461, 1.920)

Social

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.135 (0.050, 0.363)

0.166 (0.067, 0.410)

0.427 (0.223, 0.818)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.146 (0.045, 0.477)

1.740 (0.117, 25.782)

1.389 (0.386, 5.003)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

2.959 (1.022, 8.572)

3.481 (1.161, 10.436)

1.620 (0.673, 3.897)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

7.399 (2.757, 19.856)

6.014 (2.438, 14.838)

2.341 (1.222, 4.484)

Financial

Low-Low (Persistent low)‡

0.166 (0.063, 0.437)

0.246 (0.102, 0.591)

0.841 (0.398, 1.778)

 

High-Low (Loss)‡

0.174 (0.045, 0.670)

0.426 (0.091, 1.987)

0.641 (0.228, 1.801)

 

Low-High (Gain)§

2.324 (1.003, 5.384)

2.849 (0.955, 8.499)

0.882 (0.386, 2.014)

 

High-High (Persistent high)§

6.022 (2.290, 15.838)

4.072 (1.693, 9.794)

1.189 (0.563, 2.514)

  1. Bold texts indicate significant results.
  2. †US$1≈HK$7.80.
  3. ‡The “Low-Low (Persistent low)” and “High-Low (Loss)” groups were compared against the “High-High (Persistent high)” group.
  4. §The “Low-High (Gain)” and “High-High (Persistent high)” groups were compared against the “Low-Low (Persistent low)” group.