Table 1 Study setting details.
Study | Setting | Treatment | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Clinical skills training laboratory | Single surgery | Open plan clinic | Treatment on patient | Simulated treatment on patient | Mannequin | |
Belting 1964 [20] | X | X (patients TB +ve) | ||||
Hausler 1966 [23] | X | X | ||||
Larato 1966 [25] | X | X | ||||
Miller 1971 [28] | X | X | ||||
Samaranayake 1989 [32] | X | X | ||||
Bentley 1994 [21] | X | X | X | |||
Grenier 1995 [22] | X | X | ||||
Tag El-Din 1997 [33] | X | X | ||||
Purohit 2009 [30] | X | |||||
Rautemaa 2006 [31] | X | X | ||||
Yamada 2011 [34] | X | X | ||||
Manarte-Monteiro 2013 [27] | X | X | ||||
Ionescu 2020 [24] | X | X | ||||
Nulty 2020 [29] | X | X | ||||
Ahmed 2021 [37] | X | X | ||||
Allison 2021(a) [18] | X | X | ||||
Allison 2021(b) [19] | X | X | ||||
Allison 2021(c) [35] | X | X | ||||
Grzech-Lesniak 2021 [36] | X | X | ||||
Han 2021 [16] | X | X | ||||
Holliday 2021 [15] | X | X | X | |||
Llandro 2021 [26] | X | X | ||||
Shahdad 2021 [17] | X | X | X | |||