Table 1 Techniques used for identification of the 23 atherosclerotic plaque-associated bacteria

From: Linkages between oral commensal bacteria and atherosclerotic plaques in coronary artery disease patients

Atherosclerotic plaque-associated bacteria

Detection platform

Percentage of bacteria present in atherosclerotic plaque samples

Reference

Aggregatibacter actinomycetecomitans

PCR

71.4 % [5/7]

76

[Phylum: Proteobacteria]

16S rRNA

66.67 % [28/42]

77, 78

 

mAb

17 % [5/29]

25, 79

 

16S rRNA

21.87 % [7/32]

80

 

16S rRNA

18 % [9/50]

81

 

16S rRNA

25.9 % [7/27]

82

 

RT-PCR

46.2 % [18/39]

83, 84

 

16S rRNA

29.4 % [15/51]

85, 86

Chlamydiae pneumoniae

mAb

20.6 % [6/29]

25, 79

[Phylum: Chlamydiae]

16s rRNA

35.4 % [11/31]

25, 80

 

16s rDNA

18 % [9/50]

25, 81

 

ICC/PCR

48 % [11/23]

87

 

16S rRNA

51.5 % [17/33]

88

 

MIF IgA

32.6 % [63/193]

89

 

MIF IgG

61.7 % [119/193]

89

 

16S rRNA

26 % [12/46]

90

 

PCR

42 % [102/241 sections (10 samples)]

91

 

PCR

69 % [11/16]

92

 

Immunofluorescence

79 % [71/90]

93

 

PCR

70 % [42/60]

94

 

IgG antibody

61.7 % [50/81]

95

Campylobacter rectus

16S rRNA

9.52 % [4/42]

77, 78, 96

[Phylum: Proteobacteria]

PCR

11.7 % [6/51]

83, 85

 

16S rRNA

21.51 % [11/51]

83, 85, 97

 

16S rRNA

15.7 % [8/51]

98

 

16S rRNA

21.51 % [11/51]

82

Enteroacter hormaechei

16S rRNA

50 % [134/268]

4

[Phylum: Proteobacteria]

16S rRNA

40 % [2/5]

99

Eikenella corrodens

16S rRNA

54.76 % [23/42]

77, 78

[Phylum: Proteobacteria]

PCR

15.6 % [8/51]

96

 

16S rRNA

27.45 % [14/51]

98

Fusobacterium nucleatum

16S rRNA

50 % [21/42]

77, 78

[Phylum: Fusobacteria]

Monoclonal antibody

34 % [10/29]

79, 25

 

PCR

21 % [4/19]

100

Fusobacterium necrophorum

–

–

101,102,103

[Phylum: Fusobacteria]

   

Helicobacter pylori

IgA

55.4 % [107/193]

89

[Phylum: Proteobacteria]

IgM

44.6 % [86/193]

89

 

16S rRNA

37 % [17/46]

90

 

IHC

57.8 % [22/38]

104

 

PCR

92.16 % [47/51]

105

 

IgG

67.9 % [55/81]

95

Mycoplasma pneumoniae

Seropositivity

14 % [396]

106

[Phylum: Tenericutes]

–

–

107

Porphyromonas endodontalis

–

–

108

[Phylum: Bacteriodetes]

   

Porphyromonas gingivalis

16S rRNA

78.57 % [33/42]

77, 78

[Phylum: Bacteriodetes]

PCR

71.43 % [5/7]

76

 

16S rRNA

67 % [134]

4

 

mAb

52 % [15/29]

79, 25

 

16S rRNA

22.27 % [6/22]

25, 80

 

16S rRNA

26 % [13/50]

81, 25

 

PCR

47.4 % [9/19]

100

 

PCR

51 % [27/53]

109, 110

 

PCR

43.1 % [22/51]

96

 

16S rRNA

45.1 % [23/51]

83, 85

 

16S rRNA

21.6 % [11/51]

83, 85, 97

 

RT-PCR

53.8 % [21/39]

83, 84

 

16S rRNA

45.1 % [23/51]

98

 

16S rRNA

7.4 % [2/27]

82

Prevotella intermedia

mAb

41 % [12/29]

25, 79

[Phylum: Bacteriodetes]

16S rRNA

9.37 % [3/32]

25, 80

 

16S rRNA

14 % [7/50]

25, 81

 

PCR

21 % [4/19]

100

 

PCR

15 % [8/53]

23, 110

 

PCR

19.6 % [10/51]

96

 

RT-PCR

79.3 % [23/29]

83, 84

 

PCR

71.43 % [5/7]

76

 

16S rRNA

3.7 % [1/27]

82

Prevotella nigrescens

PCR

15.6 % [8/51]

96

[Phylum: Bacteriodetes]

RT-PCR

17.9 % [7/39]

83, 84

Pseudomonas aeruginosa

16S rRNA

40 % [6/15]

74

[Phylum: Proteobacteria]

   

Pseudomonas luteola

16S rRNA

100 % [15/15]

111

[Phylum: Proteobacteria]

   

Streptococcus gordonii

16S rRNA

19.4 % [-]

82

Streptococcus mitis

16S rRNA

19.4 % [-]

 

Streptococcus mutans

16S rRNA

74.1 % [20/27]

 

Streptococcus oralis

16S rRNA

3.7 % [1/27]

 

Streptococcus sanguinis

16S rRNA

25.9 % [7/27]

 

[Phylum: Firmicutes]

   

Treponema denticola

PCR

43 % [23/53]

83, 109

[Phylum: Spirochaetes]

16S rRNA

44.4 % [12/27]

82

 

PCR

35.2 % [18/51]

96

 

16S rRNA

49.01 % [25/51]

83, 85

 

16S rRNA

27.4 % [14/51]

83, 85, 86

 

16S rRNA

23.1 % [6/26]

82, 86

 

16S rRNA

49.01 % [25/51]

98

Tannerella forsythia

16S rRNA

61.9 % [26/42]

77

[Phylum: Bacteriodetes]

PCR

100 % [7/7]

76

 

mAb

34 % [10/29]

25, 79

 

16S rRNA

30 % [15/50]

25, 81

 

PCR

10.5 % [2/19]

100

 

PCR

19.6 % [10/51]

96

 

16S rRNA

5.9 % [3/51]

78, 83, 85

 

RT-PCR

25.6 % [10/39]

83, 84

Veillonella

16S rRNA

10 % [2/20]

112

[Phylum: Firmicutes]

16S rRNA

100 % [13/13]

111