Table 1 Summary of the Generalized Linear Mixed Models (GLMM) testing for main and 2nd order interactive effects of litter species (random effect) and age (fixed effect, either 0 or 180 days of decomposition) on bioassay results (i.e. growth of plants, fungi and bacteria, expressed as percentage of the untreated control).

From: Litter chemistry explains contrasting feeding preferences of bacteria, fungi, and higher plants

 

Effect type

SS

df

MS

F

p

All data pooled

Litter species (L)

Random

766411

17

45083

3.24

0.0058

Litter age (A)

Fixed

212583

1

212583

26.09

0.0001

Target organism group (O)

Fixed

4789183

2

2394591

190.77

<0.0001

L × A

Random

207740

17

12220

2.00

0.0412

L × O

Random

426784

34

12552

1.95

0.0273

A × O

Fixed

2488776

2

1244388

193.81

<0.0001

Bacteria

Litter species (L)

Random

219385

17

12905

2.33

0.0459

Litter age (A)

Fixed

236545

1

236545

15.60

0.0049

Target species (T)

Random

329809

5

65962

5.38

0.0425

L × A

Random

91187

17

5364

2.33

0.0057

L × T

Random

209600

85

2466

1.07

0.3723

A × T

Random

60483

5

12097

5.27

0.0003

Fungi

Litter species (L)

Random

358819

17

21107

2.40

0.0353

Litter age (A)

Fixed

962182

1

962182

44.51

0.0001

Target species (T)

Random

412704

5

82541

5.33

0.0406

L × A

Random

141914

17

8348

4.77

<0.0001

L × T

Random

188262

85

2215

1.27

0.1397

A × T

Random

75104

5

15021

8.58

<0.0001

Plants

Litter species (L)

Random

821469

17

48322

9.22

<0.0001

Litter age (A)

Fixed

1308116

1

1308116

16.95

0.0012

Target species (T)

Random

2604705

13

200362

2.57

0.0492

L × A

Random

150299

17

8841

2.00

0.0123

L × T

Random

1153846

221

5221

1.19

0.1019

A × T

Random

1003151

13

77165

17.54

<0.0001

Plant functional types

Litter species (L)

Random

853545

17

50209

6.74

0.0003

Litter age (A)

Fixed

1204105

1

1204105

252.35

<0.0001

Target functional type (F)

Fixed

1008085

2

504042

65.84

<0.0001

L × A

Random

162235

17

9543

1.93

0.0490

L × F

Random

260288

34

7656

1.54

0.1060

A × F

Fixed

721938

2

360969

72.69

<0.0001

  1. GLMMs were tested for all data pooled, including a fixed effect of the group of organisms (3 levels), and separately for plants, fungi and bacteria, including a random effect of target species. In the case of plants, a further GLMM was tested, including the effect of target functional type (3 levels: annual, perennial and woody).