Table 1 Methods which used the Intra-patient paradigm.

From: Inter-Patient ECG Heartbeat Classification with Temporal VCG Optimized by PSO

Work

# Classes

Feature set

Classifier

Effectiveness

Cristov & Bortonal, 200433

2

Heartbeat-Intervals, VCG

NN

Acc = 99%

Ă–zbay et al., 200634

10

Raw-wave

MLP, Fuzzy Cluster, FCNN

Acc = 99%

Bortolan et al., 200735

2

VCG and Morphological hyperbox + GA

Fuzzy Clustering

Acc = 99%

Ubeyli, 200736

4

DWT

SVM, ECOC

Acc = 99%

Yu & Chen, 200712

5

ICA, RR-interval

PNN

Acc = 99%

Yu & Chen, 200712

6

Wavelet (statistics), RR-interval

PNN

Acc = 99%

Minhas & Arif, 200837

6

Wavelet, RR-interval, PCA

kNN

Acc = 99%

Asl et al., 200838

6

HVR, GDA

SVM

Acc = 100%

Chen et al., 20146

6

RR-intervals

SVN, NN

Acc = 100%

Mert et al., 201439

6

RR-intervals, HOS,

Bagged Decision Tree

Acc = 99%

   

2nd order LPC coeff.

 

Alickovic & Subasi, 201540

5

autoregressive (AR) modeling

SVM, MLP, RBF, kNN

Acc = 99%

Li et al., 201741

6

WPD

GA-BPNN

Acc = 99%

  1. Neural Network (NN); Principal Component Analysis (PCA); Generalized Discriminant Analyses(GDA); Error correcting output codes (ECOC); Independent Component Analysis (ICA); Probabilistic neural Network (PNN); Continues Wavelet Transform (CWT); Discrete Wavelet Transform (DWT); Discrete Cosine Transform (DCT); Higher order statistics (HOS); Linear Discriminants (LD); wavelet packet decomposition (WPD). Abbreviations: Acc: Accuracy.