Table 4 Results of internal cross-validation experiments providing a comparison of the efficiency of the various evaluated diversity and inequality metrics in predicting a preterm delivery outcome.

From: First-trimester vaginal microbiome diversity: A potential indicator of preterm delivery risk

 

Accuracy

Sensitivity

Specificity

PPV

NPV

MCC

TCS

0.965 (0.02)

0.970 (0.03)

0.964 (0.03)

0.922 (0.05)

0.986 (0.01)

0.921 (0.04)

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

NA

Shannon

0.855 (0.03)

0.759 (0.10)

0.899 (0.05)

0.773 (0.09)

0.896 (0.04)

0.662 (0.07)

2.5E-165

5.9E-163

1.3E-150

3.3E-163

2.2E-164

2.7E-165

Simpson

0.819 (0.04)

0.489 (0.09)

0.963 (0.02)

0.855 (0.08)

0.812 (0.04)

0.547 (0.08)

2.5E-165

6.5E-165

2.0E-01

5.4E-84

4.8E-165

2.7E-165

Chao1

0.947 (0.02)

0.936 (0.05)

0.952 (0.03)

0.896 (0.05)

0.972 (0.02)

0.878 (0.04)

6.1E-129

4.7E-81

4.8E-49

2.0E-78

3.3E-117

1.4E-138

Gini

0.908 (0.02)

0.820 (0.09)

0.947 (0.04)

0.880 (0.08)

0.925 (0.04)

0.784 (0.05)

2.5E-163

1.8E-154

7.2E-33

1.1E-55

4.6E-160

8.0E-165

Ricci-Schutz

0.868 (0.03)

0.730 (0.09)

0.929 (0.04)

0.826 (0.09)

0.888 (0.04)

0.684 (0.07)

8.1E-165

6.9E-165

2.9E-88

5.6E-134

4.8E-165

2.7E-165

Atkinson

0.859 (0.03)

0.703 (0.11)

0.929 (0.04)

0.820 (0.09)

0.878 (0.04)

0.662 (0.07)

2.5E-165

6.9E-165

1.7E-88

1.0E-130

4.8E-165

2.7E-165

Theil

0.899 (0.03)

0.809 (0.10)

0.940 (0.05)

0.867 (0.09)

0.919 (0.04)

0.766 (0.06)

2.3E-163

1.0E-157

9.0E-48

5.1E-65

7.1E-162

4.3E-165

Decile ratio (90:10)

0.795 (0.04)

0.347 (0.08)

0.991 (0.01)

0.949 (0.08)

0.777 (0.04)

0.492 (0.07)

2.5E-165

6.5E-165

1

1

4.8E-165

2.7E-165

  1. These experiments were performed using vaginal microbiome samples obtained before 20 weeks of gestation. Mean (and standard deviation) values of the six evaluation parameters obtained across 1000 iterations of cross-validation are provided. Benjamini-Hochberg corrected p-values indicating the relatively better efficiency of the TCS metric as compared to other metrics (Wilcoxon paired rank sum test) are also indicated in italics.