Figure 5
From: Possible causes of data model discrepancy in the temperature history of the last Millennium

Superposed Epoch Analysis of the temperature response to volcanic eruptions. SH (left) and NH (right) temperature anomalies relative to 5-year pre-eruption means. Lines (shading) represent ensemble medians (9–95% range). Red: model truth, black: real proxies, other colors: PPE. Cyan shading is the 5–95% range of monte-carlo sampled years during non-volcanic periods. Distributions are across all model simulations and ensemble members. Model truth and real proxy data are shown in all panels for better comparison.