Table 1 Incremental cost-effectiveness of PrEP strategies over a 5-year time horizon.

From: Pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for MSM in low HIV incidence places: should high risk individuals be targeted?

 

number of new infections

% of new infections averted

number of PrEP usage (person-year)

Discounted QALYG(1)

Plan A

Plan B

Plan C

Discounted incremental cost, USD (2)

(2)/(1)

(2)

(2)/(1)

(2)

(2)/(1)

basecase

3450

/

0

       

non-targeting, 10%

2590

8%

17959

67

123458936

1842204

17294670

258064

9806914

146335

non-targeting, 30%

2048

23%

53910

212

370266861

1745524

51648582

243483

29176464

137545

non-targeting, 90%

942

55%

161936

526

1113780354

2115619

157156635

298518

89686050

170358

targeting, 10%

2754

3%

7629

24

52571166

2162072

7459389

306779

4277659

175926

targeting, 30%

2470

11%

22896

99

157200505

1583136

21831597

219862

12284040

123710

targeting, 90%

1780

31%

68752

287

472011282

1642874

65661580

228540

37001772

128788

test-and-treat

2075

23%

0

98

39055533

396874

39055533

396874

39055533

396874

non-targeting, 10%

1849

29%

17987

170

158411503

929215

52137608

305830

44642119

261863

non-targeting, 30%

1463

40%

53985

296

398568822

1345390

79665459

268915

57173233

192991

non-targeting, 90%

673

63%

162094

568

1127434311

1985645

170226003

299803

102714188

180901

targeting, 10%

1964

26%

7643

134

89432361

668940

44267840

331116

41082391

307290

targeting, 30%

1760

32%

22934

199

190572365

956132

55056540

276227

45498622

228274

targeting, 90%

1266

46%

68847

363

496573340

1366821

89865774

247356

61180726

168400

  1. Plan A – market price for PrEP drug (annual cost of USD7880 at the end of 2017); Plan B – generic price for PrEP drug (annual cost of USD519); Plan C – zero cost for PrEP drug. All PrEP users are assumed to be in high adherence with an average of 87.5% usage per year. As we assume that 20% of high adherence users would change to low adherence users, whereas 10% of low adherence users would change to high adherence users in a year, a proportion of PrEP users would be in low adherence, with an average of 38% usage per year.
  2. (2)/(1) = Discounted incremental cost-effectiveness (incremental $/QALYG).
  3. Non-targeting – low-threshold approach with PrEP for both low- and high-risk MSM; targeting – PrEP for high-risk MSM only.
  4. QALYG – quality-adjusted life-years gained.