Table 1 Summary of recent research results for H2 sensors based on Pd-decorated graphene, Pd/graphene composites, and related materials, operating at room temperature.

From: Chemically deposited palladium nanoparticles on graphene for hydrogen sensor applications

Pd Deposition Methods

Sensing Material

Pd NP diameter (d) or Pd layer thickness (t)

Graphene Synthesis Method

Response Value

Response/Recovery Time

Selectivity

Reference

Galvanic displacement

PMMA/Pd NP/CVD-G

d = 20 nm

CVD

66.37% (20000 ppm)

1.81/5.52 min

CO, NO2, CH4

70

e-beam evaporation

Pd NP/MLGN

t = 1 nm

Expanded flake graphite

55% (40 ppm)

21/23 s*

NH3, O2 cross-sensitivity

44

e-beam evaporation

Pd NP/CVD-G

t = 1 nm

CVD

4.1% (500 ppm)

3.5/7.77 min

 

45

Thermal evaporation

Pd NP/CVD-G

t = 3 nm

CVD

32.9% (1000ppm)

10/3.5 min

 

32

Electrochemical deposition

Pd NP/SWNT

d = 35 nm

 

0.4% (100ppm)**

18/20 min

 

71

e-beam evaporation

Pd NP/G-NRs (200-nm-thick)

t =  2 nm

PECVD

5.8% (1000 ppm)

1/1.5 min (80% recovery)

 

13

Chemical route

Pd-Pt NP/GO

t = 7.6 nm

Hummers method

4.2% (20000 ppm)

2/18 s

 

34

Magnetron sputtering

Pd film/G/Exfoliated G

t = 30 nm

Exfoliated

4.5% (10000 ppm)

1/5 min (36.8%)

 

72

e-beam evaporation

Pd NP/CVD-G Hall bar

t = 1 nm

CVD

2.5% (25 ppm)

10/20 min

CO2 O2 CH4

73

Electrochemical depositing

FPNCs/CVD-G

300/80 nm (size/length)

CVD

7% (10 ppm)

50 s

NO2, NH3

74

Chemical route

Pd NP/rGO

d = 10 nm

rGO

7% (1000 ppm)

5/10 min

O2 NO2 CO CO2 N2

35

Chemical route

Pd NP/CVD-G

d = 10 nm

CVD

5.88% (10000 ppm)

3/9 min

CH 2 O NH 3

This work

  1. PMMA: poly(methyl methacrylate), d: nanoparticle diameter, t: Pd layer thickness, Pd NP: palladium nanoparticles, CVD: chemical vapor deposition, G: graphene, MLGN: multi-layer graphene nanoribbon, SWNT: single-walled carbon nanotubes, NRs: nanorods, rGO: reduced graphene oxide. FPNCs: Flower-like Pd nanoclusters. The rest of the abbreviations can be found in the related references.
  2. *In the related reference, the response/recovery time is defined as the time for 50% of the maximum ΔR/R change/recovered.
  3. **The results are obtained from hydrogen-desorption-enhancing air (80% RH).