Table 2 The simulated historical (1979–2010) mean performance of winter wheat yield (kg ha−1) under ambient (aCO2) and elevated carbon dioxide (eCO2) at a high rainfall site near Pullman, at a low rainfall site near Lind and at an irrigated site near Moses Lake, WA.

From: Novel multimodel ensemble approach to evaluate the sole effect of elevated CO2 on winter wheat productivity

 

aCO2 (µmol mol−1)

eCO2 (µmol mol−1)

400

500

600

700

800

900

1000

Pullman WA

APSIM

6368 (209)

7222 (235)

8040 (253)

8782 (264)

9417 (268)

9882 (271)

10132 (274)

CropSyst

6268 (225)

7223 (248)

8040 (264)

8782 (278)

9417 (289)

9882 (294)

10132 (294)

DSSAT

6214 (216)

6768 (232)

7298 (245)

7772 (255)

8184 (265)

8551 (272)

8835 (277)

EPIC

6148 (239)

6764 (243)

7239 (246)

7610 (248)

7900 (250)

8127 (251)

8302 (253)

STICS

7101 (226)

8340 (278)

9284 (303)

10013 (323)

10606 (345)

11044 (351)

11353 (343)

Lind WA

APSIM

2339 (134)

2757 (136)

3112 (146)

3503 (158)

3795 (171)

3963 (183)

4129 (195)

CropSyst

2842 (167)

3320 (194)

3759 (217)

4189 (237)

4584 (253)

4897 (266)

5058 (275)

DSSAT

2643 (226)

2988 (251)

3339 (277)

3675 (304)

3980 (329)

4269 (354)

4524 (376)

EPIC

3159 (249)

3748 (264)

4329 (265)

4937 (267)

5472 (311)

5948 (351)

6162 (370)

STICS

2369 (150)

2892 (135)

3480 (236)

4017 (165)

4217 (206)

4314 (236)

4381 (267)

Moses Lake, WA

APSIM

7853 (166)

8609 (168)

9109 (179)

9209 (185)

9311 (193)

9413 (197)

9429 (203)

CropSyst

10559 (184)

11424 (195)

11911 (202)

12213 (206)

12416 (208)

12561 (210)

12668 (212)

DSSAT

8322 (350)

9125 (352)

9888 (357)

10541 (367)

11107 (377)

11594 (387)

11970 (395)

EPIC

7995 (142)

8866 (164)

9224 (230)

9510 (293)

9877 (305)

10297 (345)

10120 (367)

STICS

7353 (155)

7989 (158)

8529 (161)

9020 (165)

9466 (168)

9768 (192)

9915 (227)

  1. (Note: Standard errors (SE) of mean of the simulated data are in parentheses).