Table 2 Comparison of BAL sample analysis results obtained by DAMIAN, Taxonomer BETA, PathoScope and metaMix.
104 | 3157 | 4505 | |
|---|---|---|---|
DAMIAN | 23,828,285 reads 99,23% human sequences | 3,265,314 reads 51,74% human sequences | 2,370,210 reads 98,13% human sequences |
✓ Influenza A (39,810 reads; 42%) • H1N1 all 8 segments (8 contigs) 97–100% id. ○ Influenza A ○ A/Singapore/TT198/2011 (H1N1) ○ A/Swine/France/71-130116/2013 (H1N1) ○ A/Swine/France/71-130116/2013 (H1N1) ○ A/Singapore/TT198/2011 (H1N1) ○ A/Santa Clara/YGA_03065/2013(H1N1), ○ A/Arizona/M2/2012(H1N1) ○ A/Swine/France/71-130116/2013 (H1N1) ✓ Candida albicans (14,249 reads, 15.15%) | ✓ Influenza A (1,886 reads, 1.57%) • H3N2 all 8 segments (8 contigs) 99% id. ○ PB2, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ○ PB1, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ○ PA, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ○ HA, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ○ NP, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ○ NA, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ○ M2, M1, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ○ NEP,NS1, A/Connecticut/Flu140/2013(H3N2) ✓ human parainfluenza 3 virus (1 read) 99% id. ✓ human herpes simplex virus 1 (4 reads) 99% id. ✓ Candida albicans (10,207 reads, 7.65%) | ✓ Chlamydophila psittaci (237 reads; 4.13%) 100%id. • Chlamydophila psittacci 6BC, 4 contigs, 16S and 23S rRNA • Chamydophila VS225, 1 contig, 16S rRNA • Chlamydophila Mat116, 1 contig, 16S rRNA | |
Taxonomer BETA | 9,900,000 reads sampled*; 5% classified Bacteria: 62,128 reads; Viruses: 10,723 reads; Fungi: 86 reads | 3,200,000 reads samples; 13% classified Bacteria: 300,309 reads; Viruses: 7,686 reads; Fungi: 17,878 reads | 2,300,000 reads samples; 4% classified Bacteria: 24,960 reads; Viruses: 950 reads; |
✓ Influenza A (1,227 reads) • H1N1 (1,227 reads) ✓ α-retrovirus (9,677 reads) ✓ dsDNA virus (505 reads) | ✓ Influenza A (1,433 reads) • H3N2 (354 reads) ✓ Human parainfluenza 3 virus (13 reads) ✓ α-retrovirus (907 reads) ✓ Caudovirales (1,299 reads) ✓ Herpesviridae (184 reads) ✓ Candida albicans (15,537 reads) | ✓ Chlamydia (75 reads) • Chlamydia psittaci (33 reads) • Chlamydia trachomatis (30 reads) ✓ Proteobacteria (510 reads) ✓ Firmicutes (33 reads) ✓ α-retrovirus (169 reads) ✓ Herpesviridae (52 reads) | |
PathoScope | 45,576 aligned reads; 2,234 hits ✓ Influenza A (12,234 reads) • Subtypes H3N2; H5N1; H1N1; H9N2; H2N2 ✓ Hepatitis C (224 reads) • Genotype 2; 1; 6 ✓ Encephalomyocarditis Virus (115 reads) | 184,719 aligned reads; 2,434 hits ✓ Influenza A (1,337 reads) ✓ Subtypes H3N2 ✓ Avian leukosis virus (1,256 reads) ✓ human herpes simplex virus 1 (102 reads) ✓ Veillonella parvula (130,363 reads) ✓ Enterococcus faecium (21,178 reads) | 4,408 aligned reads; 1,752 hits ✓ Chlamydophila psittaci (23.83 reads)# |
metaMix | 26 hits; 7,328,046 human reads ✓ Influenza A (1 contig; 46,698 reads) • H1N1, 1 contig; A/Canela/LACENRS-418/2013 ✓ Candida albicans SC5314 2 contigs (601,527 reads) Bacteria 3 contigs (372 reads) | 44 hits; 201,764 human reads ✓ Influenza A (3 contigs; 2,244 reads) • H3N2, 2 contigs; A/Bage/LACENRS-205/2013; A/Porto Alegre/LACENRS-275/2013 ✓ Candida albicans, 1 contig (97,816reads) Bacteria; 15 contigs (109,048 reads) | 16 hits; 142,965 human reads ✓ Chlamydia psittaci (1 contig; 252 reads) |