Table 2 Summary of copper sulphate effects on different species, reported by previous researches, and comparison with our results.

From: Copper sulphate impact on the antioxidant defence system of the marine bivalves Cerastoderma edule and Scrobicularia plana

 

Species

Exposure Time

Chemical

Concentration

Effect

Author

Lethal Effects

Cerastoderma edule

96 hours

Copper sulphate

LC50 (Big size) = 0.818 (0.595–0.987) mg/L

LC50 (Small size) = 1.129 (0.968–1.289) mg/L

Lethality

23

Scrobicularia plana

96 hours

Copper sulphate

LC50 (Big size) = 2.563 (2.229–2.903) mg/L

LC50 (Small size) = 4.705 (3.540–12.292) mg/L

Lethality

23

Lamellidens marginalis

72 hours

Copper sulphate

LC50 = 3.990 mg/L

Lethality

32

Anodonta anatine

Pseudanodonta complanata

Unio tumidos

48 hours

Copper

LC50 = 18.9

(10.0–31.1) µg/L

LC50 = 29.3

(25.4–34.0) µg/L

LC50 = 19.0

(16.2–22.0) µg/L

Lethality

33

Nassarius reticulatus

96 hours

Copper

LC50 = 58.84

(35.45–82.29) µg/L

Lethality

34

Daphnia magna

96 hours

Copper sulphate

LC50 = 0.0826

(0.0823–0.0829) mg/L

Lethality

35

Effects on Enzymatic Activity

Cerastoderma edule

96 hours

Copper sulphate

0.35–0.9 mg/L

Increase of GR, GST, GPx activities and TBARS levels, to the big size class, at the lower concentration.

Decrease of GR activity to small size class at 0.35 mg/L and of GST activity along of the concentration range, being statistically significant at 0.9 mg/L.

Our results

Scrobicularia plana

96 hours

Copper sulphate

1.0 – 4.0 mg/L

Increase of TBARS levels on both size classes at 2.0 mg/L.

Increase of tGPx activity to small size class, at all concentrations.

Our results

Scrobicularia plana

16 days

Nanoparticles of copper oxid

10 µg/L

Increase of GST; no changes in TBARS levels

49

Chlamys farreri

96 hours

Copper

3 µg/L

No effects on GST and GPx activities

9

Perna perna

72 hours

Copper sulphate

40 µg/L

Decrease of GSH levels, with no significant changes on GST and GPx activities

50

Mytilus galloprovincialis

72 hours

Copper

40 µg/L

Decrease of GSH levels

51

Mytilus galloprovincialis

6 days

Copper

40 µg/L

Increase of lipid peroxidation

53–54

Ruditapes decussatus

28 days

Copper

2.5 µg/L

Increase of lipid peroxidation

55