Table 1 List of published work where SERS surfaces are integrated into microfluidic channel.

From: Femtosecond laser fabrication of silver nanostructures on glass for surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy

Author [reference] year

SERS fabrication method

Device material

Channel fabrication method

Analyte and minimum conc. measured or EF

SERS surface generated in situ (in channel)?

Mackenzie et al. [this paper]

Ultrafast laser photoreduction of Ag+

Fused silica

Ultrafast laser inscription then chemical etching

1 mM R6G (Rhodamine 6G)

On surface AEF ~1 × 1011

yes

Liu et al.60 2005

Ag thin film on nanowells in PDMS

glass

Bonding of glass and Ag film on textures PDMS

R6G EF 107

no

Connatser et al.61 2008

Electron beam lithography/Physical vapour deposition (PVD) of silver metal onto glass slab

PDMS

Soft lithography then glass bonding of SERS surface

70 nM Resorufin

no

Xu et al.51 2011

Femtosecond direct laser writing onto channel

Glass

Microchannel made in glass using photolithography and wet etching techniques. Sealed with PDMS film after AgNPs written

p-aminothiophenol (p-ATP)

EF 4 × 108

no

Lee et al.62 2012

Gold-patterned microarray and hollow gold nanospheres (HGNs)

PDMS

PDMS device made using soft lithography. Glass patterned with gold microarray wells, was fabricated by a photolithographic technique and bonded to PDMS

Alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) LOD 0–1 ng/mL

no

Parisi et al.57 2013

In situ electrodeposition of copper in microfluidic channels. Cu(OAc)2 and CTAB flowed through the channel, Cu and C nanowalls formed on the working electrode, AgNO3 solution was flowed through, galvanic replacement of Cu with Ag+, formation of AgNPs.

PDMS

Electrodes integrated into the channel were pre-patterned on Si substrate using standard photolithography and lift-off techniques.

50 pM Crystal violet

AEF 1.1 × 109

yes, bonding step required first

Kim et al.63 2014

Gold film-over nanospheres (AuFON)

PDMS

Soft lithography then glass bonding of SERS surface

1 nM BPE (trans-1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethylene)

no

Kim et al.63 2014

Gold nanorods and nanocubes incorporated directly into the microfluidic polymer layer

PDMS

Soft lithography with AuNPs embedded in elastomer then glass bonding of SERS surface

1 mM BPE

EF 4.1 × 107

no

Oh & Jeong64 2014

Thin silver film thermally evaporated onto channel surface

PDMS

Unwanted Ag film removed by scotch tape. Ag coated PDMS channel boded to glass

Benzenethiol

EF 1.1 × 107

no

Li et al.65 2014

Nanoporous gold disks (NPGDs) fabricated on glass substrate using nanosphere lithography

PDMS

Bonding of glass containing NPGDs to PDMS

1 μm R6G

EF 106

no

Parisi et al.66 2015

In situ galvanic replacement of a pre-patterned copper (Cu) substrate. Cu substrates pre-patterned on Si substrate using standard photolithography and lift-off techniques

PDMS

PDMS channel plasma bonded to the Si substrate containing the pre-patterned Cu substrates. AgO3 pumped through channel for galvanic replacement of pre-patterned Cu with Ag + until dense layer of AgNPs form.

Crystal violet

AEF 2.2 × 107

yes, bonding step required first

Novara et al.67 2016

Electrochemical etching of a silicon wafer in HF electrolyte, followed by immersion plating in silver nitrate solution

PDMS

Bonding of PDMS to Ag-coated porous silicon membranes (Ag-pSi)

4-Mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA)

EF 107

no