Table 3 Comparison of on-field detection protocols for CITES-listed shark species identification.

From: Rapid detection of CITES-listed shark fin species by loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay with potential for field use

 

LAMP assay

Multiplex real-time PCR assaya

Genome skimming using MinION hand-held sequencerb

Cost per sample

USD$ 0.6

USD$ 0.94

USD$ 0.8 (Extraction only)

Equipment

Multi-block thermal cycler

Real-time thermal cycler

MinION sequencer

Time required

Number of sample

   

1

3 hours

3 hours

12–40 hours

10

3 hours

3 hours

12–40 hours

94

14 hours

4 hours

12–40 hours

Tested with processed shark fin

Yes

Yes

No

Bioinformatics

Simple

Simple

Need expertise

Coverage of CITES species

All 12 species

9 out of 12 species

All 12 species

Additional genetic information

No

No

Yes

  1. aCardeñosa et al.22.
  2. bJohri et al.44.