Table 3 Biomass and nutrient remobilization amounts, remobilization efficiencies, and apparent contribution to the grain among different cultivation patterns over 2 years.
Biomass and nutrient | Year | Patterns | Remobilization amount (kg ha−1) | Remobilization efficiency (%) | Apparent contribution to grain (%) | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Stalk | Leaf | Husk + cob | Total | Stalk | Leaf | Husk + cob | Total | Stalk | Leaf | Husk + cob | Total | |||
Biomass | 2014 | SH | 593.5a | 865.4a | − 292.7c | 1,166.2a | 11.4a | 22.5b | − 2.1b | 10.5a | 4.2a | 6.1b | − 2.1b | 8.2c |
ONM | 522.1b | 907.3a | − 194.0b | 1,235.4a | 10.2b | 24.4a | − 1.5a | 11.3a | 4.0a | 6.9ab | − 1.5a | 9.4b | ||
FP | 436.2c | 733.7b | − 146.6a | 1,023.3b | 9.8b | 23.3ab | − 1.5a | 11.0a | 4.3a | 7.3a | − 1.5a | 10.1a | ||
2015 | SH | 765.8a | 791.8a | − 162.5b | 1,395.1a | 12.8a | 21.1a | − 1.1ab | 11.1a | 5.1a | 5.3a | − 1.1ab | 9.3a | |
ONM | 685.2b | 795.4a | − 148.2b | 1,332.4a | 11.9ab | 22.4a | − 1.0a | 11.1a | 4.8a | 5.6a | − 1.0a | 9.4a | ||
FP | 527.7c | 609.8b | − 125.7a | 951.8b | 11.5b | 22.0a | − 1.2b | 9.9b | 4.9a | 5.6a | − 1.2b | 9.3a | ||
N | 2014 | SH | 21.5a | 68.1a | 6.1b | 95.7a | 31.0a | 59.8a | 2.2c | 47.0a | 7.9a | 25.0c | 2.2c | 35.1c |
ONM | 18.1b | 64.2b | 6.8b | 89.1a | 26.6b | 58.1a | 3.0b | 44.9b | 7.8a | 27.8b | 3.0b | 38.6b | ||
FP | 12.0c | 55.6c | 8.4a | 76b | 23.6c | 57.8a | 5.3a | 45.9b | 7.6a | 35.2a | 5.3a | 48.1a | ||
2015 | SH | 31.7a | 70.9a | 15.3ab | 117.9a | 35.6a | 58.2a | 5.7b | 48.5a | 11.8ab | 26.5a | 5.7b | 44.0b | |
ONM | 29.9a | 57.5b | 14.4b | 101.8b | 38.3a | 55.3b | 6.0b | 48.1ab | 12.6a | 24.2b | 6.0b | 42.8c | ||
FP | 20.0b | 44.8c | 16.2a | 81c | 32.0b | 55.1b | 9.3a | 47.6b | 11.5b | 25.6ab | 9.3a | 46.4a | ||
P | 2014 | SH | 6.0a | 10.4a | 5.0a | 21.4a | 17.3a | 34.8a | 5.9b | 28.9a | 7.0a | 12.2a | 5.9c | 25.1a |
ONM | 3.9b | 9.5a | 5.0a | 18.4b | 12.5b | 34.6a | 6.4b | 27.1ab | 5.0b | 12.2a | 6.4b | 23.6b | ||
FP | 1.7c | 7.2b | 4.1b | 13c | 7.9c | 29.8b | 7.3a | 24.6b | 3.0c | 12.9a | 7.3a | 23.2b | ||
2015 | SH | 19.0a | 8.4a | 3.6a | 31a | 36.7a | 27.5a | 3.7a | 29.8a | 19.7a | 8.8a | 3.7a | 32.2a | |
ONM | 17.9a | 7.9a | 0.0c | 25.8b | 35.9a | 26.4a | 0.0c | 26.4b | 19.0a | 8.4b | 0.0c | 27.4b | ||
FP | 8.8b | 6.0b | 1.2b | 16c | 25.0b | 26.3a | 1.9b | 21.8c | 13.2b | 9.1a | 1.9b | 24.2c | ||
K | 2014 | SH | 24.8a | 24.7a | 0.7a | 50.2a | 18.7a | 36.8a | 1.3c | 23.3a | 42.6a | 42.5b | 1.3b | 86.4a |
ONM | 19.4b | 21.8b | 0.8a | 42b | 15.2b | 34.9a | 1.5b | 20.4b | 37.5b | 42.0b | 1.5b | 81.0b | ||
FP | 8.8c | 15.9c | 0.7a | 25.4c | 10.7c | 31.8b | 2.0a | 17.4c | 24.6c | 44.3a | 2.0a | 70.9c | ||
2015 | SH | 29.0a | 25.7a | − 3.6b | 51.1a | 19.4a | 36.6a | − 6.1b | 20.4a | 48.6a | 43.1a | − 6.1b | 85.6a | |
ONM | 25.2b | 21.4b | − 3.3b | 43.3b | 18.5a | 34.6b | − 6.1b | 19.4a | 46.4b | 39.5b | − 6.1b | 79.8b | ||
FP | 13.5c | 15.8c | − 0.1a | 29.2c | 13.4b | 33.5b | − 0.4a | 16.9b | 35.1c | 40.9b | − 0.4a | 75.6c | ||