Table 1 Normalization methods and grey level discretization applied in recent radiomics studies dedicated to brain tumors.

From: Standardization of brain MR images across machines and protocols: bridging the gap for MRI-based radiomics

References

Multicenter

Number of patients

MRI sequences

Normalization technique

Grey-level discretization

Radiomics software

Features

Objective

Su et al.15

No

100

T2w-flair

Pyradiomics

18 first-order, 13 shape, 54 texture

Investigate the feasibility of predicting H3 K27M mutation status by applying an automated machine learning approach to the MR radiomics features of patients with midline gliomas

Liu et al.16

Yes

130

T1w, T2w-fl1air

ComBat

Artificial Intelligence Kit (GE)

First-order, texture

Develop and validate a model that can be used to predict the individualized treatment response in children with cerebral palsy

Bologna et al.17

Phantom

T1w, T2w

Z-Score

32 FBN

Pyradiomics

18 first-order, 14 shape, 75 texture

Analysis of virtual phantom for preprocessing evaluation and detection of a robust feature set for MRI-radiomics of the brain

Elsheikh et al.18

Yes

135

T1w, T1w-gd, T2w, T2w-flair

First-order, texture

Analysis of multi-stage association of glioblastoma gene expressions with texture and spatial patterns

Tixier et al.19

Yes

90

T1w-gd, T2w-flair

128 FBN

CERR

72 features (first-order, texture, shape)

Study the impact of tumor segmentation variability on the robustness of MRI radiomics features

Ortiz-Ramón et al.20

No

200

T1w, T2w, T2w-flair

32 FBN

MATLAB

114 textures

Identify the presence of ischaemic stroke lesions by means of texture analysis on brain MRI

Vamvakas et al.21

No

40

T1w, T1w-gd, T2w, T2w-flair

MATLAB

11 first-order, 16 texture

Investigate the value of advanced multiparametric MRI biomarker analysis based on radiomics features and machine learning classification for glioma grading

Tixier et al.22

Yes

159

T1w, T1w-gd, T2w-flair

128 FBN

CERR

286 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Evaluate the capacity of radiomics features to add complementary information to MGMT status, to improve the ability to predict prognosis

Wu et al.23

Yes

126

T1w, T1w-gd, T2w, T2w-flair

704 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Identify the optimal radiomics-based machine learning method for isocitrate dehydrogenase genotype prediction in diffuse gliomas

Artzi et al.24

No

439

T1w-gd

WhiteStripe

MATLAB

757 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Differentiate between glioblastoma and brain metastasis subtypes using radiomics analysis

Kniep et al.25

No

189

T1w, T1w-gd, T2w-flair

WhiteStripe

Pyradiomics

18 first-order, 17 shape, 56 texture

Investigate the feasibility of tumor type prediction with MRI radiomics image features of different brain metastases in a multiclass machine learning approach for patients with unknown primary lesion at the time of diagnosis

Sanghani et al.26

Yes

163

T1w, T1w-gd, T2w, T2w-flair

Pyradiomics

2200 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Predict overall survival in glioblastoma multiforme patients from volumetric, shape and texture features using machine learning

Liu et al.27

Yes

84

T2w

Z-Score

MATLAB

131 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Develop a radiomics signature for prediction of progression-free survival (PFS) in lower-grade gliomas and investigate the genetic background behind the radiomics signature

Peng et al.28

No

66

T1w-gd, T2w-flair

64 FBN

MATLAB

51 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Distinguish true progression from radionecrosis after stereotactic radiation therapy for brain metastases with machine learning and radiomics

Bae et al.29

No

217

T1w-gd, T2w-flair

WhiteStripe

Pyradiomics

796 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Investigate whether radiomics features based on MRI improve survival prediction in patients with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) when they are integrated with clinical and genetic profiles

Chen et al.30

Yes

220

T1w, T1w-gd, T2w, T2w-flair

Nyul

Pyradiomics

420 features (first-order, shape, texture)

Classify gliomas combining automatic segmentation and radiomics