Table 3 Metamaterial sensor application and sensing method comparison other than open-ended coaxial probe.

From: SNG and DNG meta-absorber with fractional absorption band for sensing application

Ref. paper

Method

Key parameter identification

MUT

Method accuracy

Remarks

48

TRL

Complex permittivity (ε) and permeability (µ)

Low loss sample

Medium good

Robust algorithm can improve results

42

Resonant

S21 resonance shifting is the critical point

Methanol–water and ethanol–water

Very good

detection of fluidics

44

FSM

S21 resonance shifting is the critical point

NaCl and C2H4O2 substances

Medium good

impurities level identity

45

Resonant

S21 resonance shifting is the critical point

Oil, methanol, glycerol and water

Very good

Dielectric properties

43

TRL

Determination of permittivity

Microfluid

Medium good

Phase shift method for calculation