Table 2 Table of the critique of the literature.
From: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the hip capsule innervation and its clinical implications
Paper | Prospective or retrospective study | Clearly defined sample (e.g., age, sex, side) | Cadavers excluded with reasons | Study type (e.g., formalin, fresh-frozen) | Use of magnification during dissection | Replicable and clearly defined methodology | Clearly defined outcomes and results | Clear diagrams and images to display the results | Justified interpretation of the results and concise conclusion | Clearly state limitations or bias of research |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Berhanu et al. (2020)71 | P | Y | N | Embalmed | N | Y | Y | Y | Y | N |
Nielsen et al. 201866 | P | Y | N | Ethanol- glycerol and phenolic acid | NS | Y | Y | N | U | Y |
Sakamoto et al. 201864 | P | Y | N | Embalmed | NS | Y | Y | N | Y | Y |
Short et al. 201867 | P | Y | Y | 12 formalin and 1 light embalm | NS | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Nielsen et al. 201768 | P | Y | N | Ethanol- glycerol and phenolic acid | NS | Y | Y | N | U | Y |
Turgut et al. 201780 | P | Y | N | Fresh frozen | NS | Y | Y | Y | U | N |
Sakamoto et al. 201465 | P | N | N | Formalin | NS | N | N | N | U | Y |
Rohini et al. 201281 | R | N | N | NS | NS | Y | Y | N | U | N |
Anagnostopoulou et al. 200982 | P | Y | N | NS | NS | Y | Y | N | Y | N |
Anloague and Hijbregts 200970 | P | Y | Y | Embalmed | NS | Y | U | N | Y | Y |
Apaydin et al. 200973 | P | Y | Y | NS | NS | Y | N | N | U | N |
Locher 200869 | P | Y | N | Embalmed | Y | Y | Y | U | Y | N |
Kampa et al. 200783 | P | Y | N | Formalin | NS | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y |
Birnbaum et al. 200074 | R | Y | N | NS | NS | N | Y | N | U | N |
Tubbs et al. 200384 | P | Y | Y | Formalin | NS | Y | Y | N | U | N |
Birnbaum et al. 199776 | P | N | N | Formalin | Y | N | Y | Y | Y | N |
Aizawa 199275 | P | N | N | NS | Y | N | N | N | U | N |
Katrisis 198085 | P | N | N | Embalmed | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Dee 196978 | P | N | N | Fresh | Y | N | N | N | U | N |
Moghaddam 196259 | P | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Poláček 196360 | P | Y | N | NS | Y | N | N | Y | U | N |
Woodburne 196086 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Poláček 195863 | P | N | N | NS | NS | N | Y | N | U | N |
Wertheimer 195277 | P | N | N | Formalin | Y | N | Y | Y | Y | N |
Gardner et al. 194887 | P | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | Y | U | N |
Kaiser 194979 | P | N | N | NS | NS | N | Y | Y | U | N |
Poulhés 194958 | R | N | N | NS | Y | N | N | Y | U | N |
Tavernier and Pellanda 194956 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Kaplan 194872 | P | N | N | NS | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | N |
Billet et al. 194757 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | N | N |
Sadovsky 193362 | P | Y | N | NS | NS | Y | Y | N | U | N |
Jamieson 190388 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Paterson 189189 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Chandelux 188655 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Duzéa 188654 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
Meyer 185761 | R | N | N | NS | NS | N | N | N | U | N |
