Table 7 Performance of SAP, OPUS-TASS, SPOT-1D, and SPIDER2 when our testing proteins are grouped based on their lengths. In the table, ΔMAE of a system (e.g. OPUS-TASS, SPOT-1D or SPIDER2) is its MAE minus the MAE of SAP. As such, the greater the value of ΔMAE, the worse the performance of the system w.r.t. the performance of SAP. The horizontal lines in SAP columns split those columns such that the upper parts have MAE values less than the overall MAE values and the lower parts have MAE values greater (a slight exception for θ).
Testing proteins | Φ | ψ | θ | τ | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SAP | OPUS- TASS | SPOT-1D | SPIDER2 | SAP | OPUS-TASS | SPOT-1D | SPIDER2 | SAP | SPOT-1D | SPIDER2 | SAP | SPOT-1D | SPIDER2 | ||
Length | Count | MAE | ∆MAE | ∆MAE | ∆MAE | MAE | ∆MAE | ∆MAE | ∆MAE | MAE | ∆MAE | ∆MAE | MAE | ∆MAE | ∆MAE |
001–100 | 210 | 14.43 | + 0.14 | + 0.34 | + 2.75 | 13.19 | + 7.84 | + 8.02 | + 13.53 | 5.63 | + 0.36 | + 1.61 | 15.19 | + 5.52 | + 11.55 |
101–200 | 381 | 15.33 | + 0.06 | + 0.35 | + 2.93 | 13.73 | + 7.94 | + 8.43 | + 14.77 | 6.09 | + 0.47 | + 1.82 | 16.54 | + 6.44 | + 13.42 |
201–300 | 264 | 15.21 | + 0.28 | + 0.56 | + 3.03 | 13.94 | + 8.01 | + 8.59 | + 14.99 | 5.96 | + 0.67 | + 1.93 | 16.25 | + 7.35 | + 14.46 |
301–400 | 180 | 15.73 | − 0.26 | + 0.26 | + 3.36 | 14.29 | + 7.35 | + 8.30 | + 15.85 | 6.11 | + 0.57 | + 2.07 | 17.12 | + 7.08 | + 15.27 |
401–500 | 102 | 16.03 | + 0.37 | + 0.79 | + 3.44 | 14.70 | + 9.04 | + 9.45 | + 16.97 | 6.09 | + 0.81 | + 2.27 | 17.27 | + 8.33 | + 16.32 |
501–800 | 69 | 16.49 | + 0.28 | + 0.77 | + 3.25 | 15.22 | + 9.17 | + 10.21 | + 17.07 | 6.29 | + 0.86 | + 2.17 | 17.97 | + 9.15 | + 16.33 |
Overall | 1206 | 15.62 | + 0.12 | + 0.41 | + 2.90 | 14.23 | + 8.18 | + 8.69 | + 15.32 | 6.07 | + 0.54 | + 1.87 | 16.85 | + 7.17 | + 14.39 |